Speculations What did they do to be recognized as the strongest?

#3



What did they do or what happened for them to be seen as the strongest?
When do you think each was recognized as such?

  1. Whitebeard- known as world's strongest man and pirate at the time
  2. Kaido- known as the world's strongest creature and pirate at the time
  3. Mihawk- known as world's strongest swordsmen
Kaido earned his repo from fighting many strong guys, that's how he got his fame (check his flashback in manga). Mihawk also went around challenging everybody that's how he got his repo/title (check VC). WB was said to rival Roger and had the GGnM, the power to destroy the world, so he got the WSM title.

They all peaked at different times and as long as they are not defeated they retain the title, doesn't matter if they are as strong as they were back when they got the title/repo.
 
#4



What did they do or what happened for them to be seen as the strongest?
When do you think each was recognized as such?

  1. Whitebeard- known as world's strongest man and pirate at the time
  2. Kaido- known as the world's strongest creature and pirate at the time
  3. Mihawk- known as world's strongest swordsmen
There is only kaido who is known as the world's strongest creature here, the 2 others are officially the strongest:endthis:
 
#5
- wb had the most destructive paramecia and had toptier haki capable of clashing with roger

- kaido has a history of challenging the strongest of individuals and not dying , this gave him the epithet of being unkillable , also his dragon form serves as a big intimidation factor .

- mihawk has the strongest sword and he fought countless enemies on his way to the wss , he was so ruthless that there was no swordsman left to be known stronger than him and thus he got the title

Note : only wb and mihawk are the ones to actually have legit titles .
 
#6
It all comes from their Fame
Whether it's Newspaper Articles or Stories exchanged between people
Words about them start to spread more & more until People start giving them a certain Epithet to make them stand out from rest

Mihawk is a Master Swordsman, Kaidou is a (Base looks like Oni) Dragon & WB has Powers of Gura Gura No Mi
Their Adventures led to people realizing that there is No Swordsman better than Mihawk, No Creature who is Tougher to fight than Kaidou & No Man who can unleash more Destructive Power than WB

So automatically people started calling Mihawk WSS, Kaidou Strongest Creature & WB Strongest Man
They simply believed no one can surpass Mihawk's Fighting Style, no one can Kill Kaidou & no one can be more Dangerous than WB
 
#7
Kaido earned his repo from fighting many strong guys, that's how he got his fame (check his flashback in manga). Mihawk also went around challenging everybody that's how he got his repo/title (check VC). WB was said to rival Roger and had the GGnM, the power to destroy the world, so he got the WSM title.

They all peaked at different times and as long as they are not defeated they retain the title, doesn't matter if they are as strong as they were back when they got the title/repo.
- wb had the most destructive paramecia and had toptier haki capable of clashing with roger

- kaido has a history of challenging the strongest of individuals and not dying , this gave him the epithet of being unkillable , also his dragon form serves as a big intimidation factor .

- mihawk has the strongest sword and he fought countless enemies on his way to the wss , he was so ruthless that there was no swordsman left to be known stronger than him and thus he got the title

Note : only wb and mihawk are the ones to actually have legit titles .
When it comes to kaido and mihawk who do you think they were beating?
Like kaido potentially fighting other strong previous rocks members and mihawk strong marines?

Like they had to fight some really strong characters. Unless they killed everyone they challenged to reach the top i wonder where they are now
 
#9
When it comes to kaido and mihawk who do you think they were beating?
Like kaido potentially fighting other strong previous rocks members and mihawk strong marines?

Like they had to fight some really strong characters. Unless they killed everyone they challenged to reach the top i wonder where they are now
kaido could have fought rocks members like how bb fought wang zhi
It was also said he challenged the navy and the yonkos , so he prob defeated some right hands or looked impressive against admirals .

For mihawk , he was known as a marine hunter
He prob defeated an admiral swordsman and
About his duels with shanks idk whether he defeated shanks or not but he certainly looked the stronger guy during those duels ,
mihawk could have possibly also defeated some remnants of the rocks crew .
 
#10
- wb had the most destructive paramecia and had toptier haki capable of clashing with roger

- kaido has a history of challenging the strongest of individuals and not dying , this gave him the epithet of being unkillable , also his dragon form serves as a big intimidation factor .

- mihawk has the strongest sword and he fought countless enemies on his way to the wss , he was so ruthless that there was no swordsman left to be known stronger than him and thus he got the title

Note : only wb and mihawk are the ones to actually have legit titles .
Which mean WB> Roger and mihawk>shanks. Officially title has something to relate to while unofficial title kaido has nothing to relate too
 
#11
Tbh rarely do top tiers engage in death battle kind of fights.

