General & Others Who is The Most Replaceable Member in SHC?

[Sir WanKing]

Robin.

Apart from being a massive plot device to find the one piece now, what does she actually being into the crew?
Nothing.

lol r u mad? replace her and who can u get to read ponelgyph? just logical discussion here

 

[Desolate Smaug]

It's probably Zoro to he honest. He is just the crew combatant and the new world is full of strong fighters ready to serve strong captains like Luffy.
The rest of the crew have dual roles so their importance kinda trumps that of Zoro. And most of the crew are actually among the best in the world at what they do while poor green boy doesn't even rank top 20 as fighter in the world.

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

no mean to disagree, but every pirate crew need a sharpshooter / sniper :) maybe usopp is the only one who can use cannon LOL

Lol yeah he’s a good sniper but that’s far less important than the jobs of the other members, also there’s a ton of people in One Piece who can shoot a cannon so he’s pretty replaceable.

 

[Sir WanKing]

Lol yeah he’s a good sniper but that’s far less important than the jobs of the other members, also there’s a ton of people in One Piece who can shoot a cannon so he’s pretty replaceable.

yeah, i can't disagree to that lmao

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

It's probably Zoro to he honest. He is just the crew combatant and the new world is full of strong fighters ready to serve strong captains like Luffy.
The rest of the crew have dual roles so their importance kinda trumps that of Zoro. And most of the crew are actually among the best in the world at what they do while poor green boy doesn't even rank top 20 as fighter in the world.

The NW isn’t filled with people Zoro level lol He’s in the worst generation meaning he’s up there with the worst of the worst meaning he’s a rare commodity. Also you don’t find guys his strength just wandering around the NW.

 

[Ravagerblade]

Nami. Anybody can navigate once they learn... she herself is not vital.
Brook should be labeled fighter if he's to stay.
Usopp is fine
Franky is fine.
Chopper is fine.
Robin, eh yes and no.
Sanji is fine.

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

yeah, i can't disagree to that lmao

He’s funny though and his journey to being a strong warrior of the sea is interesting... He’s fine a long way since his introduction.

 

[Sir WanKing]

It's probably Zoro to he honest. He is just the crew combatant and the new world is full of strong fighters ready to serve strong captains like Luffy.
The rest of the crew have dual roles so their importance kinda trumps that of Zoro. And most of the crew are actually among the best in the world at what they do while poor green boy doesn't even rank top 20 as fighter in the world.

nice, quite a decent reasoning there... no mean to disagree, but i just think that zoro indirectly given the role of luffy's right hand which meant to give luffy serious advice (like what happen with usopp), so he's kinda has dual roles too imo
[automerge]1590759499[/automerge]

Nami. Anybody can navigate once they learn... she herself is not vital.
Brook should be labeled fighter if he's to stay.
Usopp is fine
Franky is fine.
Chopper is fine.
Robin, eh yes and no.
Sanji is fine.

lol everybody has their weaknesses, nobody's perfect... but choose one pls, just dont roast everybody here 😂

 

[Desolate Smaug]

The NW isn’t filled with people Zoro level lol He’s in the worst generation meaning he’s up there with the worst of the worst meaning he’s a rare commodity. Also you don’t find guys his strength just wandering around the NW.

Lol the new world is full of Zoro level dudes. Just recently Jinbei joined. People like Kata and Marco could actually join Luffy if he put his mind to it. We have people like Barto and Cavendish who are lil beat weaker but still strong enough to adequately replace him especially if two or three join. Facts.

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

nice, quite a decent reasoning there... no mean to disagree, but i just think that zoro indirectly given the role of luffy's right hand which meant to give luffy serious advice (like what happen with usopp), so he's kinda has dual roles too imo

Also replaceable means you can find someone else his strength to join the crew and to be honest that’s almost impossible. When do we ever see Yonko commander level guys just casually walking around the NW. Almost never.

