[FNZ] Role Madness A Song of Ice and Fire: Game of Thrones Mafia Game Thread

[Emil]

yo tan does not kill broki here because broki wanted to lynch ratchet first

only ratchet benefits from that kill

guys, lets end his misery

@Pot Goblin @Dr_Professor83 @Yo Tan Wa @WakandaForever @Kagurashii

vote lynch ratchet

 

[Emil]

I really thought YTW would end up performing a killing action so now I'm panicking cos I don't understand how it can be you, Ratchet.

But if its not you then Pot's result is concerning.

we lynch ratchet today
if game doesnt end we lynch pot

its all good man

 

[Emil]

wait, that can't be right since there surely can't be cersei and Randyll left for red.

cersei can order randyll
just like how joeffry's role has 2 knights mentioned. heck one of them excecutes for him

 

[Ratchet]

cersei can order randyll
just like how joeffry's role has 2 knights mentioned. heck one of them excecutes for him

Randyll isn't a Knight of the Queensguard.

 

[Emil]

That would mean Randyll started as Town - I hinted at my Hider claim Day 1, and Randyll makes no sense as a Hider. The only other argument I can see here is that I am Cersei, recruited Randyll, and then used his sword to confirm myself.

no it just means its part of your role, like illyn payne is part of joeffrys role

 

[Emil]

Randyll isn't a Knight of the Queensguard.

none cares
he is under cerseis command and is used as a method to facilitate a fake claim here

 

[Emil]

the broki kill was by the textbook kill ratchet does here. it doesnt make sense for yo tan anyway

just by the kill alone i can tell its you

 

[Ratchet]

We also know scum had one sword - why do they need another?

Answer - they don't.

 

[Ratchet]

none cares
he is under cerseis command and is used as a method to facilitate a fake claim here

You don't care, because you've stopped thinking.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Yes, something did.

When I was reading my PM again yesterday , I noticed I made a big mistake.

I misread my abilities - they are Psychologist and 2x Amplifier. I misread this as meaning the Psychologist is a single shot, but it actually means there is no limit.

Therefore I used my Psychologist on YTW yesterday. They did not use a killing action.

Thanks for clearing me, my brother Rob Stark😉

 

[Pot Goblin]

yo tan does not kill broki here because broki wanted to lynch ratchet first

only ratchet benefits from that kill

guys, lets end his misery

@Pot Goblin @Dr_Professor83 @Yo Tan Wa @WakandaForever @Kagurashii

vote lynch ratchet

I will say that I did get Heartsbane last night.
No fancy description or anything just the fact that I recived it.

By the way, I realize this doesn't clear Ratchet as Sam anymore. The other swords we've seen this game I've noticed a trend where the swords begin with the original owners such as how oathkeeper went to Jaime and widows wail went to Joffery.

I look up the original owner of heartsbane and I see that it belonged to Sam Tarly's father first as a family heirloom.

And then I realize that the Tarly house is part of house Lannister. A perfect reason to have Heartsbane. It would be exactly like how Joffery had an ability named after a character. It would fit perfectly in the inconsistencies that Gramm talked about without being bastard. My mistake was assuming that Heartsbane belonged to Sam and Sam only, but looking at the origins tells the truth here. It's not Sam Tarly it's House Tarly who would be Lannister Aligned.


On top of that, Wakanda proved that Yo didn't submit a killing action. Yet someone died. That narrows it down completley.

Ratchet is the lynch today.

 

[WakandaForever]

Thanks for clearing me, my brother Rob Stark😉

You're not technically clear as you could be NK or a second scum but yes it is looking better for you.

 

[WakandaForever]

I will say that I did get Heartsbane last night.
No fancy description or anything just the fact that I recived it.

By the way, I realize this doesn't clear Ratchet as Sam anymore. The other swords we've seen this game I've noticed a trend where the swords begin with the original owners such as how oathkeeper went to Jaime and widows wail went to Joffery.

I look up the original owner of heartsbane and I see that it belonged to Sam Tarly's father first as a family heirloom.

And then I realize that the Tarly house is part of house Lannister. A perfect reason to have Heartsbane. It would be exactly like how Joffery had an ability named after a character. It would fit perfectly in the inconsistencies that Gramm talked about without being bastard. My mistake was assuming that Heartsbane belonged to Sam and Sam only, but looking at the origins tells the truth here. It's not Sam Tarly it's House Tarly who would be Lannister Aligned.


On top of that, Wakanda proved that Yo didn't submit a killing action. Yet someone died. That narrows it down completley.

Ratchet is the lynch today.

Yeah the part about Tarly is what I said earlier too. Randyll Tarly.

Everything except the sword points towards Ratchet here so I definitely think that may be where I end up lynching today.

 

[Ratchet]

I will say that I did get Heartsbane last night.
No fancy description or anything just the fact that I recived it.

By the way, I realize this doesn't clear Ratchet as Sam anymore. The other swords we've seen this game I've noticed a trend where the swords begin with the original owners such as how oathkeeper went to Jaime and widows wail went to Joffery.

I look up the original owner of heartsbane and I see that it belonged to Sam Tarly's father first as a family heirloom.

And then I realize that the Tarly house is part of house Lannister. A perfect reason to have Heartsbane. It would be exactly like how Joffery had an ability named after a character. It would fit perfectly in the inconsistencies that Gramm talked about without being bastard. My mistake was assuming that Heartsbane belonged to Sam and Sam only, but looking at the origins tells the truth here. It's not Sam Tarly it's House Tarly who would be Lannister Aligned.


On top of that, Wakanda proved that Yo didn't submit a killing action. Yet someone died. That narrows it down completley.

Ratchet is the lynch today.

You're just repeating Ekko's nonsense. Cersei having Randyll as an ability doesn't make any sense at all.

 

[WakandaForever]

Do we have anything that actually proves the Night King exists btw? Or are we just speculating?

 

[Ratchet]

Do we have anything that actually proves the Night King exists btw? Or are we just speculating?

Speculation from the existence of the swords.

 

[Ratchet]

With Joffrey having one it's further evidence BTW. Because if they're not used as a confirmation tool, then they serve some other, grander purpose.

 

[Pot Goblin]

You're just repeating Ekko's nonsense. Cersei having Randyll as an ability doesn't make any sense at all.

House Tarly was a huge Lannister ally.
When you flip it's not going to say that the sword is specifically Cerci's, it's going to say it's House Tarly's as one of your abilities.

Not to mention a big reason I was leaning Yo over you other than the sword was the idea of the Night King. And since it's still speculation that the Night King exists compared to how Cerci is now confirmed, and Yo didn't submit a killing action...

It spells bad news for you.

 

[WakandaForever]

Weird that they've not come into play at all then tbh

 

[Pot Goblin]

With Joffrey having one it's further evidence BTW. Because if they're not used as a confirmation tool, then they serve some other, grander purpose.

If they did, something would've happened once Prof got it. Since he's the main owner of Heartsbane.