General & Others Next Strawhat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Guan Yu
- Start date
- Tags #carrot4prison #furries4carrot #larrot #yamato4nakama #yamatofansunite #yamatoisnakama carrot blows cry about carrot furries for nakama furries scurries i need my support carrot body pillow oni princess and the pirate king this thread stupid we're here for jew vs dizzy who wants rabbit stew yamato > carrot yamato best girl yamato finds the one piece yamato hype yamato is the last crew mate
- Status
It's okay it's not necessary to join the crew, only to be recruited. That will happen AFTER Wano.
It's not about mystery, it's about characterization. You will understand that soon enough.
Indeed and those are enough to start her characterization.
It's okay it's not necessary to join the crew, only to be recruited. That will happen AFTER Wano.
Wrong. Those three character did not get an arc revolving around their character but other themes or other characters. They only got a flashback and a centric storyline but not the whole arc. (For jinbe, the flashback wasn't even centered on him.
This was but a part of the arc. Nothing more.
Wrong, Carrot's characterization is worth talking about.
We don't need that.
It's not necessary, everything we need is here. You should read what I write more carefully.
Wrong. Yes it is. What you are looking for is what will happen AFTER Carrot joins the crew, what we have now are the setups, not the actual centering on the character. Don't worry, we have everything we need right now, the rest will come. You are comparing things that are uncomparable. Period.
Not until they were recruted LATER in the story. Never forget that.
Indeed. That's something Carrot don't need, she already knows Luffy.
Indeed, just like carrot in whole cake.
Exactly like Carrot. You are just ignoring the setup concerning this characters. But they are here ;))
Like I said manytime, it's not a regular strawhat story. Carrot's story revolves around her characterization not an arc.
Irrelevant
It's okay. We have enough cahracterization for her to join the crew.
No, it's not a requierement to join the crew.
For good reason, the fight did not matter, only the defeat was important. I won't go back to that, read what I write about the subject.
That will only happen AFTER she joins, she is not a strawhat yet. Those are not requierement to join the crew.
Still not a requierement to join the crew. it's irrelevant. The point of the defeat was for Carrot to experience a set back, there was no reason for a strawhat to help her here. It would have render the scene meaningless, you need to understand that your point does not stand the test of narration.
Wrong. Or more exactly you can't know that.
It's called a setup for a reason.
As I see it, it's preparing Carrot for an introspection so it DOES help her move forward.
Wano is not Carrot's story, it's logical for Oda to push her back.
And that happen in whole cake for Carrot. We are gonna have a problem if you keep ignoring whole cake. Carrot is linked to whole cake, not to Wano. And BOTH ARC are part of the yonko Saga, so BOTH ARC are relevant in that matter. Wake up.
Yamato is treated as an arc character. And there are subversive dialogue showing that the strawhat crew is not her final destination so I won't extend myself on her case, it's done.
Until you understand that both whole cake and wano have to be taken into account, you won't understand why Carrot joined the crew at the end of Wano ;)
That's true, but that's also the last thing she must developp to sail the see, so we can expect it to happen very soon.
Again, you can't know until you see the end of the Saga. ;) So your point is - for the moment - irrelevant.
Wrong, you should try to learn a thing or two about characterization.
In fact Yamato's motivation to sail the sea is for the moment on the same level as Carrot. She has no other reason that being free. So try to avoid comparing those two characters on that front ;)
Wrong, it was managed by herself.
Just like Yamato
And that something that can only happen once the character JOINS the crew.
So this point is irrelevant right now.
Don't try to make Yamato fit that parameter. She does not. Yamato NEVER said that she would improve for Luffy so her place here is completely undeserved. Your argument is irrelevant here.
You need to actually wait for that. This can only happen in a moment of rest. So wait until the end of the arc before concluding anything please ;)
No. Wano is not Carrot's story. I should not expect something that has no place in the story right now.
True, but that was just an hypothesis that could lead to a confirmation, there are still windows for confirmation in the future ;)
No but a good fan should remember what she did in whole cake. Sad thing, you do not, you are therefore not a good fan .. case and point..
That can only happen in a moment of rest. Wait for the end of the arc mate ;)
Wrong, it would be logical with what she did in whole cake. Don't try to find a way to trash Carrot for no reason.
Wano is just a PART of the yonko Saga, what Carrot did in whole cake was MORE THAN ENOUGH for her to join.
It won't be enough for her to be recruited, but that will happen AFTER she joins. But you will have to wait to see that ;)
As always, a lot of text for a lot of nothing.
Same arguments in circle. Same counter argumentation. Nothing here is relevant. wait a little and you will understandjust how wrong you are ;)
It's not about mystery, it's about characterization. You will understand that soon enough.
