Even if we assume that Michelle's pocketing on Ratchet is innocent, and that is big if, she had ample amount of time and opportunity to make ammends. A lot of patience as well. In another game there would have been 6-8 votes on her by now. This shows that there is some resistance on her wagon.
The game is low presence, as proof you have me high poster when I didn't even have time to play, so votes wouldn't show as usual.