Who will be the Next Strawhat?


  • Total voters
    506
In a sence science is very important on the Sunny:

- Robin > Archeology
- Chopper > Medecine
- Franky > Engineer
- Usopp > Creative Engineer / Botanism
- Nami > Climat tactician

So I'm not really against the idea of a new type of scientist joining. But what would be their task then ? What would be their field of study ?

With Vegapunk I could easily see the mind of a mathematical theorist/cosmologist coming up.. but with Stussy.. I don't really know.
Stussy would be a physicist and focus on forms of energy which relates to Vegapunks dream
 
That doesn't relate whatsoever to an actual necessity the Strawhats have. The Sunny and Frankies mechs never had energy problems, so she has no use on the crew.
You could say the same for:
Jinbe
Robin

Hell you were a carrot fan and straw hats never had look out problems.

Besides the Sunny has had energy problems. Multiple times they’ve been unable to use a coup de boom due to a lack of soda.
 
You could say the same for:
Jinbe
Robin

Hell you were a carrot fan and straw hats never had look out problems.

Besides the Sunny has had energy problems. Multiple times they’ve been unable to use a coup de boom due to a lack of soda.
But reading ponelgyphs actually matters unlike having the need to be soda refill girl and helsman and lookout are actual real pirate roles unlike scientist, which is a role basically already occupied by Chopper and Franky.

On a character that we don't even know if it's a scientist or not.
 
But reading ponelgyphs actually matters unlike having the need to be soda refill girl and helsman and lookout are actual real pirate roles unlike scientist, which is a role basically already occupied by Chopper and Franky.

On a character that we don't even know if it's a scientist or not.
Archaeologist was only revealed to be important decades after robins introduction.

Franky also doubled as the helmsman prior to jinbe joining and chopper and Franky aren’t scientists. They’re doctors and engineers. Chopper was helped by a scientist and Franky has so far only been able to copy machinations from scientists

Both could benefit from a legitimate scientist. And we didn’t know Jinbe was a good helmsman until he joined the crew too.
 
But reading ponelgyphs actually matters unlike having the need to be soda refill girl and helsman and lookout are actual real pirate roles unlike scientist, which is a role basically already occupied by Chopper and Franky.

On a character that we don't even know if it's a scientist or not.
Like I said scientist is broad. A lot of strawhats are scientist, but they do need a task to fullfil.

Archaeologist was only revealed to be important decades after robins introduction.
I think people missunderstand the point of Robin's role. Her task might be archeologist but her real role is the course giver. Basically Robin act as the person that point to a direction. She is the creator of the road of the Ship. Much like Christopher Colombus at the time of the discovery of indi.. Cuba.
 
Ussop could also benefit from a real botanist, which was a real role in Oda original concept, doesn't mean one's joining. You're arguing for something that's so niche it's pure guesswork
 
Top