Character Discussion Debate: Who is the Best Yonkou?

[GUI VI]

Who is the Best Yonkou?
(Luffy is not included.)
- Kaido

- Shanks

- Blackbeard

- Big Mom

- Old Whitebeard

- Buggy The Genius Jester

I'll split this question into 7 Rounds:
•R1: Which one has the best Development?
•R2: Which one has more charisma?
•R3: Which one is more badass?
•R4: Which one has the best design?
•R5: Which one has the best (not the strongest) DF? (in this question, Teach is only with Yami Yami)
•R6: Which one has the coolest crew?
•R7: Which one has the best Right-Hand?
•Personal Question: Which one is YOUR FAVORITE?

I know there's still more to learn about the Yonkous..........But i don't care ;)

Spoiler: Tags

@TheAncientCenturion @Natalija @Gol D. Roger @RayanOO @Garp the Fist @Doggo @Uncle Van @Light D Lamperouge @Warchief Sanji D Goat @Shimotsuki Ghostly @Fujishiro @Zolo @Cream filled donut7 @CoC: Color of Clowns @Rottkins @Peroroncino @Seatonnes @MonsterKaido @Sasaki Kojirō @Erkan12 @Blackbeard @Psalm @Peppercore @Mr. Reloaded @Kyou @Seth @Roronoa-sama @nik87 @ConquistadoR @Sir Yasheen @Agni Kaios @comrade @Shiroyru @ZenZu @Jiihad @BillSlipton @Fn Lucci @HA001 OF THE RAIN @mly90 @Murilo @Franosuke @Novak D Jokovic @Fleet Leader Fenaker @Jonudle @Daikenki @Cinera @Steven @BleakAsh @Kerkovian @Toby D. Dog @Herrera95 @NAMELESS @Ice devil slayer @notAfanboy @Monkey D Theories @DarkestKnightofSpoilers @Red Admiral @DonWick @grey matter @JayKitetsu @Boundless @Pantheos @ReggieZoldyck21 @Vanlax @Thabeast @Salah WG @Luffy is the mc @Zolo @SkySanji @cyka @uyuu @ranady @lee33 @AkainuTheGrimReaper @MarineHQ @EmperorKinyagi @SakazOuki @MarineHQ @Lor D. Coast @Ace @Marco @Chaves @Playa4321 @NikaInParis @centurion @Le Fishe D. Tomdou @Reborn @BangOO🍅 @ShishioIsBack @Don't Mind Me @GeneralP123 @TheKnightOfTheSea @Jailer @Owl Ki @HAJI @silverfire @The Buddha @Extravlad @Chrono @Dark Admiral @dark witch @Nidai_Kitetsu @Worst @Buusatan94 @EtenBoby @Orojackson Refugee @Yo Tan Wa @ShadowStyle369 @Luffy_Fan @Crocks @Kurozumi Bepo @Kurozumi Wiwi @Reborn @Just a member @Boiroy @Emmazrine @AL sama @Albino 👑 @L55 @Lion of Olympus @Cruxroux @kurwa

Post your thoughs!!​

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

R1: Big Mom
R2: Teach
R3: Shanks
R4: Kaido
R5: Kaido
R6: Whitebeard
R7: Buggy (since technically the RHM would be Mihawk)

PQ:

 

[GUI VI]

R1: Big Mom
R2: Teach
R3: Shanks
R4: Kaido
R5: Kaido
R6: Whitbeard
R7: Buggy (since technically the RHM would be Mihawk)

PQ:

 

[Jiihad]

Best Yonko: it’s WhiteBeard he’s got tha best attributes from tha others

1. Kaidous strength
2. Shanks presence/cool factor
3. Teech’s abilities or vice versa I should say
4. Big Moms massive crew and ally size
5. And buggy’s charisma

Strongest is either Kaidou or WhiteBeard before he got off his meds. Followed by Shanks and Teech, then LinLin and Buggy in a heated death match for last place

