[FNZ] Role Madness Game 03: One Piece Dressrosa

[Finalbeta]

Guys it is clear we can't afford a mislynch

We have 8 players in the pot with 5 being town and 3 mafia most likely

If we mislynch mafia will likely win the game by tonight

Be careful

 

[AL sama]

Guys it is clear we can't afford a mislynch

We have 8 players in the pot with 5 being town and 3 mafia most likely

If we mislynch mafia will likely win the game by tonight

Be careful

another wild guess huh

5 mafias in a normal 16 players role madness is too much

 

[Finalbeta]

another wild guess huh

5 mafias in a normal 16 players role madness is too much

What makes me believe that is the fact we got 3 factions and we also got an indie

It is pretty common and solid to assume each one is composed by 5 members don't you think?

 

[AL sama]

What makes me believe that is the fact we got 3 factions and we also got an indie

It is pretty common and solid to assume each one is composed by 5 members don't you think?

I m far more experienced as a host beta and its too much for there to be a 5 men mafia team in a game this size

 

[Bogard]

What makes me believe that is the fact we got 3 factions and we also got an indie

It is pretty common and solid to assume each one is composed by 5 members don't you think?

There was only one kill this night as opposed to previous night where someone gained the mera, so i think there is probably only one scum left. Maybe there is another indie tho

 

[Finalbeta]

I m far more experienced as a host beta and its too much for there to be a 5 men mafia team in a game this size

It's either that or 5-5-4-2

4 mafia and 2 indies

I can't see anything different at this point

 

[AL sama]

also executives and originals are both town so that basically means 1 faction not 2

 

[Finalbeta]

There was only one kill this night as opposed to previous night where someone gained the mera, so i think there is probably only one scum left. Maybe there is another indie tho

But scum isn't defined just by kills. Some scum roles don't kill.

 

[Finalbeta]

also executives and originals are both town so that basically means 1 faction not 2

Yes this is what I obviously mean but technically they still make groups if we don't want to call them factions

I think it's pretty logical to say each has 5 members no?

 

[AL sama]

4 mafia and 2 indies

now this is possible

but we saw 2 kills only once so far

 

[Finalbeta]

now this is possible

but we saw 2 kills only once so far

I guess the other indie could be a non killing role and that second kill was provived by the mera usage

 

[AL sama]

I think it's pretty logical to say each has 5 members no?

nope that'd be too much

 

[AL sama]

I guess the other indie could be a non killing role and that second kill was provived by the mera usage

s
possible

 

[Bogard]

But scum isn't defined just by kills. Some scum roles don't kill.

Sure but TAC's role was revealed and there were no mention of killing in his abilities, so i think. So i think even after he died, the remaining scum(s) who killed in night phase 2 should have been able to do the same in night phase 3 unless he/they were unable to do it this time for one reason or another, maybe due to mera being a one shot ability

 

[Sentinel]

I vote Finalbeta

Imo Reborn is right about Finalbeta; the latter accused him several times and only voted at last for TAC yesterday. And even then, Final still accuses Reborn being a maf.
If Final isn't a scum, his play would still help the scums.

But @Reborn: What do you think about the users voting for you yesterday?

 

[Finalbeta]

I vote Finalbeta

Imo Reborn is right about Finalbeta; the latter accused him several times and only voted at last for TAC yesterday. And even then, Final still accuses Reborn being a maf.
If Final isn't a scum, his play would still help the scums.

But @Reborn: What do you think about the users voting for you yesterday?

But I mentioned I would have kept suspecting Reborn even if TAC ended up scum.

I sticked with my line of thought overall.

 

[AL sama]

Sure but TAC's role was revealed and there were no mention of killing in his abilities, so i think. So i think even after he died, the remaining scum(s) who killed in night phase 2 should have been able to do the same in night phase 3 unless he/they were unable to do it this time for one reason or another, maybe due to mera being a one shot ability

um mafia having faction kill is the most common thing

 

[Bogard]

um mafia having faction kill is the most common thing

Sure but in that case the faction kill would be given to the entire group, right? And in that case only giving mafia the ability to kill one person each nights, which happened in all nights thus far except the second one where someone gained the mera

 

[Finalbeta]

Guys I feel Denim provided no fake claims to the mafia faction because TAC didn't reveal character while Rej only claimed Trebol because his abilities in Cavendish were fitting such claim.

At the same time I feel Flower's role wasn't discovered because Rej could have used it instead of that flimsy and risky Trebol claim.

At this rate if I'm correct Reborn, Kiwi and Jew are supposed to compose the remaining anti-towns.

Simply because they never claimed so far.

I would like they to do as much to see if we can catch liars. Reborn won't it seems.

 

[NeutralWatcher]

Guys I feel Denim provided no fake claims to the mafia faction because TAC didn't reveal character while Rej only claimed Trebol because his abilities in Cavendish were fitting such claim.

At the same time I feel Flower's role wasn't discovered because Rej could have used it instead of that flimsy and risky Trebol claim.

At this rate if I'm correct Reborn, Kiwi and Jew are supposed to compose the remaining anti-towns.

Simply because they never claimed so far.

I would like they to do as much to see if we can catch liars. Reborn won't it seems.

Different time zone for Kiwi and Jew. Kiwi joined on day 3. It is 18:25 est in Canada so Kiwi Didn't active makes sense and Jew is usually active around 19:00. Jew is also new so I doubt he knows he should claim.