News One Piece Live Action Series!!

[Dark-Abel]

They can merge all the arcs into one for all I care, they need to respect the characters moments and Arlong park and Hachi was important for Zoro's character.
If I'm seeing Zoro losing stuff and other characters involved in things they weren't in the manga I won't stand up and clap like a bot.

I'm hearing rumors they are skipping Drum Island and Chopper in season 2

 

[AverageNamiEnjoyer]

No lol, not in there case xD
Don't try to turn my own argumentation against me, it won't work lol

Sanji and Zoro are two very different character whose role can not be fullfilled by someone else ( unless this character is weird as F)



Oh come on, why everything has to be a fight with you ?

And Hachi and Arlong are two different character.
Saboady park and Arlong Park are parallel to each other.
Arlong Park is replica of saboady Park.
Hachi play important role in introducing the real antagonist " world government "
You can't just say we can replace him because he have too many hands.

 

[Lor D. Coast]

.

I'm hearing rumors they are skipping Drum Island and Chopper in season 2

Skip Brook too.

 

[Logiko]

And Hachi and Arlong are two different character.
Saboady park and Arlong Park are parallel to each other.
Arlong Park is replica of saboady Park.
Hachi play important role in introducing the real antagonist " world government "
You can't just say we can replace him because he have too many hands.

Do you really think we will go to Sabaody in the live action ?

 

[AverageNamiEnjoyer]

to be fair that is a bad comparison from you

Not really he said you can replace character then why not do it with every single character.

Do you really think we will go to Sabaody in the live action ?

I don't think it should even exist

 

[Logiko]

Not really he said you can replace character then why not do it with every single character.

No, I said that if the purpose of one character that is too difficult to create can be done in another way, then we should do it that way.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

I don't agree, the purpose of the many and many occurence in term of plot line has a purpose. It creates a repetition that helps the theme to be more vivid. Actually, Oda cuts a LOT of thing you can see that everywhere.

But I get that some people might be upset not to see Hachi

I see the live action as its own thing. The manga will always be the original and it won't disappear.

No, it means that there purpose can be fullfilled by something else. They are important in the manga, but in the live action things must be adapted differently.

You don't have to like the live action, no problem with that.

to be fair that is a bad comparison from you

He is being sarcastic

 

[Logiko]

I see the live action as its own thing. The manga will always be the original and it won't disappear.

Exactly, the live action is a work of creation, this is "live action One Piece" not "One Piece". Its another vision on the story.

 

[AverageNamiEnjoyer]

No, I said that if the purpose of one character that is too difficult to create can be done in another way, then we should do it that way.

Yeah I agree with you.
That's why I am saying we should apply it to every character.
They already doing it with arcs.

 

[Logiko]

Yeah I agree with you.
That's why I am saying we should apply it to every character.
They already doing it with arcs.

 

[AL sama]

Not really he said you can replace character then why not do it with every single character.

some minor characters can be removed to be fa8r

they certainly can't adapt everything

however they can't and shouldn't remove important ones

as for zoro and sanji they are the main cast hence I said your comparison is bad

 

[AverageNamiEnjoyer]

zoro and sanji they are the main cast hence I said your comparison is bad

That's why I used Zoro and Sanji as example.
I am just taking it to extreme.
Of course main character can't be replaced.

 

[Franz]

Hachi play important role in introducing the real antagonist " world government "

You assume too much that they get there.

 

[AL sama]

No, I said that if the purpose of one character that is too difficult to create can be done in another way, then we should do it that way.

then should chopper be replaced by a new human character??

also how should they make fishman island arc??

what about brook or shirahoshi??

 

[Logiko]

then should chopper be replaced by a new human character??

No because Chopper is too important in term of narration.

what about brook or shirahoshi??

I don't see those to has very difficult to make. The problem with Hachi is his tentacule, it demands a total creation of the character in CGI and when Brook is stiff or Shiraoshi just big, tentacules are very hard to do.

also how should they make fishman island arc??

But I guess that if we go there, we will have a lot more budjet and therefore be able to make a lot of cool fishmen

 

[AL sama]

No because Chopper is too important in term of narration.



I don't see those to has very difficult to make. The problem with Hachi is his tentacule, it demands a total creation of the character in CGI and when Brook is stiff or Shiraoshi just big, tentacules are very hard to do.



But I guess that if we go there, we will have a lot more budjet and therefore be able to make a lot of cool fishmen

 

[Logiko]

What ?

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

No because Chopper is too important in term of narration.



I don't see those to has very difficult to make. The problem with Hachi is his tentacule, it demands a total creation of the character in CGI and when Brook is stiff or Shiraoshi just big, tentacules are very hard to do.



But I guess that if we go there, we will have a lot more budjet and therefore be able to make a lot of cool fishmen

maybe they are introducing Hachi with Camie and Pappag, if the LA ever gets this far

 

[AL sama]

what I think would've been proper is redesigning hatchi rather than removing him

 

[Logiko]

What ?

Oh yeah.. Hachi doesn't have tentacule, just 6 arms my bad LUL