Character Discussion Luffy sucks as a main character btw

Doggo

Doggo

Welcome to the House of Hope
‎
#62
#62
Emmazrine said:
the luffy hate in this so forum is unjustified all bc they hate the chosen one clichè.

luffy is more than that:catrude:
Click to expand...
The "D." is more than enough "chosen ones" shenanigan.

Stacking long lost joyboy's power, CoC, Nika, etc, that's when it becomes a problem.
I'm not a "tension junkie" that NEEDS main characters dying to keep me on the edge, but the problem I have with these prophecy stacking is that it reduces the sense of a vast world One Piece had.
I think the last time Oda did it right was with the Supernovas introduction. Characters that were having adventures of their own at the same time the main cast.
Now it all revolves around Luffy.
Even the Supernovas.
It's boring.
:kayneshrug:
 
Emmazrine

Emmazrine

‎
#63
#63
Doggo said:
The "D." is more than enough "chosen ones" shenanigan.

Stacking long lost joyboy's power, CoC, Nika, etc, that's when it becomes a problem.
I'm not a "tension junkie" that NEEDS main characters dying to keep me on the edge, but the problem I have with these prophecy stacking is that it reduces the sense of a vast world One Piece had.
I think the last time Oda did it right was with the Supernovas introduction. Characters that were having adventures of their own at the same time the main cast.
Now it all revolves around Luffy.
Even the Supernovas.
It's boring.
:kayneshrug:
Click to expand...
lol you can't get a better profile picture? :whitepress:
 
P

PeperLevi

‎
#68
#68
Doggo said:
Definitely.
Most of the "Luffy hate" comes from people who just wished their character was the MC instead.
:kayneshrug:
Click to expand...
"pEoPlE WaNt ThEiR FaVoUrIte To bE ThE MaIn ChArAcTeR"
This is the only thing that Condom-Boy's dick-swallowers can say. Just like that broken alarm of a speech that consume Condom-Boy's whole life.
And it's not even a true argument. Not matter how good is the concept of a character is,if the character get endlessly wanked and forced down everyone's throats like Lolda does with Condom-Boy ,the character will always be dogshit.
These are the reasons for Condom-Boy be dogshit:
This condom in form of a boy embodies the belief that life is a series of simple questions with simple answers. His secret dream that Lolda foolishly hides and want everyone to be excited about is obviously change the world into a place where special status doesn't exist and people are all equal. A character who is truly smart and brave would never want this. Because What make a true story is the conflict. In a universe where everything is always goody-goody there is no story to tell.
He always resolve everything by fighting. And his definition of fighting is simply create a new and obnoxious stronger punch everytime the enemy get stronger. This is one of the biggest insults to the art in create comics i ever saw.
People always infatuate over his fights being always those with most at stake,when this "most at stake" is dogshit. What he always fight for is the freedom of boring people to live boring lifes. This is a very steryoptical concept for a character that is too stale to be used anymore.
He is the same kind of character as Buggy. They are both examples of "Plot driving a character,because the character can't drive the plot.". These characters are too dumb to do things such as deal with complicated matters and accept defeat when it come to them. For this,the shithead author who write them always bring dumb solutions to their biggest problems out of nowhere and make the story's villains always shot themselves in the foot.
His content in every arc of Shit Piece is save everyone to have a party with them later. It grew to the most unbearable state in Shitty Country Arc. The only two characters who died for real in that pathetic excuse for a war were chosen to die by Lolda because Condom-Boy was not close with them,so it wouldn't ruin the party. This is disgusting like a filthy toilet. The fact of Condom-Boy live happy because no people close to him ever die is a giveaway about how much he is a cowardly softie written by someone who is his shoelicker.
Click to expand...
@CensoredbyWG @Onepiecedying @Pooth @kurwa @lee33
 
Doggo

Doggo

Welcome to the House of Hope
‎
#69
#69
PeperLevi said:
"pEoPlE WaNt ThEiR FaVoUrIte To bE ThE MaIn ChArAcTeR"
This is the only thing that Condom-Boy's dick-swallowers can say. Just like that broken alarm of a speech that consume Condom-Boy's whole life.
And it's not even a true argument. Not matter how good is the concept of a character is,if the character get endlessly wanked and forced down everyone's throats like Lolda does with Condom-Boy ,the character will always be dogshit.
These are the reasons for Condom-Boy be dogshit:

@CensoredbyWG @Onepiecedying @Pooth @kurwa @lee33
Click to expand...
Cry
 
C

CensoredbyWG

#71
#71
PeperLevi said:
"pEoPlE WaNt ThEiR FaVoUrIte To bE ThE MaIn ChArAcTeR"
This is the only thing that Condom-Boy's dick-swallowers can say. Just like that broken alarm of a speech that consume Condom-Boy's whole life.
And it's not even a true argument. Not matter how good is the concept of a character is,if the character get endlessly wanked and forced down everyone's throats like Lolda does with Condom-Boy ,the character will always be dogshit.
These are the reasons for Condom-Boy be dogshit:

@CensoredbyWG @Onepiecedying @Pooth @kurwa @lee33
Click to expand...
I only watch it for TRAFALGAR LAW and the hot girls.
 
Blackbeard

Blackbeard

‎
#72
#72
PeperLevi said:
"pEoPlE WaNt ThEiR FaVoUrIte To bE ThE MaIn ChArAcTeR"
This is the only thing that Condom-Boy's dick-swallowers can say. Just like that broken alarm of a speech that consume Condom-Boy's whole life.
And it's not even a true argument. Not matter how good is the concept of a character is,if the character get endlessly wanked and forced down everyone's throats like Lolda does with Condom-Boy ,the character will always be dogshit.
These are the reasons for Condom-Boy be dogshit:

@CensoredbyWG @Onepiecedying @Pooth @kurwa @lee33
Click to expand...
You sir are a legend.
 
iMaRS_hr

iMaRS_hr

‎
#74
#74
Punk Rotten said:
Luffy is not meant to be overly deep as a character, which is why when he is confronted with the complexities of the OP world and its factions it is interesting. Like others have said, he is a idealistic full embodiment kind of character and is actually selfish in aspects and carries leadership skills that many other shonen main protagonists lack convincingly.

I just read and enjoy him as a character because his personality matches his abilities and the essence of this goofy and absurd manga. In a way he is modeled to be a timeless cartoon like character similar to say....A Popeye or something to that effect. Except he has more empathy than that but thats obviously Oda's intent.
Click to expand...
finally someone that understands luffy's character
 
iMaRS_hr

iMaRS_hr

‎
#76
#76
PeperLevi said:
"pEoPlE WaNt ThEiR FaVoUrIte To bE ThE MaIn ChArAcTeR"
This is the only thing that Condom-Boy's dick-swallowers can say. Just like that broken alarm of a speech that consume Condom-Boy's whole life.
And it's not even a true argument. Not matter how good is the concept of a character is,if the character get endlessly wanked and forced down everyone's throats like Lolda does with Condom-Boy ,the character will always be dogshit.
These are the reasons for Condom-Boy be dogshit:

@CensoredbyWG @Onepiecedying @Pooth @kurwa @lee33
Click to expand...
common PeperLevi L
Post automatically merged:

Onepiecedying said:
You both don't understand
I believe you not even started one piece in chapter one
Click to expand...
jokes on you i've already read chapter one
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top