[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Kagu Nyan]

Agreed, feels like she is trying to blend in and then made a post about wanting to read/know what neeko and chevy are talking about which feels forced.

Dude.. that wasn't about Neeko and Chevy. It was in response to Pero calling me scum.

 

[Charlie]

But if you feel Neeko was pushy on Cal, how would I be the first person to "push" another player? I don't mean to be locked on here, it just doesn't make sense and you're doubling down on it which confuses me more.

Honestly, before that post I didn't think focus that much on cal.

Has he? I disagree.

Attempting to lead based on behavioural play would be making reads based on behavioural play opposed to just asking others to make reads on behavioural play and not lean into theme speculation. There is a difference my friend!

I don't understand why you wouldn't challenge someone early in the game thread. How else do you plan to generate reads if not by prodding and asking questions!

Yeah, the wild woman just gifted you +1 vote power as well as a bonus roll to your consitution check.

Giving me extra vote power never ends up well

 

[Peroroncino]

What are your reads so far.

Neeko vs chevy looked like TvT to me but i never played with them so im going on gut feeling here.
Same with Michelle.
Way too early to make an opinion.

 

[Fujishiro]

So far I dont find Kagu scummy, the opposite really. She's pretty clumsy and I associate that with her town self. @Peroroncino @Arp Bladstrum and others played with her there when she was town, would you say she's acting similarly here?

In the last game she was more careful with what she was saying I felt.

 

[Neeko]

So you dont town lean on SK but asked him to join you on an arp push?

Of course!

I mean it was SK who said the post felt fake, why wouldn't I ask him? Not to mention if I only asked people I town lean to vote on a push we would never get many votes considering the stage of the game we're at and the amount needed for a proper push and then even more for a lynch.

Do you only ask those you town lean to vote with you?

its Majority Lynch (ironically thats what Ripped was pointing out originally that I thanked him for) votes here and there can cause the wrong person to get lynched if theyre on the board, Im not overly worried about a single vote but day ends the second a majority is reached and a single vote can fuck everything.

I understand how majority lynch works, hence my confusion. It takes 17 votes for a lynch, you're nowhere near danger yet the reaction was quite strong.

Could you clarify why my vote and post felt untowny to you? I'm very excited to know why!

 

[Peroroncino]

There's plenty of people here you can read let's leave excuses out of this

I said im gonna have a hard time reading them not that im not gonna do it.

 

[Fujishiro]

Neeko vs chevy looked like TvT to me but i never played with them so im going on gut feeling here.
Same with Michelle.
Way too early to make an opinion.

How do you read Arp/Kagura/Neeko.

 

[Kagu Nyan]

Vote Kagurashii

What's wrong?

 

[Michelle]

A vote count would be cool

 

[DoflaMihawk]

Hello

 

[Michelle]

What's wrong?

Your approach to TAC regardless his alignament

 

[RippedCal]

I said im gonna have a hard time reading them not that im not gonna do it.

The idea that you are setting up failure was the prevalent theme I took from your post whether you plan on reading people is irrelevant to the Ripped one

 

[Neeko]

Honestly, before that post I didn't think focus that much on cal.




Giving me extra vote power never ends up well

Hi Charlie, do you have any thoughts outside of myself and Chevy since that post since other things have been happening?

 

[Peroroncino]

How do you read Arp/Kagura/Neeko.

All look null to me except for neeko who looks townish but maybe he planned that with his scum buddy, i can see that happening too.

 

[Fujishiro]

Of course!

I mean it was SK who said the post felt fake, why wouldn't I ask him? Not to mention if I only asked people I town lean to vote on a push we would never get many votes considering the stage of the game we're at and the amount needed for a proper push and then even more for a lynch.

Do you only ask those you town lean to vote with you?




I understand how majority lynch works, hence my confusion. It takes 17 votes for a lynch, you're nowhere near danger yet the reaction was quite strong.

Could you clarify why my vote and post felt untowny to you? I'm very excited to know why!

Well no but Id usually try to start a push with those I feel more comfortable with, its just an unconscious thing tbh. I feel like most townies would feel/act the same.

17 majority lynch and with 32 players Id say there is 18-19 town so I guess you're right in a way.

 

[Arp Bladstrum]

I didn't read anything from day 1 of that game and that was a while ago if it did happen as you claimed, but why are you using this as an example? I don't really care what happened in previous games, focusing on the game at hand is the best approach.

But, I didn't see any softclaim attempt from her, her vibe and way she playing seems forced/fake.

ngl weird post from you arp, like by weird I mean the way you are approaching this.

Day 1 The Lich King outed themselves in the WoTLK game, In this thread it was a post about having a secret chat and I reference that game as it the only other game Ive actually played in full and recent enough that others will remember.

Why is it a weird way of approaching it? I asked the question do you think that the talk of a secret chat was a very early slip or attempt at open scum, which you answered.

 

[Fujishiro]

Fuji pls stop changing the avas you confuse me! Thanks!

The north is free, you can't chain me down.

 

[Peroroncino]

The idea that you are setting up failure was the prevalent theme I took from your post whether you plan on reading people is irrelevant to the Ripped one

This looks like town paranoia to me i'll give you a townread for now.

 

[Fujishiro]

Day 1 The Lich King outed themselves in the WoTLK game, In this thread it was a post about having a secret chat and I reference that game as it the only other game Ive actually played in full and recent enough that others will remember.

Why is it a weird way of approaching it? I asked the question do you think that the talk of a secret chat was a very early slip or attempt at open scum, which you answered.

My game was wilder than this one Id wager, the LK was death immune to mostly everything bar TAC/Tirion or if you found his phylactery.

 

[Michelle]

The north is free, you can't chain me down.

It's a kind request :cheers: