General Queries and issues with how Mafia section operates

[T-Pein™]

First of all, every situation is specific. Second of all, when we punish one person in a fight with a ban, we also punish the other because it takes two to tango.

Water under the bridge Pein

Nah.
There was no tango.
He said slurs.
Told him to stop.
He said many more slurs
I get banned.

*eyeroll

 

[Zemmi]

I'm not a coach anymore.

I have no interest in returning to mafia at any point.

I just pop in here and there and give advice on how I handled things back during my time that worked well and made the section function well.

 

[Mashiro Blue]

I believe I don't have much to say about this subject.

Coaches are useful for hosts without much experience.

As for the punishment role I *guess* hosts could forbid people from playing but it wouldn't really effective imo since "what someone does in someone's else house is not my problem"

All in all I have no issue with the way things are or any changes that may occur as of now.

 

[Natalija]

Drago is the only one left, Al left. Regardless id like it if the deciding power wasnt in the hands of one or two people regarding serious matters like that so elective a body seems better to me, and if a few members of said body arent deemed as just they can always be replaced.

Al didn't leave

Nah, elective body is totally unnecessary, this isn't a congress, it's a manga forum and there's no need to complicate things.

 

[Noctis]

Drago is the only one left, Al left. Regardless id like it if the deciding power wasnt in the hands of one or two people regarding serious matters like that so elective a body seems better to me, and if a few members of said body arent deemed as just they can always be replaced.

This is what actually happens, we take the opinion of all coaches(and we are like 6 of us), make consensus and then issue the action.

 

[Fujishiro]

Al didn't leave

Nah, elective body is totally unnecessary, this isn't a congress, it's a manga forum and there's no need to complicate things.

The mafia section is different from a manga forum as all users are interracting with each other in a deeper manner so a tribunal of sorts would work and would be welcome.

I thought Al left lmfao? He said so himself.

 

[T-Pein™]

I believe I don't have much to say about this subject.

Coaches are useful for hosts without much experience.

As for the punishment role I *guess* hosts could forbid people from playing but it wouldn't really effective imo since "what someone does in someone's else house is not my problem"

All in all I have no issue with the way things are or any changes that may occur as of now.

I think hosts and not coaches should be the ones banning people
Like if you dont want Joygirl in your game then fine.
Your decision.
But what if I want mid or Joygirl in my game?
Why do 5 people get to choose?

 

[Fujishiro]

This is what actually happens, we take the opinion of all coaches(and we are like 6 of us), make consensus and then issue the action.

The coaches werent elected and we cant replace them as they are needed to help new hosts.

 

[Noctis]

Al didn't leave

Nah, elective body is totally unnecessary, this isn't a congress, it's a manga forum and there's no need to complicate things.

To counter your this point, these games have nothing to do with manga, they are there separate entities

 

[Emil]

Thirded
Also.
Unban my boy mid

#freemidmight

 

[Zemmi]

This is what actually happens, we take the opinion of all coaches(and we are like 6 of us), make consensus and then issue the action.

More or less this is how it works.

Things are discussed everyone adds there opinion, the final call is basically on Drago and use to be Al, not sure he says he isn't but he is but he isn't who knows. The only time I think an issue with the coaches have been an issue is when Drago and Al both had different opinions on how to proceed and sides were taken on the course of action, I think that is the only sway that has happened from coaches overall. Other times it was more a complete consensus when something was done.

 

[Noctis]

The coaches werent elected and we cant replace them as they are needed to help new hosts.

Oh, we will note that down, if more players agree we can consider that

 

[Fujishiro]

Imo the mods can be a part of the tribunal and even have a vero power just in case but the idea is fine and should be done.

Players are more likely to accept rulings and punishments from people that were elected to those positions anyways.

 

[T-Pein™]

Imo the mods can be a part of the tribunal and even have a vero power just in case but the idea is fine and should be done.

Players are more likely to accept rulings and punishments from people that were elected to those positions anyways.

We do not need a wg government lol

 

[Natalija]

The mafia section is different from a manga forum as all users are interracting with each other in a deeper manner so a tribunal of sorts would work and would be welcome.

I thought Al left lmfao? He said so himself.

No, AL didn't leave.

To counter your this point, these games have nothing to do with manga, they are there separate entities

What does that have to do with anything? I meant to say it isn't that serious to have a tribunal and high court, it's just games lol

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I nominate @Worst to head the new mafia illuminati tribunal.

 

[Mashiro Blue]

Tbh It's like a paradox

In Narutoforums where the modding is much more strict the Mafia section has more freedom.

In here it's the opposite.

Quite interesting.

 

[T-Pein™]

Ekko not being an "approved host" is blasphemous

 

[Natalija]

We do not need a wg government lol

Exactly, free the people!

Tbh It's like a paradox

In Narutoforums where the modding is much more strict the Mafia section has more freedom.

In here it's the opposite.

Quite interesting.

I know, it's literal insanity

 

[Fujishiro]

We do not need a wg government lol

It already exists, its called Bogard and his mods.

This isnt a government its a tribunal, say a player repeatedly fucks up games, he gets reported and the tribunal handles his case if his actions are within the confines of mafia. Drago can be apart of said tribunal and egen have a veto but i feel like people would be more receptive to punishments if they are handed out by a group of people players choose to be there.

Just my 2 cents.