Questions & Mysteries Oden vs Mihawk?

Who wins

  • Mihawk

    Votes: 136 83.4%
  • Oden

    Votes: 27 16.6%

  • Total voters
    163

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#42
I'm willing to concede that, but then Roger was also at his peak with 39 in God Valley and not with 50+ something when fighting Whitebeard and Oden?

Different people may have different peak ages. And Shanks is too murky of a debate because we haven't seen a single attack from him and we don't know why Kaido considers him to be at his level.
Yes why not Roger in his 50s was old and sick
Oda said wbs prime was late 30s too.
Whatever level he is doesn't matter as we won't see shanks in 10 years time
But he's 39 now
 
#48
I don’t know if this was done before,but oden was one of the few people who could fight yonko kaido. And mihawk had numerous fights with yonko shanks.

Both can go toe to toe with a yonko. So do you think wins? Do you think mihawk is yonko level? Jozu a yonko commander could stop one of his powerful attacks meant for white beard
Mihawk. He's the best swordsman of his time. Oden is very strong but I dont think he was the best of his time.
 
#50
It was a powerful slash meant to cut a human, the World's Strongest Human, but still a human - the same human who was being cut by Marine fodder. And Jozu came in to block a slash meant to cut that, not Diamond. Re-read Zoro vs Mr.1 fight, Breath of All Things is a thing in One Piece's powersystem & Mihawk aimed that slash to cut Whitebeard and not to cut Diamond.

A similar interaction happened between Mihawk, Daz Bones and Luffy - Daz Bones blocked a slash from Mihawk aimed at cutting Luffy, but the moment Mihawk actually wanted to cut Daz Bones (steel), Daz Bones was one-shotted.
Meant to cut human, but ended up cutting through ice…. Also Jozu wasn’t full body diamond he still had human flesh on some parts, no excuses for this one
 
#51
It was a powerful slash meant to cut a human, the World's Strongest Human, but still a human - the same human who was being cut by Marine fodder. And Jozu came in to block a slash meant to cut that, not Diamond. Re-read Zoro vs Mr.1 fight, Breath of All Things is a thing in One Piece's powersystem & Mihawk aimed that slash to cut Whitebeard and not to cut Diamond.

A similar interaction happened between Mihawk, Daz Bones and Luffy - Daz Bones blocked a slash from Mihawk aimed at cutting Luffy, but the moment Mihawk actually wanted to cut Daz Bones (steel), Daz Bones was one-shotted.
Young Oden was making Primebeard sweat and shook

Posthawk is seen as nothing but someone vista can handle by Marco

Marco would never send vista to handle Oden or Shanks or Yonko! Never
And Vista would never stop them successfully if he tries.
Marco himself failed to stall or stop nerfed casual BM , hot choked and didn't attempt again after that

Nobody in their right mind will see Oden eeats vs WB, Kaido and all the hype he got then go say "Mihawk is stronger"
Oden doesn't fall under his title even coz he peaked and died before Mihawk could be WSS even.

Oden > commander Oden >~ Young Oden ~ Posthawk (until he shows more)
 

ConquistadoR

The Rogue Prince
#54
Meant to cut human, but ended up cutting through ice…. Also Jozu wasn’t full body diamond he still had human flesh on some parts, no excuses for this one
Because of the energy that the slash carries lol. More than being "meant to cut Human" it was more about "not being meant to cut Diamond". And how does it matter whether he has human flesh on half his face when he blocked the attack using his diamond parts? You think BOAT isn't a thing in One Piece?

One thing Ill give Jozu is his physical strength though, he was able to stop that massive slash when Fujitora was being pushed back by a tiny Zoro slash in comparision.
 
#56
Mihawk will win without any kind of permanent scar.

Mihawk,

first of his name,
the unscarred,
forger of Black Blade,
the World's Strongest Swordsman.

It's funny how people make fun of Mihawk because of Jozu and Vista, wherein:

-WB got scared of Kaido
-WB got his body pierced by Veteran Level Squidward
-Kaido screamed in pain by YC3 Killer Sonic Attack
-Kaido got scarred by Zoro, who's even weaker than Mihawk even after he wakes up
-Kaido's dragon slashes which damaged Sun God Nika got neg-diffed by Zoro's casual parry slash
-Big Mom got clowned so many times
-Shanks got scarred by YC level Teach
-Shanks couldn't get the WSS title from Mihawk
-Shanks wanted to settle fight with Mihawk, but Mihawk was not in mood, Shanks offered drinks instead lol, He could've fight Mihawk if he wanted

-Jozu took many seconds using Diamond Body before he could re-direct Mihawk's casual Slash, wherein Zoro not only neg-diffed but also cut Kaido's Wind Slash
-Vista couldn't connect a single hit on Mihawk, Kaido got hit twice by YC3 Laughing Killer
-Even Nika Plot Armor protected Luffy from getting arms cut off from Mihawk

:steef:
 
#59
Because of the energy that the slash carries lol. More than being "meant to cut Human" it was more about "not being meant to cut Diamond". And how does it matter whether he has human flesh on half his face when he blocked the attack using his diamond parts? You think BOAT isn't a thing in One Piece?
So now you’re contradicting the point , now it’s the “energy of the slash” why would it cut through ice last time I checked that isn’t flesh.
Also Jozu quite literally took the attack head on you can see it in the anime and manga with his silhouette
 

ConquistadoR

The Rogue Prince
#60
So now you’re contradicting the point , now it’s the “energy of the slash” why would it cut through ice last time I checked that isn’t flesh
Does any of this change the fact that the slash wasn't aimed at cutting Diamond? Yes or No?
Also Jozu quite literally took the attack head on you can see it in the anime and manga with his silhouette
Where he defended with his diamond parts. His physical strength was also highlighted along with his diamond defense since Fujitora was being pushed back by a tiny slash from Zoro.
 
Top