Chapter Discussion Did Sabo survive?

[Killer#777]

Nobody assumed Sabo is dead
Everyone knows he's obviously alive

No at the reverie before we had confirmation people just assumed sabo was dead after facing the two admirals.

 

[Mad_Monk]

I hope not

 

[Franosuke]

You know it’s bad when even WesMidnight criticizes one piece

 

[yorosenpai]

the will of P will expand to the will of S

 

[mad monk]

Barely out of Wano, Oda already throwing his usual fakedeath tension.

 

[OnePeace]

suddenly a new op character appears for another saving sabo plot

 

[Bil02]

What would be the narrative purpose?

Why would Oda have Imu completely fail at erasing Lulusia? How does that advance the story?

The goal is accomplished,the country is destroyed but not necessarily the citizens.

Wouldn't be the first time Oda bends backwards when one of Luffy's acquaintances is involved.

 

[Cinera]

The goal is accomplished,the country is destroyed but not necessarily the citizens.

Wouldn't be the first time Oda bends backwards when one of Luffy's acquaintances is involved.

No, if the citizens are alive, the country is not "destroyed" in any sense.

The goal was to erase Lulusia — to make it a country that "never existed — that goal cannot be accomplished if its citizens remain alive.

 

[Best_Biscuits_5]

Yes, he was sent down swimming in magma, having sex with Big Mom

 

[Tyki_Mikk]

The massive bombing of Milk Girl Island ofc.

Does Sabo survive it due to his logia properties? Does this new attack somehow kill even Logia?

 

[Bil02]

No, if the citizens are alive, the country is not "destroyed" in any sense.

The goal was to erase Lulusia — to make it a country that "never existed — that goal cannot be accomplished if its citizens remain alive.

Then I think the goal isn't accomplished then.

 

[OnePieceFanGirl]

Unfortunately, there’s little doubt he made it. Characters I don’t like are practically immortal.

 

[NAMELESS]

I think he still lives.You need haki to kill a logia.Sabo just got blasted,but survived.Vivi on the other hand...well,i hope she was not there.

 

[TheSufferingGob]

100% alive, Logia are effectively immortal unless the attack had haki.

 

[Murilo]

Someone in my Discord server noticed this:

When the sky starts to lit up we see the citizens and you can see how they're shaded. Which makes sense since they are in the island and the light is illuminating all of it, they're all looking up.

Now look at Sabo, everyone is looking up and he is looking to the side/up, the light is coming from his right side.

He is close to the island but he isn't in the island anymore. Plus if he was the attack would have no effect on him, he would die if he drowned or something.

 

[Celestial D. Dragon]

Of course he's not dead. And next week, it'll turn out that he stopped Uranus from completely erasing Lulusia with the Mera Mera no Mi.

 

[Tripod]

No, if the citizens are alive, the country is not "destroyed" in any sense.

The goal was to erase Lulusia — to make it a country that "never existed — that goal cannot be accomplished if its citizens remain alive.

Not that I disagree
But what you’re saying can’t happen literally did with Ohara

 

[Rmstorm]

Not that I disagree
But what you’re saying can’t happen literally did with Ohara

Ohara WAS NOT NUKED. A different type of attack was sued on Ohara to protect the innocent citizens. Akainu just murdered them on his own accord.

 

[Cinera]

Not that I disagree
But what you’re saying can’t happen literally did with Ohara

Ohara was used to make an example, and everyone but Robin did die. The example was successfully made.

You can't make a country as if it "never existed" if there are many people who still remember it. Especially if those people are citizens of said country.

 

[King4nakama]

Yes unphased too, man built different