It actually pains me to say this, since the power of souls is an extreme power. Can you imagine if BM just casually make Yoru or Gryphon into homies? Akainu's magma into a homie? Etc etc she should be one of the most haxxed fighter...but her fighting IQ is meh to the extreme even Franky and Robin humilate her lol.
To compare her IQ to Mihawk? As the WSS, he literally should have the most focus, composure precision in the entire series imo. Shanks the lazy drunken bum doesn't have that kind of crazy focus and precision all the time. Imo even with BM's crazy stamina and superior durability, Mihawk will tear BM apart using faster and more consistent damage per second.
Lol no, it's one thing if you think Mihawk would defeat her but saying he would defeat her very fast is fucking dumb.
I don't care how strong you think Mihawk is or what your opinion on Big Mom is, but he will not defeat Big Mom that fast and it's absolutely dumb if you actually think that.
Poor Big Mom, everyone and their mom clowns on her now
Not really. While I think Oda failed to truly showcase Big Mom during her fight against Kid and Law, we got to remember that:
1. Most of the fight was off paneled, if this was Luffy vs Big Mom then Oda would have shown way more feats from her.
2. Kid and Law were actually struggling against her and they had to finally use their awakening to have any chances of severely injuring as well as finally defeating her.
3. Plot yes we can't forget about plot, there were moments where she was very close on defeating Kid and Law but their plot armor saved them.
4. When it comes to non SH fights especially ones that aren't focused on Luffy, those fights are not going to get the same amount of focus and because of that those fights and the villains of that fight might come off very disappointing.
At the end of the day, it's not that Big Mom is weak but it's that Oda really didn't care about her fight against Kid and Law because it was not a SH focused fight.