 

[Sir WanKing]

He’s funny though and his journey to being a strong warrior of the sea is interesting... He’s fine a long way since his introduction.

right, imo he's actually one of few characters in op that actually got a huge character development tho... same goes to his fanbase

 

[Desolate Smaug]

nice, quite a decent reasoning there... no mean to disagree, but i just think that zoro indirectly given the role of luffy's right hand which meant to give luffy serious advice (like what happen with usopp), so he's kinda has dual roles too imo
[automerge]1590759499[/automerge]

lol everybody has their weaknesses, nobody's perfect... but choose one pls, just dont roast everybody here 😂

I disagree he doesn't have dual roles. Everyone is actually always advising Luffy. If that gives Zoro a duo role the rest of the crew have tri-roles

 

[Sir WanKing]

I disagree he doesn't have dual roles. Everyone is actually always advising Luffy. If that gives Zoro a duo role the rest of the crew have tri-roles

lol, luffy loves being the child of his own crew

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

Lol the new world is full of Zoro level dudes. Just recently Jinbei joined. People like Kata and Marco could actually join Luffy if he put his mind to it. We have people like Barto and Cavendish who are lil beat weaker but still strong enough to adequately replace him especially if two or three join. Facts.

Jinbei Is weaker than Zoro. Barto and Cavendish are scrubs compared to Zoro lol. Marco and Kata wouldn’t Join Luffy as well since one is already a commander in a crew and the other has chosen to take care of his pop’s village.

Things is it’s not really possible to find new characters as strong as Zoro who don’t are willing to join the crew. There are billions of people in the O.P worlds and only 25 or so are stronger than Zoro... that’s elite level strength.

Brook, Chopper, Usopp and Nami are fat more replaceable. It’s asking who’s the MOST replaceable.

 

[XGoldrogeRX]

zoro. because he is the only one who has no essential role in the ship except as fighter.even as a Hella fighter his role isnt matter since luffy is great fighter and could get other formidable fighter like zoro. after all his best ability is attracts and gain friend. but his loyality to luffy is unmatched.

brooks is comes second.but brooks good at surveillance mission.

 

[Ravagerblade]

nice, quite a decent reasoning there... no mean to disagree, but i just think that zoro indirectly given the role of luffy's right hand which meant to give luffy serious advice (like what happen with usopp), so he's kinda has dual roles too imo
[automerge]1590759499[/automerge]

lol everybody has their weaknesses, nobody's perfect... but choose one pls, just dont roast everybody here 😂

Nami.

 

[CaptainJackSparrow]

zoro. because he is the only one who has no essential role in the ship except as fighter.even as a Hella fighter his role isnt matter since luffy is great fighter and could get other formidable fighter like zoro. after all his best ability is attracts and gain friend. but his loyality to luffy is unmatched.

brooks is comes second.but brooks good at surveillance mission.

You can’t get another good fighter like Zoro anywhere lol. You have a ton of navigators, doctors, musicians, Cooks, Snipers all over the NW. But it’s rare to have a second in command as strong as Zoro (which has been said many times in One Piece).

 

[Desolate Smaug]

Jinbei Is weaker than Zoro. Barto and Cavendish are scrubs compared to Zoro lol. Marco and Kata wouldn’t Join Luffy as well since one is already a commander in a crew and the other has chosen to take care of his pop’s village.

Things is it’s not really possible to find new characters as strong as Zoro who don’t are willing to join the crew. There are billions of people in the O.P worlds and only 25 or so are stronger than Zoro... that’s elite level strength.

Brook, Chopper, Usopp and Nami are fat more replaceable. It’s asking who’s the MOST replaceable.

Jinbei is stronger and infamous than Zoro. Cavendish is infamous more experience and in Zoro range. Barto is a super rookie just like Zoro.
It's possible to find many people even stronger than Zoro to join the crew.
Meanwhile the likes of Nami, Robin, Sanji etc are the absolute best at what they do.

 

[Formerly Seth]

Usopp ofc.
Imagine his dad's reaction if he founds out that Usopp is not even YC level

 

[Desolate Smaug]

Muscle is literally the easiest commodity to find in the new world. Strong pirates literally force the next level of pirates to serve them and even Luffy doesn't need that due to his ability to make attract people