Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
you get the names of the ones with the most kills right? Isnt prof's killer tied with vergil now?
Once per Day. I get the name of the character with the most kills at that point. Then I post some flavour, and Fuji announces this to the thread. There will be no new information until tomorrow.
 
Putting half the game down as "Null" and being willfully ignorant of town-clearing elements is not Mafia.
See, this is where the cap begins. I literally have 3 null reads. If I have someone as null/town lean or null/scum lean it means they are slightly town or slighty mafia. This is why I said you are spewing nonsense my way and we are not reading the same game.

Well I'm not going to do your job for you, am I? Like what is this expectation?
You come to me and say some of my reads are wrong and complaining about it, then why don't you point them out? and let's discuss why they are wrong or right. No point making such statements if you gonna just stuff for the sake of it. Plus, as i said before I play from mafia POV not from a position where I get people flavors etc and start solving the game in other ways.

If it were mere disagreement, sure. It doesn't actually matter to me either way, but you continue to fall into pitfalls because you continue to argue from positions of ignorance.
Sure, I am ignorant and you are not. I forgot you are the all knowing, all seeing. You are never wrong.

I'm not insulting you here, to be clear. I'm pointing out that the arguments you are making are not informed.
If you expect me to follow every action or ability that get used and try make sense of things in a game where literally anything can happen, then you are mistaken. I am playing mafia and will scum hunt and do my thing to read people. That does not mean I am ignoring the actions completely, I use the information provided to me in the thread and make the best judgement moving forward and so far, my reads been on point.
 
honestly I’m just confused I’m 100 pgs behind and honestly everyone is just running around with their heads cutoff..

get your shit together if you’re town. & @Nikamara if you’re wondering why town lose games here it’s cause everyone has an ego and doesn’t know how to cooperate unless claims are thrown around endlessly.
I mean you know these players better than I do outside of Ultra and Ratchet I haven't play many games with people here. The main problem I see as an outsider isn't ego because look how people were falling over for Ekko and T-Pein Day 1 on literally NADA. If they had some self confidence, they wouldn't fall for such obvious scum play. The main problem is town doesn't seem to know how to be townread. I'm going way off topic here and by no means do I consider myself some sort of mafia expert, but as someone who used to be guilty of looking scummy all the time, if people repeatedly find your play scummy, it means you are the problem, not the rest of the player base. Learning how to be read as town is beneficial in any alignment.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
You come to me and say some of my reads are wrong and complaining about it, then why don't you point them out? and let's discuss why they are wrong or right.
No need to respond to the rest, but this I do need to address, or rather, redress. What possible value is there, in your eyes, for me to do this? You have no guarantee that my reads are genuine, no guarantee that my arguments are genuine, and at the very least you can sure that for the sake of maintaining neutrality, my reads will be tempered. You gain nothing from any discussion because if you're Town, you have absolutely no reason to take anything I say that isn't purely pertaining to established information and value it higher than your own deduction. And this is important, because for any dialogue to succeed, you need to approach it with a willingness to compromise on your views, within margins. I'm nt going to do this - not because I can't, but because it serves no purpose.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top