Who will be the Next Strawhat?


  • Total voters
    506
I am sure she will appear again and then it is your time again to shine. Now however you still have the anime that has not even covered the whole of Wano. Take solace in the much screen time she will still get during the anime.
Post automatically merged:

You could still pick someone else just for fun: What about Bonney for example? Or another character that you like - maybe not as much as Carrot, - and could at least consider to be a "temporary" candidate to feed your burning passion until Carrot appears again.
 
Last edited:
I mean the problem with Bonney to me is that she's a former captain that has the trait to be glutunous, just like Luffy. She's also has an aging fruit which lends her to not fit into any role in the crew in particular on the SHs.
She fits much better a another mini-Law since she has no real role or connection to the SHs. Her story jsut seems like a retelling of Rebeca and Kyros story, an emotional past for a character (Kuma) in which the daughter is the emotional centerpiece to make you go ":(".

She's also extremlly tied to characters related to the revolutionary army, Vegapunk/Kuma, so to me it's likely Kuma dies at the end of this arc and she and Vegapunk go join the Revolutionary army. It's also a good excuse to have one of the worst gen show up at the last war, since they're always involved in these kind of events in movies and such.
 
I mean the problem with Bonney to me is that she's a former captain that has the trait to be glutunous, just like Luffy. She's also has an aging fruit which lends her to not fit into any role in the crew in particular on the SHs.
She fits much better a another mini-Law since she has no real role or connection to the SHs. Her story jsut seems like a retelling of Rebeca and Kyros story, an emotional past for a character (Kuma) in which the daughter is the emotional centerpiece to make you go ":(".

She's also extremlly tied to characters related to the revolutionary army, Vegapunk/Kuma, so to me it's likely Kuma dies at the end of this arc and she and Vegapunk go join the Revolutionary army. It's also a good excuse to have one of the worst gen show up at the last war, since they're always involved in these kind of events in movies and such.
Yes, there are not many hints of her joining. The revolutionary arme would be a place for her. But then, she could also get reunited with her father and leave via Kuma's DF-power.
Also, I too think her character is not well thought through. She is too impulsive for me.

I too am curious if Kuma dies or not. Because I wonder if S-Bear will lose his ability he got from Kuma. And then there are the other Pacifista, who are possibly going to be controlled by Saturn. If Kuma dies, maybe they will lose a part of their power, too.
 
I mean the problem with Bonney to me is that she's a former captain that has the trait to be glutunous, just like Luffy. She's also has an aging fruit which lends her to not fit into any role in the crew in particular on the SHs.
She fits much better a another mini-Law since she has no real role or connection to the SHs. Her story jsut seems like a retelling of Rebeca and Kyros story, an emotional past for a character (Kuma) in which the daughter is the emotional centerpiece to make you go ":(".

She's also extremlly tied to characters related to the revolutionary army, Vegapunk/Kuma, so to me it's likely Kuma dies at the end of this arc and she and Vegapunk go join the Revolutionary army. It's also a good excuse to have one of the worst gen show up at the last war, since they're always involved in these kind of events in movies and such.
I'd hardly call Bonney tied to Vegapunk... wanting to beat his ass isn't exactly what I'd call a positive character relationship.

And her being tied to Kuma doesn't really mean much considering there are more ties in the Strawhats to the Revos... but they aren't revos themselves.

Like I'm not sold on the idea of Bonney joining, but these are pretty weak reasons.
 
I'd hardly call Bonney tied to Vegapunk... wanting to beat his ass isn't exactly what I'd call a positive character relationship.

And her being tied to Kuma doesn't really mean much considering there are more ties in the Strawhats to the Revos... but they aren't revos themselves.

Like I'm not sold on the idea of Bonney joining, but these are pretty weak reasons.
Who is your candidate, by the way? I'm just curious.
 
I'd hardly call Bonney tied to Vegapunk... wanting to beat his ass isn't exactly what I'd call a positive character relationship.

And her being tied to Kuma doesn't really mean much considering there are more ties in the Strawhats to the Revos... but they aren't revos themselves.

Like I'm not sold on the idea of Bonney joining, but these are pretty weak reasons.
? Bonney is tied to both Vegapunk and Kuma, not just Vegapunk, and she wants to beat him up because of what he did to her dad, but it's already been setup that Vegapunk had a reason to do with he did.

Also if you don't see a clear path to Bonney going hard against the celestial dragons because of whatever they did to her dad, then i don't know what to tell you.

If you have some better end faction Bonney will eventually join up to feel free to share, because i doubt she'll just be some rando singular person doing things on her own again.
 
Top