Yeah, Roger's a Swordsman. I don't see anything controversial about that honestly, atleast with Shanks, Mihawk vs Shanks is a discussion that's been on for years, Roger being a Swordsman doesn't really change much the way I see it, him and Newgate were near equals and he had the Pirate King title, unless Oda claims Rayleigh was World's Strongest Swordsman or something that causes a fuss, I don't see why anyone would be opposed to Roger, who wileds a sword and matched Whitebeard just fine in combat with it, being a Swordsman.