[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Ratchet]

phoenix is the towniest there

ytw and neeko toss ups
ytw self resolves
neeko is an already claimed scum. take his slot with grain of salt

Can you explain to me how YTW "self-resolves" here?

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Wasn't it Tyrion who did most of the work?

Tyrion did most of the work at the start but then Stannis was kicking too much ass anyway until Tywin brought the Tyrells in and saved the day.

 

[Emil]

It's a shame, show had some good moments. Everything Season 5 onwards just goes into the gutter.

Might carry on with the books again, just got DWD left.

season 6 was actually good
5 7 and 8 just ugh
peaked s4

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Which direction for this btw?

Still want to know this @Ratchet

 

[Emil]

Can you explain to me how YTW "self-resolves" here?

he will either get shot or catch scum. id assume he only got 2 shots left max cuz winter is coming
keeping him around is nice to keep mafia wifoming who he is watching

im more concerned as to why kweh is still alive

red already had the tracker. i hope the watcher is town

kweh is joat and could be anything. idk why r they leaving him alive yet

 

[Zolo]

im not filthy indie , I kill them

 

[Ratchet]

Still want to know this @Ratchet

If Melkor red it looks bad on Cal. I can get some quotes, but on several instances I noticed he was trying to make the lynches a toss up (some people threw my name around half-seriously, Cal immediately says the lynch is between Melkor and myself), he couches several of his arguments against me as "his slot is disruptive, even if he's town" which struck me as giving himself wiggle room afterwards. I don't know if I'd say Cal must be red, but it definitely seemed to me that Cal wanted Melkor to live the day, which even non-red scum would want. Plus we have him attempting to take the credit for Pero, proclaiming that he's confirmed town, and he's still talking about this merger which makes no sense to even exist here.

 

[Ratchet]

he will either get shot or catch scum. id assume he only got 2 shots left max cuz winter is coming
keeping him around is nice to keep mafia wifoming who he is watching

im more concerned as to why kweh is still alive

red already had the tracker. i hope the watcher is town

kweh is joat and could be anything. idk why r they leaving him alive yet

Please read the posts I'm making towards you. YTW says his main ability is done, 3-shots, like most power roles here. We aren't getting any more watcher results from him unless he gets refilled.

 

[Emil]

He says his ability is spent. Like most "power roles", he's claiming 3-shot Watcher. That's what we're getting.

just saw this now
welp
cant self resolve then lmao
back to indie box he goes

 

[Dr_Professor83]

If Melkor red it looks bad on Cal. I can get some quotes, but on several instances I noticed he was trying to make the lynches a toss up (some people threw my name around half-seriously, Cal immediately says the lynch is between Melkor and myself), he couches several of his arguments against me as "his slot is disruptive, even if he's town" which struck me as giving himself wiggle room afterwards. I don't know if I'd say Cal must be red, but it definitely seemed to me that Cal wanted Melkor to live the day, which even non-red scum would want. Plus we have him attempting to take the credit for Pero, proclaiming that he's confirmed town, and he's still talking about this merger which makes no sense to even exist here.

I remember him being weird around Melkor when he first claimed and we were doubting his alert townie claim. Probably go back and look at that with fresh eyes.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Cal has been after Lethal for a minute now.

 

[Ratchet]

I remember him being weird around Melkor when he first claimed and we were doubting his alert townie claim. Probably go back and look at that with fresh eyes.

His posts around that are fine, from what I recall. It was really only last DP. I could see him being Indie too, maybe even most plausibly.

 

[Emil]

If Melkor red it looks bad on Cal. I can get some quotes, but on several instances I noticed he was trying to make the lynches a toss up (some people threw my name around half-seriously, Cal immediately says the lynch is between Melkor and myself), he couches several of his arguments against me as "his slot is disruptive, even if he's town" which struck me as giving himself wiggle room afterwards. I don't know if I'd say Cal must be red, but it definitely seemed to me that Cal wanted Melkor to live the day, which even non-red scum would want. Plus we have him attempting to take the credit for Pero, proclaiming that he's confirmed town, and he's still talking about this merger which makes no sense to even exist here.

u can say the same for neeko pretty much
dont feel any fire from him against red
doesnt seem happy with red getting rekt

 

[Emil]

wait ratchet and prof have all of us ever being town in a game b4?

i dont wanna jinx it

but is this even possible

 

[Dr_Professor83]

His posts around that are fine, from what I recall. It was really only last DP. I could see him being Indie too, maybe even most plausibly.

Vic lol? With his Purple obsession.

 

[Ratchet]

u can say the same for neeko pretty much
dont feel any fire from him against red
doesnt seem happy with red getting rekt

I mostly believe his purple claim. He's not going to endgame anyway, I do think he's lying about elements of his claim. Why does he even need to check for Knights?

 

[Ratchet]

wait ratchet and prof have all of us ever being town in a game b4?

i dont wanna jinx it

but is this even possible

Not that I recall.

Vic lol? With his Purple obsession.

Yeah, agreed.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

wait ratchet and prof have all of us ever being town in a game b4?

i dont wanna jinx it

but is this even possible

Not that I can think of lol.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Vic lol? With his Purple obsession.

Yeah, agreed

@Pot Goblin

 

[Emil]

Not that I recall.

Not that I can think of lol.

whose the imposter then? ik it aint me