[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[WakandaForever]

Wakanda you want to lynch anyone except you, this is scum mindset
You don't want to point to a scum read you have, you just want to survive

You're purposefully pulling this out of context though. My exact statement was "while obviously i'd like not to get lynched as I know I'm town, I don't think Cooler offers much more.

It was effectively me saying I'm not necessarily excited about a Cooler lynch, but it would still be better than me from my own perspective.

I have very clearly pointed to my preferred choice, which is Pero based on the fact that our claims don't mesh (and the fact that I was suss on him before he claimed).

If you read back on my posts you'll see my argumentation that both him and Melkor squirmed when linked which I didn't like at all, both acted suss, and now this tips it for me for Pero.

Hmmm mm mm. Would have felt better about the claim if you were. Like Arya, probably not worth gambling on a lynch here, but I want it noted that I feel like from my own role your claim would make more sense if Robb was King in the North.

I stand by exactly what I said - nothing more I can do there.

The idea of longevity is true, but also not a home run if pero was the lynch, it's a big game that will likely have crossover.

Surviving one phase could make a big difference and things can change at night

I understand that, but do you think I would stand a better chance of surviving by claiming unkillable than if I had excluded that from a hypothetical fake claim? I really don't think I would. (This dips into WIFOM but meh)

 

[T-Pein™]

You don't want to point to a scum read you have, you just want to survive

I think that in this format we just need a lynch rather than none.

 

[Michelle]

I have very clearly pointed to my preferred choice, which is Pero based on the fact that our claims don't mesh (and the fact that I was suss on him before he claimed)

This is interesting

 

[RippedCal]

You're purposefully pulling this out of context though. My exact statement was "while obviously i'd like not to get lynched as I know I'm town, I don't think Cooler offers much more.

It was effectively me saying I'm not necessarily excited about a Cooler lynch, but it would still be better than me from my own perspective.

I have very clearly pointed to my preferred choice, which is Pero based on the fact that our claims don't mesh (and the fact that I was suss on him before he claimed).

If you read back on my posts you'll see my argumentation that both him and Melkor squirmed when linked which I didn't like at all, both acted suss, and now this tips it for me for Pero.



I stand by exactly what I said - nothing more I can do there.



I understand that, but do you think I would stand a better chance of surviving by claiming unkillable than if I had excluded that from a hypothetical fake claim? I really don't think I would. (This dips into WIFOM but meh)

Not particularly but you need to understand your use of it in your defense to point the finger at Pero suggests you did think that.

 

[Emil]

U r a show-only secondary. Any flavour knowledge you could have is undermined by a lack of context from the books. I don't just underestimate your flavour knowledge, I am dismissing it.

gram is basing the game over both book and show. certain elements r the same for both, including potentially what ur alluding at

book and show are only different like season 5 on ward. before then they r fairly on the same page, with few nitpickings maybe being different

 

[T-Pein™]

U r a show-only secondary. Any flavour knowledge you could have is undermined by a lack of context from the books. I don't just underestimate your flavour knowledge, I am dismissing it.

stop being a book elitist

 

[Emil]

@WakandaForever this is a 32 player game, in comparison to the usual 15ish player games that u play, its possible for 2 townies to have some protections

is ur entire reasoning for suspecting pero the fact that hes tanky?

 

[T-Pein™]

@WakandaForever this is a 32 player game, in comparison to the usual 15ish player games that u play, its possible for 2 townies to have some protections

is ur entire reasoning for suspecting pero the fact that hes tanky?

so we staying on cooler or what?
Its about bedtime for me.

 

[KWEH]

Care to give reasons for strong town leans on Michelle and Hime? They might have escape my attention.

They both seem consistently solvy without much of an agenda that I can detect

 

[Michelle]

I see how the thread is more animated by the Wakanda wagon than before when on the chopping block were Pero and Ekko

It's this because of the short time until Eod?

 

[KWEH]

I'm not gonna be able to catch up on 30 pages before EoD btw

What are the options?

 

[Emil]

so we staying on cooler or what?
Its about bedtime for me.

i am
doesnt seem like anyone is convinced

 

[hime]

hmm a bit over an hour left

not sure how thisll turn out tbh, all ik is that if wakanda is lynched and flips town then chevy and pero should be examined/lynched next imo

 

[Tyler Herro]

iffy on pero, kagura and Ratchet

 

[RippedCal]

I'm not gonna be able to catch up on 30 pages before EoD btw

What are the options?

Pero/Wakanda/no lynch

 

[Tyler Herro]

I’ll vote Wakanda as we need a flip

 

[RippedCal]

Someone mass tag pls

Townie points on offer

 

[Emil]

I see how the thread is more animated by the Wakanda wagon than before when on the chopping block were Pero and Ekko

It's this because of the short time until Eod?

i was never really a "wagon"

and yeah, time is ticking, and with it people post more

 

[Michelle]

iffy on pero, kagura and Ratchet

That's your 3rd post in this game!

Explain please

 

[Ratchet]

iffy on pero, kagura and Ratchet

Is is because I said you were overrated?