Controversial The defenitive thread about swordsmanship skills and titles.

[Gelo]

have you read the thread or do you say the same stuff expecting me to use same arguments? Honestly, what you said isn't even remotevely related to my argument.

Bro you made 4 threads the same
And instead of improving you only got worse

 

[[No Name]]

You're talking shit.
The famed sword skill without haki means nothing

Zoro is still using the same sword skill from his introduction
So according to you he's not any better as a swordsman

Zoro became a Sword Master so he got better, he's same ranking as Shanks, but he isn't of the same rank of Vista, Ryuma, Mihawk and Ushimaru.

Post automatically merged: Aug 30, 2022

Bro you made 4 threads the same
And instead of improving you only got worse

Ok, you didn't even read it.

 

[HeroesNZ]

so swordsmanship is not equal to overall strength.
If a Master swordsman can be stronger than a Grandmaster then a Master swordsman like Shanks can be stronger than Mihawk.

Yes you're absolutely correct, Shanks could be stronger than Mihawk.

However, he's not, because Mihawk has the title of Sekai Saikyo no Kenshi, and Shanks is a Kenshi.

So if your thread was about proving that simply having greater sword skill doesn't make Mihawk stronger than Shanks then good stuff, great thread.

But if your thread is about proving that Mihawk's title no longer holds meaning then that's incorrect. Zoro's dream may be to be the strongest Dai-Kengo ever, but that is not Mihawk's title. These are two different topics.

What you've done, however, is prove beyond reasonable doubt that Shanks is indeed a Swordsman. A master swordsman, in fact. And as a master swordsman, he is inevitably included in Mihawk's title which was reiterated multiple times last chapter to be the World's Strongest Swordsman. Not World's Most Skillful Swordsman, not World's Strongest Dai-Kengo, World's Strongest Swordsman period.

 

[BleakAsh]

Trying this badly to distract when Mihawk title couldn't be clearer

Zoro wants to be Worlds strongest Dai-Kengo..


that just means Shanks being stronger doesn't matter to Zoro

Mihawk stalemated Shanks.. he hit a wall against Shanks while being Wss... never won against him.. nor did he fight him in the last decade.. there is ni grounds to prove that in a 1v1 Shanks would loose just based off a title that has an obvious exemption.. or not coz.. Shanks isn't a Dai Kengo LOL

again baseless

 

[HA001]

Zoro became a Sword Master so he got better, he's same ranking as Shanks, but he isn't of the same rank of Vista, Ryuma, Mihawk and Ushimaru.

Post automatically merged: Aug 30, 2022

Ok, you didn't even read it.

Nope. Don't run

Why is he still using the same sword skills as his introduction

Why did mihawk teach him 0 sword skills

According to you since haki is separate and physical strength has nothing to do with skill

Zoro has not grown since his intro

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Yes you're absolutely correct, Shanks could be stronger than Mihawk.

However, he's not, because Mihawk has the title of Sekai Saikyo no Kenshi, and Shanks is a Kenshi.

So if your thread was about proving that simply having greater sword skill doesn't make Mihawk stronger than Shanks then good stuff, great thread.

But if your thread is about proving that Mihawk's title no longer holds meaning then that's incorrect. Zoro's dream may be to be the strongest Great Swordsman ever, but that is not Mihawk's title. These are two different topics.

What you've done, however, is prove beyond reasonable doubt that Shanks is indeed a Swordsman. And as a swordsman, he is inevitably included in Mihawk's title which was reiterated multiple times last chapter to be the World's Strongest Swordsman. Not World's Most Skillful Swordsman, not World's Strongest Dai-Kengo, World's Strongest Swordsman period.

Basically he proved that Zoro will both become the greatest swordmaster and strongest swordsman when beating Mihawk lol

 

[Hedfi]

If you encourage me enough i can honestly debunk the theory of Mihawk > Shanks in a thread to logically proved how this claim is standing on an alternative interpretation of the text in manga


and
ye


Mihawk.. is WS Dai-Kengo ig

Go for it, make a thread about swordsmanship lvls in One Piece.

 

[Rootbeer]

Except ushimarus swordsmanship couldn't scar kaido zoros can

Yeah they starved them and gave them poor blades..

By the way in case you don't understand @Gol D. Roger is saying Shanks>Mihawk..

 

[style]

Kaidou is not a Swordsman he is generalizing.. keep reaching for more headcanon..

Bold of you talking about headcanon

 

[BleakAsh]

Mihawk is both the number one dai kengo and the world strongest kenshi
Nice try

But zoro's dream is WS dai kengo.. lol

and Mihawk never won against Shanks
coz after defeating everyone he could...there seems to be an exception oda ha laid

 

[[No Name]]

So if your thread was about proving that simply having greater sword skill doesn't make Mihawk stronger than Shanks then good stuff, great thread.

/QUOTE]

Thank you

Zoro's dream may be to be the strongest Great Swordsman ever, but that is not Mihawk's title. These are two different topics.

So Zoro doesn't want to be strongest KENSHI but strongest Dai-Kengo right? This is what you are saying, confirm it and it's enough for me.

 

[HA001]

Yeah they starved them and gave them poor blades..

By the way in case you don't understand @Gol D. Roger is saying Shanks>Mihawk..

So if ushimaru had his normal swords he can scar kaido now ???

 

[Gelo]

Zoro became a Sword Master so he got better, he's same ranking as Shanks, but he isn't of the same rank of Vista, Ryuma, Mihawk and Ushimaru.

Post automatically merged: Aug 30, 2022

Ok, you didn't even read it.

I don't read stupid topics and you don't read manga
I'd say we're even

 

[Rootbeer]

Basically he proved that Zoro will both become the greatest swordmaster and strongest swordsman when beating Mihawk lol

Whats your point Zoro is not even a Grandmaster yet..

 

[HeroesNZ]

Ushimaru has a higher rank than Zoro, therefore he has better Swordsmanship than Zoro..

I don't even know what you're arguing bro

 

[Sir Tuna Sandwich II]

Vista > Shanks confirmed!

 

[Rootbeer]

So if ushimaru had his normal swords he can scar kaido now ???

According to his Ranks yeah but he also does not have plot armor like Zoro, so Zoro is bond to get incredible feats..

 

[HA001]

According to his Ranks yeah but he also does not have plot armor like Zoro, so Zoro is bond to get incredible feats..

Shove the ranks where the sun doesn't shine.
Can ushimaru scar kaido ?

 

[gz89]

That explains why the thread is so retarded

 

[Rootbeer]

I don't even know what you're arguing bro

Ushimaru > Zoro