[FNZ] Super Role Madness Waifu Wars: Requiem of Eternity

[Lord Melkor]

Though I am not sure

that's nothing compared to how games here would usually go

Fortunately.

 

[Destroya]

absolutely, i'm more of a policy lynch than zolo,you thought zolo was a policy lynch here but he's not he usually gets to end game since he just lurks or appears random asking where are the indies so he can kill them

Yeah, it was just this morning.

 

[Indigo]

Yeah I figured we had to be just about done.

I'm not interested in an Ekko lynch. I don't feel super comfortable with a policy lynch on Zolo. Pero has claimed they are a policy lynch, but there was some legit suspicion around that slot and initial votes. Despite Pero's feelings about it, I still don't think there was any attempt to defend and I felt like they came off scummy around if.

Who said that they may know Pero's role and that it should be town? That would be the only thing stopping me from voting here.

I said i think i know the character, and i don't think this character could be Mafia

Since the character is among the good guys in their story

 

[MonochromeYoru]

I don't care that Pero is a policy lynch or thinks they are one, but they legit put up no defense against any of the votes and they weren't just policy votes like on Zolo. I also feel like their inability to name a scum on their wagon, until prompted further, wasn't a great look, especially when Pero was claiming it was a scum influenced wagon.

Wasn't that just a generic claim by pero? Like, if he's town, and some people are trying to get him lynched for no reason from his perspective, then he would call them scummy right? I don't see too much wrong with that.

 

[Destroya]

If I was going for a wild hair CFD I’d go T-Pein.

His entrance was honestly scummy. I kind of like Tpein and would feel bad doing that to. Mitch I don't really know and I just caught him as hostile in another game, so...

 

[Lord Melkor]

@Ratchet to avoid the same issue we had at the start of the HXH game, I want to mention before I drop a vibe list that I'm a bit unsure of your slot currently. Your interaction with Prof was fine from a perspective of how you usually play, but it felt a bit weird that you told Prof he was doing 'much better' after a post he made where I didn't actually think he really clarified what you were asking him for. You also told Pero they were doing 'much better' when they said 'I guess Ekko' in a delayed response to the question of who they thought was scum on the Pero wagon. It kind of felt like maybe you let these two go a bit easily. I also kind of thought you were fishing for the trivia winner and wished that maybe would have stayed quiet. I think there's also an element of your aggressiveness that is perhaps being put on a bit. I couldn't give you thoughts of why I initially called your slot scummy in HXH, but when I did a reread of this game, I made sure to make note of what I was unsure about with you so that I could communicate in an attempt to help solve your slot in a more effective and less headachey way.

Yes, I also fee uneasy about Ratchet right now.

His reaction to me voting him is being friendly and proposing Zolo.

 

[T-Pein™]

@T-Pein™ I kind of think Melkor and Nessos are townie right now, yet you said they are both scummy. Thoughts on that?

I have a bias against them.
Nothing serious.

 

[Destroya]

I said i think i know the character, and i don't think this character could be Mafia

Since the character is among the good guys in their story

Well then, I'm not going to allow that to outweigh scummy behavior.

 

[T-Pein™]

Someone aware me of who we voting today.
I have my vote on peroncino i think

 

[Lord Melkor]

Also I was already hit with two hostile actions this game, bleeding and losing an ability. I think time to check my role and roll.

 

[Gambit]

You will become the counterwagon for Ekko.

Says he wants to scum hunt. Does nothing.

Ask people who he should vote. Votes whoever is leading despite having no interactions with him. Didn't ask why he's being voted either. As if he was happy that its not someone else.

Fair enough. I only skimmed through and haven't truly delved on it. You got a good eye.

Town lock Charlie.

Pot is legal, no jail time necessary.

I should have known since it's legal in our town as well.

Flower claimed indie early game.

I think those are actually town points in your favour, because a scum would likely be informed by his team.

Hmm. I didn't think of anything about that post. She knows me and how I always paint her as scum regardless. Lololol

 

[T-Pein™]

If I was going for a wild hair CFD I’d go T-Pein.

I am town.
I will be able to town confirm myself.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

I don't care that Pero is a policy lynch or thinks they are one, but they legit put up no defense against any of the votes and they weren't just policy votes like on Zolo. I also feel like their inability to name a scum on their wagon, until prompted further, wasn't a great look, especially when Pero was claiming it was a scum influenced wagon.

That inability to name a scum on his wagon is something I believe I have seen Town Pero do before. As with his not really defending himself and instead just passively complaining. It can be frustrating because it creates a difficult read.

If he would have started with those reactions it probably wouldn’t raise much of an eye. But instead he just ignored those first votes on him (and didn’t even acknowledge them even in a “you guys suck at reading me/finding scum” kind of way) for awhile until I pointed out how he wasn’t doing these things he usually does.

To make things clear I don’t have some dead eyed locked in read on him here that’s prime for a tunnel. I could easily switch to T-Pein here. He hasn’t posted much but I have about the same level of read on the two.

 

[T-Pein™]

Imma stick with the Pero Vote.
Feeling good about it.
Nessos bad too.
Not a fan of anyone trying to lynch kekko

 

[Destroya]

Wasn't that just a generic claim by pero? Like, if he's town, and some people are trying to get him lynched for no reason from his perspective, then he would call them scummy right? I don't see too much wrong with that.

Perhaps, but that can be too easy. One thing I've really come to understand in Mafia is that players are always going to be wrong in games at some point. I've been in so many town vs town arguments that I know that you can wrongly suss town. You got to read between the lines and see if they are simply wrong or is their an ulterior motive for their push or votes. Unfortunately with me, calling someone scummy for voting you and then just ignoring it doesn't really do anything for me, especially when there's a few votes and you're a leading wagon. Got to do something to help town solve slots like that and not just flop.

 

[Dr_Professor83]

Interesting. I think Pero told me that they were?

He did. But I’ve heard him say he was before when he was Town when he’s not really lol. He’s a policy D1 wagon almost. But not a lynch.

 

[Flower]

I am town.
I will be able to town confirm myself.

Go for it .

 

[Gambit]

Yes, I also fee uneasy about Ratchet right now.

His reaction to me voting him is being friendly and proposing Zolo.

How can someone be friendly while pointing the gun at someone else? I say evil. Lololol

Anyway, I am not a fan of policy lynch as well. Not only it scare away players old and new into playing mafia but it also allows an unnecessary lynches. The only good thing it does is actually subconsciously outing scums but that ofcourse would only be realised upon later times.

I should know because I have been a victim of it several times.

 

[T-Pein™]

That inability to name a scum on his wagon is something I believe I have seen Town Pero do before. As with his not really defending himself and instead just passively complaining. It can be frustrating because it creates a difficult read.

If he would have started with those reactions it probably wouldn’t raise much of an eye. But instead he just ignored those first votes on him (and didn’t even acknowledge them even in a “you guys suck at reading me/finding scum” kind of way) for awhile until I pointed out how he wasn’t doing these things he usually does.

To make things clear I don’t have some dead eyed locked in read on him here that’s prime for a tunnel. I could easily switch to T-Pein here. He hasn’t posted much but I have about the same level of read on the two.

Like I said b4.
I will town confirm myself.

 

[Destroya]

Someone aware me of who we voting today.
I have my vote on peroncino i think

You're probably find to stay there.