Questions & Mysteries Why do you just assume Sanji defeated Page One?

Is the Anime Reliable?


  • Total voters
    116
No. Zoro's feat was a matter of lethality, not force. Steel is nothing for a seasoned swordsman lol. Even Kinemon can do that.

Eg. Doffy would have sliced that door like butter, because his strings are extremely sharp.

Hell it's even comparable to Kaido. Kaido eats blunt attacks like nothing, even falling from a height of 10k ft. But Oden cut Kaido's chest open.
If Zoro hasnt got that strength to slice he couldnt do it of course blunt force is inferior in matter of destroying steel but pre ts Luffy could knock the steel door

even if I didnt have the proof if you guys consider Sanji on par with Luffy and Zoro he should do that strength feat but he couldnt Sanji fell back after TS thats clear as day you see it also in the masters
Luffy had Rayleigh top tier, Zoro had Mihawk top tier and Sanji had a fodder like himself

So Luffy pre ts managed to topple a steel door and Sanji post ts not
Zoro gets general zombie and Sanji not
Zoro has defeat Pica a figure similar to Vergo and Sanji lost a kick duell his specialty
In fact, Sanji couldn't defeat anyone he was rather used as a measure to hype Doflamingo
he failed against Vergo, Doflamingo , Bege, Daifuku and Page One

Also Kinemon easily took an Doflamingo attack I'm sure Kinemon is even stronger than Sanji muhahahahah muhahahahaha
 
1) Yep, and is it as strong as when he uses a sword? (I´ll make just do with this = did not replace a sword)
2) And stated it is powerful and he has to master it. Same thing happened to Kitetsu, he stated he needs to master it.
3) Did not tame it, hence why he is training with it.
4) And was it as strong as a normal flying slash?
5) Don´t know what you are referring to here.
6) All Nami main fights literally have her jumping out trying to figure out how the shit works.
7) Yep, it´s a cloud, only stronger.
8) Yep, and stated has to get used to it.
9) Did not replace his main fighting style, only added to it, and also stated he needs to get used to it and master it, and we immediately saw him training after.
10) And also stated how he is not used it and needs to master it.

Nobody claimed Killer was useless, but to suggest a fighting style he has been fighting with all his life can be replaced in 2 weeks is one of the most stupid things i have read in this forum, and there was a lot of stupid shit around here.
Killer didn't replace his entire fighting style he replaced the weapons.
He already had scythes just mechanical ones instead of the non mechanical he used in Wano.

The main difference was that with themechanical ones he could spin them whereas with the non mechanical he span his entire body. Other than that there is no difference evident.

Nami's entire fighting style chanced after getting the climatact and it change in a single fight. She went from being a cqc fighter to a long range fighter in 1 fight.

That was a bigger adjustment tha the one Killer had to go through. After that first fight she was a master at using the climatact.

Same happened with Sabo, he went from a cqc fighter to one that could do long range attacks. He adapted to all those changes on the same day he got the abilities and was even able use the new abilities to fight against an admiral.

Same with BB. The guy was able to immediately use the island crushing attack WB used on his first try.

The adjustment that Nami, BB and Sabo had to make are bigger than Killer and they achievedthem on the same day they received their abilities.

As for Killer, he has had days/weeks to adjust to the new weapons. As evident from how he fought, it was obvious he had adjusted. He was fighting even with nitoryuu Zoro without any issues.

If that was the first day Killer got those weapons and was fighting zoro I might have understood, but thiswas days/weeks after getting those weapons. If Zoro on the first day can use a scythe and perform his normal sword techniques, then I do see how Killer could not after days/weeks. Zoro also didnt show any decreased ability whilst using the scythe.
 
Killer didn't replace his entire fighting style he replaced the weapons.
He already had scythes just mechanical ones instead of the non mechanical he used in Wano.

The main difference was that with themechanical ones he could spin them whereas with the non mechanical he span his entire body. Other than that there is no difference evident.

Nami's entire fighting style chanced after getting the climatact and it change in a single fight. She went from being a cqc fighter to a long range fighter in 1 fight.

That was a bigger adjustment tha the one Killer had to go through. After that first fight she was a master at using the climatact.

Same happened with Sabo, he went from a cqc fighter to one that could do long range attacks. He adapted to all those changes on the same day he got the abilities and was even able use the new abilities to fight against an admiral.

Same with BB. The guy was able to immediately use the island crushing attack WB used on his first try.

The adjustment that Nami, BB and Sabo had to make are bigger than Killer and they achievedthem on the same day they received their abilities.

As for Killer, he has had days/weeks to adjust to the new weapons. As evident from how he fought, it was obvious he had adjusted. He was fighting even with nitoryuu Zoro without any issues.

If that was the first day Killer got those weapons and was fighting zoro I might have understood, but thiswas days/weeks after getting those weapons. If Zoro on the first day can use a scythe and perform his normal sword techniques, then I do see how Killer could not after days/weeks. Zoro also didnt show any decreased ability whilst using the scythe.
And he had no handle, and he were at the side of his hands.
You literally ignore weapon mastery dude.
You think you can easily substitute even a small change at the level these guys are right now? Please...

See above.

And it was shown in the fight, in which 80% was comedic gold and even the finisher was not intended.