So titles can be debatable in terms of accuracy.

WB mostly got the title due to gura's destructive power

Mihawk mostly due to his cutting powers and possibly defeating other swordsman

Kaido due to his challenges and one to one wining ratio
 
#12
You are actually bringing up something Oda has been bad at - giving us lore about what happened the past 40 years and connecting different characters to each other. It would only need to be a chapter or two in total. Oda could space it out, 2-3 pages here, 2-3 pages there if he wants or better yet dedicate some time to this because I'm sure most fans would love it. At least give it to us in a data book or something if you can't fit it in the manga. Perhaps he will do it like Harry Potter and just make spin off after spin off though

- Who did Shanks defeat in order to become a yonko (literally 4 emperors so there had to have been one before him)?
- Who was Ace going to replace as a shichibukai? Was it going to be hachibukai? Or was he up for Moriahs spot?
- Who has been a shichibukai but got defeated/defected before?
- Who was admiral before Aokiji? Sengoku? If so, who was commander in chief before Kong (who we only have seen two panels off) assuming he was fleet admiral then?
- Who is the worlds strongest bounty hunter?
- How many monsters are there in the WG that we don't know off? Fujitora and Ryukogyu came from a global subscription out of no where, who else is there out there?
 
#14



What did they do or what happened for them to be seen as the strongest?
When do you think each was recognized as such?

  1. Whitebeard- known as world's strongest man and pirate at the time
  2. Kaido- known as the world's strongest creature and pirate at the time
  3. Mihawk- known as world's strongest swordsmen
We should be getting a view of former admirals and what happened to them.

It's very likely only Sencuck and Kong survived the hard times
 
#15
You are actually bringing up something Oda has been bad at - giving us lore about what happened the past 40 years and connecting different characters to each other. It would only need to be a chapter or two in total. Oda could space it out, 2-3 pages here, 2-3 pages there if he wants or better yet dedicate some time to this because I'm sure most fans would love it. At least give it to us in a data book or something if you can't fit it in the manga. Perhaps he will do it like Harry Potter and just make spin off after spin off though

- Who did Shanks defeat in order to become a yonko (literally 4 emperors so there had to have been one before him)?
- Who was Ace going to replace as a shichibukai? Was it going to be hachibukai? Or was he up for Moriahs spot?
- Who has been a shichibukai but got defeated/defected before?
- Who was admiral before Aokiji? Sengoku? If so, who was commander in chief before Kong (who we only have seen two panels off) assuming he was fleet admiral then?
- Who is the worlds strongest bounty hunter?
- How many monsters are there in the WG that we don't know off? Fujitora and Ryukogyu came from a global subscription out of no where, who else is there out there?
I think shanks might've defeated shiki lowkey or maybe some other previous rocks member

But yeah im dying to know what the 3 great powers originally looked like. Cause the 4 emperors and 7 warlords weren't always a thing. Seeing the original version of each would be dope
 
#16
I think shanks might've defeated shiki lowkey or maybe some other previous rocks member

But yeah im dying to know what the 3 great powers originally looked like. Cause the 4 emperors and 7 warlords weren't always a thing. Seeing the original version of each would be dope
That would definitely make sense in verse. Oda could just have said it when he presented Shanks bounty.
"The youngest and newest yonko, Akagami Shanks. He became a yonko 6 years ago when he took down Shiki the Golden Lion, a former Rocks pirate just like Whitebeard, Big Mom and Kaido."
 
#17
That would definitely make sense in verse. Oda could just have said it when he presented Shanks bounty.
"The youngest and newest yonko, Akagami Shanks. He became a yonko 6 years ago when he took down Shiki the Golden Lion, a former Rocks pirate just like Whitebeard, Big Mom and Kaido."
I think back when they were listing emperor bounties they were just highlighting what made them emperors aka their crews. They weren't really hyping up the feats and accomplishments of the captains
 
#18
WB was the only one capable to fight with Roger, the others were clearly below, Roger died and WB was left the obly one in that league. That is also why he was considered the ruler of the seas and no Kaido, BM etc. dared to challenge him.

Kaido has the strongest zoan and so the strongest creature (a dragon), also after WB was dead he had the highest bounty among pirates (still waiting for Dragon) and so he was labeled as the strongest pirate even by Kidd and the others.

Mihawk and Shanks are most likely, the same as Roger and WB swordwise. They were the clearly peak in sword skills, nobody was close enough to them. At a certain point Mihawk get the WSS title and is still waiting for a worth rigal to the point he is bored (and has also to teach himself potential rivals).
 
Top