Chapter Discussion If Imu is Lily, they’re probably not Luffy’s final fight

#41
You say cant assume and then you go and assume that it was telling them to hunt D clan members. But also like we've seen no D clan hunting in Alabasta or anywhere in the world.
Im not making assumptions about the letter, and I don’t think anyone who’s arguing Im is Lily is using that argument.

Plus I’m not even arguing that Lily is Im.

The whole point of the thread is “if character x is y” not “character x is y.”
 
Last edited:
#42
There’s no way you watch Film Red or read chapter 1055 and don’t come to the conclusion that Shanks is a Big Good.
Throwing whataboutisms at me doesnt disregard anything I just said lol. Film Red, nor 1055 do nothing to argue against it. He needs Luffy for something, that's all you can conclude from that. In fact, Film Red already implies hes a CD.

Shanks had been "good" for a 1000 chapters. It does not mean shit when he inadvertantly does things that make you question what he actually is. It also does not help that we know nothing about what he actually wants.
 
#45
Throwing whataboutisms at me doesnt disregard anything I just said lol. Film Red, nor 1055 do nothing to argue against it. He needs Luffy for something, that's all you can conclude from that. In fact, Film Red already implies hes a CD.

Shanks had been "good" for a 1000 chapters. It does not mean shit when he inadvertantly does things that make you question what he actually is. It also does not help that we know nothing about what he actually wants.
Film Red literally made Shanks look like Jesus when he let civilians hit him.
Post automatically merged:

This was uncalled for.
Fine I’ll delete it
 
Last edited:
#49
Film Red literally made Shanks look like Jesus when he let civilians hit him.
Post automatically merged:


Fine.
Again, doesnt matter what he's outwardly portrayed as. Its nothing we already dont know. The issue is it still does nothing to argue against what I said. Those scenes are there for a reason.

I could also tell you hes one of the few characters that have the look of betrayal like Apoo and Kanjuro, but I wont even go that far.
 
#52
No way… Shanks looked left in a panel?!? I can’t believe this!

….
:pepeke:
Believe what you want. This theory existed before volume 95 for Kanjuro when Apoo was shown to also shown to have betrayed Kid. Then Oda did it again for Shanks.

If this is also the one thing youll gravitate towards to keep arguing over the literal evidence ive shared about him acting out of character, then there is no more conversation
 
#54
Believe what you want. This theory existed before volume 95 for Kanjuro when Apoo was shown to also shown to have betrayed Kid. Then Oda did it again for Shanks.

If this is also the one thing youll gravitate towards to keep arguing over the literal evidence ive shared about him acting out of character, then there is no more conversation
I watched 11 hours of Yoshio Harada movies before making Greenbull theories.

I need more to argue with than Shanks did the same look as X which doesn’t even clearly mean anything beyond coincidence without interpretation.
 
#55
I watched 11 hours of Yoshio Harada movies before making Greenbull theories.

I need more to argue with than Shanks did the same look as X which doesn’t even clearly mean anything beyond coincidence without interpretation.
Lmao, again, you gravitated towards one statement I made and ignored the rest.

Sure, lets ignore:

- The desire that Luffy wants to fight him and didnt single out Blackbeard or Kaido or Big Mom in that statement
- Meeting the Gorosei and explicitly not being shown talking about said pirate
- His CD Lineage/God Valley connections
- His desire to go after Luffy's fleet
- His desire to go after One Piece with an extremely serious face
- Clear and blatant setup that he stole the Nika fruit knowing what it was and fed it to Luffy purposefully
- Has not yet been shown a living equal in terms of Haki feats he's been given on page ("Haki conquers all")
- This:
But sure, keep ignoring what im saying:cheers:
 
H

Herrera95

#57
I don't think Imu is Lily but I can see why you people have this theory.

But it is a very poor theory with less than 0,000...1% of being true because Lily was clearly someone that didn't wanted to be above other humans like all other Tenryuubitos were and to think she ended up becoming the one who sits on the throne is absurd.
 
Top