Status
Not open for further replies.

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Reborn what’s your read on Apollo bc I noticed you seemed to drop that
What I dropped?

I wanted clarification from Apollo regarding his claim because I found some inconsistencies and Apollo replied to me clarifying it and I find it satisfactory.

So, what I dropped exactly, Mr Prof?
 
Ekko doesn't seem like part of Adam's team.

If tac is scum and he pushed ekko (let's assume he flips town) on weak ground like kill failed on you in SRM then next cycle it will be tac who will be under fire and would highlight himself which seem too risky for pushing someone for Lynch who is already getting sussed


This doesn't feel like scum gameplay, Mr. Prof
Didn’t you think Apollo lying about his Ratchet info lol?

That’s a more suicidal play for scum than pushing someone for surviving a kill

Also I disagree, it’s an easier basis for scum to push a mislynch than by actually having to push them for their play which is messier
 
What I dropped?

I wanted clarification from Apollo regarding his claim because I found some inconsistencies and Apollo replied to me clarifying it and I find it satisfactory.

So, what I dropped exactly, Mr Prof?
I did a quick ISO of you after reading Ekko’s post around your Apollo play and it looked like you just shaded Apollo and then moved on
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Didn’t you think Apollo lying about his Ratchet info lol?

That’s a more suicidal play for scum than pushing someone for surviving a kill

Also I disagree, it’s an easier basis for scum to push a mislynch than by actually having to push them for their play which is messier
I did feel apollo claim looks like role cop but it's tinfoil and totally based on assumption..



And, I disagree. In what world lynching ekko regardless of his alignment is a mislynch? :milaugh:


I don't see that as scum play so disagree with you
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
I did a quick ISO of you after reading Ekko’s post around your Apollo play and it looked like you just shaded Apollo and then moved on
If you isoed it then definitely you saw that I didn't throw shade but analysed Apollo claim properly.

After that I was inactive for whole day or more because of work. I didn't even vote because I didn't log in worstgen at all
 
I did feel apollo claim looks like role cop but it's tinfoil and totally based on assumption..



And, I disagree. In what world lynching ekko regardless of his alignment is a mislynch? :milaugh:


I don't see that as scum play so disagree with you
Is your argument that scum wouldn’t want Ekko lynched with the last part lol?

Also, the point still stands that you’re saying Tac wouldn’t want to look bad for Ekko when you tinfoiled Apollo as doing something worse lol, unless you didn’t believe Ratchet was Town
 
If you isoed it then definitely you saw that I didn't throw shade but analysed Apollo claim properly.

After that I was inactive for whole day or more because of work. I didn't even vote because I didn't log in worstgen at all
I feel like the point about Apollo saying a vig can shoot Ratchet if they want was cherry picking without context when he, in the same post, said he could only be lynched. And he’d been saying shooting him would be pointless lol.

Basically it was more like saying “if you don’t believe me try” than advocating for Town to waste bullets like you suggested.
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Is your argument that scum wouldn’t want Ekko lynched with the last part lol?

Also, the point still stands that you’re saying Tac wouldn’t want to look bad for Ekko when you tinfoiled Apollo as doing something worse lol, unless you didn’t believe Ratchet was Town
I don't think you are reading what I am saying

Tac read - based on gameplay. Don't see scum pushing someone like that.. that's just dumb play

Apollo - I found some inconsistencies which I highlighted so how you say it's tinfoil worse than tac?
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
I feel like the point about Apollo saying a vig can shoot Ratchet if they want was cherry picking without context when he, in the same post, said he could only be lynched. And he’d been saying shooting him would be pointless lol.

Basically it was more like saying “if you don’t believe me try” than advocating for Town to waste bullets like you suggested.
Why you even advocate town vig to waste a bullet on someone if you think you are 100% sure that someone can't be killed.



That's just absurd
 
I don't think you are reading what I am saying

Tac read - based on gameplay. Don't see scum pushing someone like that.. that's just dumb play

Apollo - I found some inconsistencies which I highlighted so how you say it's tinfoil worse than tac?
I am reading lol. I’m saying if your tinfoil was right, then Apollo would be doing something dumber than what you’re saying would be dumb for Tac to do lol.

At the least you didn’t think through what your tinfoil would mean then lol
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
I am reading lol. I’m saying if your tinfoil was right, then Apollo would be doing something dumber than what you’re saying would be dumb for Tac to do lol.

At the least you didn’t think through what your tinfoil would mean then lol
So you believed apollo the moment he claimed?
 
Basically the only way it would work as scum is if you believed in fake flipping town roles as scum, but if going with that it would have to be considered on a theoretical scum Tac push too so I don’t see why apply it to one and not the other
 
Im saying pushing someone over surviving a kill can be written off as “sorry dumb” more easily between the two scenarios if you’re talking about blow back for bad push
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
He wasn’t lol. Saying “you can do it if you don’t believe me”, isn’t advocating when you’ve been clear you didn’t think it would work
This is the post I questioned -
Where did he say 'you can do it if you don't believe me"
I know two pieces of information, you are scum and can only be dealt with through the rope.



If any brave vigilante wants to take a shot at you, they are welcome to do it.
I wasn’t there, but reading through it became pretty clear that it would be a suicidal move if he were scum lol.
I don't think you isoed the posts properly.


I literally began the post with words - need some clarifications.... I wanted to be sure and what's wrong with asking questions
Hey Mr. Apollo

I need some clarifications regarding what you claimed



In above post you said you used two abilities

1) upbeat charm - on Ratchet

2) Fido net on ekko

Here you claimed you got Ratchet's alignment and also the name of his ability and proceeds to tell us what that ability does. And, all you used is one ability "Real Charm".

How come just one ability can give both alignment and ability name and what it does? Isn't this too op unless it's role cop?



But here you said - you learnt his alignment and used one of his abilities.






Also, this post^^

You made this post before you claimed - Why you advocated vig to take shot on Mr. Ratchet if you already knew he can't be killed as long as Aizen is alive?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top