You claimed it because it was redirected, for all I know you think Adam is also scum (not with you) and decide to get some cred from it. Again, you as scum could not possibly anticipate Charlie being able to counter the redirect part. I'm focusing purely on the mechanics here, it fit into place perfectly and now I'm being told it doesn't count because of some other info and that it's all a coincidence. Put yourself in my shoes here - what conclusion would you come to? Focus mechanics over player for this.
If he’s claiming my action was, then I’ll happily take the lynch for a 1 to 1 trade no problem