Yep, there is a difference between being completely useless with a new thing and actually mastering it.

And still fought in CQC, and when using the fruit, admitted he is not used to it.

And also admitted he can´t control it and has to get used to it.

Baseless, the usage of a new DF and a weapon change is neither comparable nor tangible, you are trying too hard.
Also nice that you forget to mention Kaku and Kalifa, both also not being able to master the ability, which was also comedic gold.


Years vs weeks, obvious which is superior.

Were Zoro´s techniques on the same level? No.
Do we know who Killer even fought in those 2 weeks? No.
All headcanon trying to follow an obvious agenda.

If i were Zoro, i would use 3 different weapons to be able to adjust to every situation, since in 2 weeks, his mastery will be as good as what he has practiced for significantly more than a decade, what´s the difference, right?
 

Jew D. Boy

I Can Go Lower
Serious question to everyone here (or at least the three or four users who evidently have NOTHING better to do, ever) - do y’all know what extenuating circumstances are??

• Zoro was caught off guard by Kamazo (really a fellow SN in disguise) and Onimaru (whose true identity/abilities weren’t known at the time) while protecting Hiyori/Toko
• Sanji was trying to protect the Wano citizens and his nakama, while also attempting to maintain his own false identity, against a Yonko-affiliated veteran
• They’re both in a foreign land, trying to operate in secret, and neither of them have ever been “finer details” kinda guys as much as people who attack first (sometimes to diminished effect) and ask questions eventually

Nobody in One Piece wins every single fight the first time (Luffy fought Crocodile multiple times before beating him and is already on attempt number two with Kaido), so WHY, for the love of God, WHY do y’all need to CONSTANTLY argue which one between Zoro and Sanji is the bigger loser?? They both were caught off guard (or using new equipment they hadn’t figured out) and both came out relatively unscathed. They’re both at full power and ready to rock in Onigashima. They’ll both be crucial in bringing down the Yonko and their crews this arc. Regardless of how oddly this arc has been written, in regards to their characters as well asoverall, there will be redemption for both of them.

Take a step back, do ten deep breaths, and FUCKING CHILL OUT FOR A MINUTE GOD DAMN
 
And he had no handle, and he were at the side of his hands.
You literally ignore weapon mastery dude.
You think you can easily substitute even a small change at the level these guys are right now? Please...

See above.

And it was shown in the fight, in which 80% was comedic gold and even the finisher was not intended.

Yep, there is a difference between being completely useless with a new thing and actually mastering it.

And still fought in CQC, and when using the fruit, admitted he is not used to it.

And also admitted he can´t control it and has to get used to it.

Baseless, the usage of a new DF and a weapon change is neither comparable nor tangible, you are trying too hard.
Also nice that you forget to mention Kaku and Kalifa, both also not being able to master the ability, which was also comedic gold.


Years vs weeks, obvious which is superior.

Were Zoro´s techniques on the same level? No.
Do we know who Killer even fought in those 2 weeks? No.
All headcanon trying to follow an obvious agenda.

If i were Zoro, i would use 3 different weapons to be able to adjust to every situation, since in 2 weeks, his mastery will be as good as what he has practiced for significantly more than a decade, what´s the difference, right?
Guess we will just have to agree to disagree then.
 
I agree with that but that´s not the point. Zoro ain´t oneshotting normal Killer.
The dude was completely broken and literally calls Orochi master and defends his honor, the fact that people believe he is not broken is what´s funny.
Zoro beats him normally, and Killer´s actual strength can be discussed, but this ain´t it chief.
And the statement "scythes are superior" is as ridiculous as they come, pretty much noodle level.
Don't get me wrong i'm not saying that Zoro would one shot normal Killer lol
Just answering the candybois that act like a non nerfed Killer is above Zoro
 
the pink part would go bye bye
if it was killers main weapons
I disagree for 2 reasons.

1 - the scythe give some greater range so Zoro would have been outside of Killer range. Killer's attack would have missed Zoro.

2 - Killers scythes can be used with two hands which generates more power. His spinning gauntlet sickle only uses one hand. If you could hit Zoro the the sickle the damage would be less because the attack would have less power.
 
Liffy could fight an admiral 3 days after defeating Doflamingo, and he is no zoan.

but this is just damage control, true there is no evidence of Sanji winning If p1 is fine next chapter. I will take my L.
Does it prove it though? One Piece is a world where DFs like this exist:



It's a fantasy world with magical powers. People kept saying how could Denjiro be Kyoshiro when they look nothing alike, and I pointed out it really doesn't matter. Plot points to Denjiro -> Kyoshiro and that's what matters. Details are irrelevant. Same thing here. Plot dictated that Sanji only fought Page 1 to eliminate him, and he was nowhere to be seen.

Only thing that will prove this, is Sanji himself acknowledging he didn't beat him (or him being replaced in the Tobbi Roppo).
 

Finalbeta

Zoro Worshipper
I never really got that argument since Sanji didnt exactly struggle against P1 much.

All P1 did was survive the encounter lol
I honesty feel Sanji can defeat PO but it will be similar as vs. Jyabura. Can't see it to be mid difficulty.

PO is just too durable and will make Sanji run out of stamina a lot.
 
Top