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

1. Blackbeard. Dude makes an excellent parallel to Luffy, he went from a nobody, to Yonko in only a single year.
2. The dude who got an admiral on his side with the power of spoken word only
3. Whitebeard is the most badass character in the manga.
4. Subjective. Blackbeard's design is the most piratey, Kaido looks like a proper monster, and BM is the most unique. Not sure imo.
5. The Yami Yami is one of the most interesting in the series.
6. Cross Guild if they get a few other warlords, but otherwise the Blackbeard Pirates. They are the only crew that feels like proper pirates.
7. Best is subjective. I think Shiryu's the coolest looking, but the others outside of Beckmen have showed they can be pretty competent.

Personal Question: Blackbeard, as you can probably tell by my answers.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Whitebeard or Buggy easy

 

[GUI VI]

Whitebeard or Buggy easy

What about the questions?

 

[Sir Yasheen]

What about the questions?

1. Buggy
2. Buggy
3. Whitebeard
4. Whitebeard
5. Whitebeard/Buggy
6. Buggy
7. Buggy - Croc and Mihawk are the best RHM

My favorite: Buggy

 

[drumming_seawizard]

•R1: Blackbeard
•R2: Whitebeard
•R3: Whitebeard
•R4: Blackbeard
•R5: Whitebeard
•R6: Shanks
•R7: Shanks
•Personal Question: Blackbeard

 

[zenox]

Wb is the gigachad of onepiece

 

[Philosoraptor]

Who is the Best Yonkou?
(Luffy is not included.)
- Kaido

- Shanks

- Blackbeard

- Big Mom

- Old Whitebeard

- Buggy The Genius Jester

I'll split this question into 7 Rounds:
•R1: Which one has the best Development?
•R2: Which one has more charisma?
•R3: Which one is more badass?
•R4: Which one has the best design?
•R5: Which one has the best (not the strongest) DF? (in this question, Teach is only with Yami Yami)
•R6: Which one has the coolest crew?
•R7: Which one has the best Right-Hand?
•Personal Question: Which one is YOUR FAVORITE?

​

1. Big Mom
2. Shanks
3. Kaido
4. Kaido
5. Big Mom
6. Whitebeard
7. Whitebeard

8. I like the ex Rocks members equally

 

[Fujishiro]

Gurarara

 

[zzShinichi]

•R1: Which one has the best Development? Whitebeard
•R2: Which one has more charisma? Whitebeard
•R3: Which one is more badass? Shanks
•R4: Which one has the best design? Whitebeard
•R5: Which one has the best (not the strongest) DF? (in this question, Teach is only with Yami Yami) Whitebeard
•R6: Which one has the coolest crew? Shanks
•R7: Which one has the best Right-Hand? Shanks
•Personal Question: Which one is YOUR FAVORITE? Whitebeard

 

[GUI VI]

Wb is the gigachad of onepiece

 

[BillSlipton]

Whitebeard for literally all of them

 

[Sir Yasheen]

@Rottkins need to represent!

 

[GUI VI]

@Rottkins need to represent!

 

[DarkWitch]

R1: Blackbeard
R2: Shanks
R3: Shanks
R4: Kaido
R5: Whitebeard
R6: Shanks
R7: Shanks
Personal Question: Which one is YOUR FAVORITE?: Blackbeard

 

[ZenZu]

•R1: Which one has the best Development?​

Blackbeard

•R2: Which one has more charisma?

Whitebeard-Shanks-Buggy

•R3: Which one is more badass?

Shanks

•R4: Which one has the best design?

Blackbeard

•R5: Which one has the best (not the strongest) DF? (in this question, Teach is only with Yami Yami)

Whitebeard

•R6: Which one has the coolest crew?

Shanks

•R7: Which one has the best Right-Hand?

Big Mom

•Personal Question: Which one is YOUR FAVORITE?

Whitebeard
​

This thread reminded me how mid Yonkou are as a group.

 

[Rottkins]

@Rottkins need to represent!

already put my vote on myself

Post automatically merged: May 19, 2023

and for each question, obviously buggy