General & Others Thoughts On Oda’s Cross Guild Idea?

[notAfanboy]

While the idea is great, but it shits on other Yonkos and their efforts.

I am confused,

1) I would hate it if they get their hands on 3 RP copies the next time we see them just because of Buggy's luck.

2) They can save Law or Kid on their way. Maybe a new alliance? Both of them have 3 RP and they just lost their crew!
Not too bad!

3) They find the man with burn scar, defeat him and take the RP. They will have the missing RP and all of the Yonkos will be on their ass.
It will be fun to see how they react to this.
It will open up new possibilities and may give us the fights we were waiting for.

4) Any other possibility?

I dont see them directly confronting Shanks, BB or SHs though.

 

[Mathias]

People on this thread be like

Spoiler

 

[bluefire12]

Solid group
Wonder how they will tie in with the Rox plotline?
Supernovas must have motive to deal with this guild
I wonder if Cross Guild fleet is stronger than Luffy
Looks like Crocodile is acting like a loan shark to powerful pirates

 

[Urouge D. Rouge]

Wish it'd come earlier tbh

 

[Gol D. Roger]

It's a clever idea and one hell of a way to force Mihawk into the throne wars.

 

[Herrera95]

The idea is somewhat good but Mihawk doesn't seem to fit that too much giving the personality Oda gave him.

In fact Mihawk is very controversial. Oda try to makes him a lonely wolf that seeks challenge but having him as Shichibukai basically goes against it.

 

[NAMELESS]

A genius way to make Mihawk vs Zoro 2 happen,while bringing back old fan favorites like Buggy and Crocodile.

 

[straightforward]

People on this thread be like

Spoiler

it's a great film tbh tbf

just like cross guild

 

[Johnny B. Decent]

It needs more powerful people then just Crocodile and Mihawk.

 

[straightforward]

Solid group
Wonder how they will tie in with the Rox plotline?
Supernovas must have motive to deal with this guild
I wonder if Cross Guild fleet is stronger than Luffy
Looks like Crocodile is acting like a loan shark to powerful pirates

buggy is xebec's son

 

[JoNdule]

Mihawk fans went from bragging Mihawk can survive alone, he won't join anyone or else it's bad writing
To
Accepting him being Buggy's underling lol

I've never seen any legit top tier [with the right mind) in any manga be an underling a weakling

 

[Adam-san]

BB is EOS material.

If RHP and BBP were to fight plot would have BBP come out victorious

 

[The White Crane]

Strangely, I kinda feel like the Cross Guild will still be there beyond EoS, even after the SHs disband.

 

[Tejas]

Meh

 

[CensoredbyWG]

Need more cute chicks.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Convenient way to bring back old villains.
Tho I don't like Buggy's position as a torture victim

 

[CensoredbyWG]

On a serious note: if hancock and doflamingo joins and we get confirmation that mihawk and buggy are coc users, with MAYBE crocodile being one to because why not.

Crossguild could have 5 conquerors inside one crew, thats rocks pirates staff, all commanded by captain buggy

 

[Kenshiro11]

Good. So those characters can stay relevant. Also they have a proper reason to be part of the "biggest war" ever.
They cant be Shanks 2.0, show up unannounced and fuck shit up.

 

[Jay2002]

On a serious note: if hancock and doflamingo joins and we get confirmation that mihawk and buggy are coc users, with MAYBE crocodile being one to because why not.

Crossguild could have 5 conquerors inside one crew, thats rocks pirates staff, all commanded by captain buggy

hancock is never serving under buggy

 

[CensoredbyWG]

hancock is never serving under buggy

People said the same about mihawk and crocodile.