Indeed and those are enough to start her characterization.
It's okay it's not necessary to join the crew, only to be recruited. That will happen AFTER Wano.
Wrong. Those three character did not get an arc revolving around their character but other themes or other characters. They only got a flashback and a centric storyline but not the whole arc. (For jinbe, the flashback wasn't even centered on him.
This was but a part of the arc. Nothing more.
Wrong, Carrot's characterization is worth talking about.
We don't need that.
It's not necessary, everything we need is here. You should read what I write more carefully.
Wrong. Yes it is. What you are looking for is what will happen AFTER Carrot joins the crew, what we have now are the setups, not the actual centering on the character. Don't worry, we have everything we need right now, the rest will come. You are comparing things that are uncomparable. Period.
Not until they were recruted LATER in the story. Never forget that.
Indeed. That's something Carrot don't need, she already knows Luffy.
Indeed, just like carrot in whole cake.
Exactly like Carrot. You are just ignoring the setup concerning this characters. But they are here ;))
Like I said manytime, it's not a regular strawhat story. Carrot's story revolves around her characterization not an arc.
Irrelevant
It's okay. We have enough cahracterization for her to join the crew.
No, it's not a requierement to join the crew.
For good reason, the fight did not matter, only the defeat was important. I won't go back to that, read what I write about the subject.
That will only happen AFTER she joins, she is not a strawhat yet. Those are not requierement to join the crew.
Still not a requierement to join the crew. it's irrelevant. The point of the defeat was for Carrot to experience a set back, there was no reason for a strawhat to help her here. It would have render the scene meaningless, you need to understand that your point does not stand the test of narration.
Wrong. Or more exactly you can't know that.
It's called a setup for a reason.
As I see it, it's preparing Carrot for an introspection so it DOES help her move forward.
Wano is not Carrot's story, it's logical for Oda to push her back.
And that happen in whole cake for Carrot. We are gonna have a problem if you keep ignoring whole cake. Carrot is linked to whole cake, not to Wano. And BOTH ARC are part of the yonko Saga, so BOTH ARC are relevant in that matter. Wake up.
Yamato is treated as an arc character. And there are subversive dialogue showing that the strawhat crew is not her final destination so I won't extend myself on her case, it's done.
Until you understand that both whole cake and wano have to be taken into account, you won't understand why Carrot joined the crew at the end of Wano ;)
That's true, but that's also the last thing she must developp to sail the see, so we can expect it to happen very soon.
Again, you can't know until you see the end of the Saga. ;) So your point is - for the moment - irrelevant.
Wrong, you should try to learn a thing or two about characterization.
In fact Yamato's motivation to sail the sea is for the moment on the same level as Carrot. She has no other reason that being free. So try to avoid comparing those two characters on that front ;)
Wrong, it was managed by herself.
Just like Yamato
And that something that can only happen once the character JOINS the crew.
So this point is irrelevant right now.
Don't try to make Yamato fit that parameter. She does not. Yamato NEVER said that she would improve for Luffy so her place here is completely undeserved. Your argument is irrelevant here.
You need to actually wait for that. This can only happen in a moment of rest. So wait until the end of the arc before concluding anything please ;)
No. Wano is not Carrot's story. I should not expect something that has no place in the story right now.
True, but that was just an hypothesis that could lead to a confirmation, there are still windows for confirmation in the future ;)
No but a good fan should remember what she did in whole cake. Sad thing, you do not, you are therefore not a good fan .. case and point..
That can only happen in a moment of rest. Wait for the end of the arc mate ;)
Wrong, it would be logical with what she did in whole cake. Don't try to find a way to trash Carrot for no reason.
Wano is just a PART of the yonko Saga, what Carrot did in whole cake was MORE THAN ENOUGH for her to join.
It won't be enough for her to be recruited, but that will happen AFTER she joins. But you will have to wait to see that ;)
As always, a lot of text for a lot of nothing.
Same arguments in circle. Same counter argumentation. Nothing here is relevant. wait a little and you will understandjust how wrong you are ;)
Post automatically merged:
Joining means that you embark on the ship like Nami during east Blue or Vivi during Grandline or Robin after Alabasta.. Being recruited means that you are recognize by Luffy or the crew as a REAL Nakama and that you embark with him until the end of the story.
What I expect Carrot to do, is not to be recruited, but to REjoin the crew after wano, and be recruited AFTER Elbaf
@CarrotForNakama would you accept Carrot as Nakama if she’s there for Luffy to eat at the party at the end of Wano
Her only use for the crew is to be food. If that’s what you accept as her role in the crew then I’ll believe it
Her only use for the crew is to be food. If that’s what you accept as her role in the crew then I’ll believe it
- Status