Questions & Mysteries why would itachi tell sasuke to kill his best friend?

[Tai long]

I don't get it, if itachi was a good guy why would he tell his brother to kill his best friend

 

[matt245]

Did Sasuke already have the MS? If not, then that's a possibility. If yes, then Itachi was a bad guy since the beginning but Kishimoto changed it in the last moment

 

[soheilhazrat]

Did Sasuke already have the MS? If not, then that's a possibility. If yes, then Itachi was a bad guy since the beginning but Kishimoto changed it in the last moment

No Itachi told him to kill his Best friend to gain eyes as powerful as him. He was talking about MS.

But Sasuje refused to kill Naruto after their battle at the end of part 1 since he didnt want to become strong in same way as itachi

 

[Tai long]

Did Sasuke already have the MS? If not, then that's a possibility. If yes, then Itachi was a bad guy since the beginning but Kishimoto changed it in the last moment

I know but shouldn't this moment have made it impossible to retcon itachi to be a good guy. and why does killing your family still make him a good guy
[automerge]1693344010[/automerge]
w

No Itachi told him to kill his Best friend to gain eyes as powerful as him. He was talking about MS.

But Sasuje refused to kill Naruto after their battle at the end of part 1 since he didnt want to become strong in same way as itachi

why would a good guy tell his baby brother to be a murderer

 

[NAMELESS]

I don't get it, if itachi was a good guy why would he tell his brother to kill his best friend

To get the MS I suppose,but that would probably make him a rogue ninja too.I think Kishimoto retconned Itachi.

 

[lee33]

You obviously were speed reading Naruto. It was already explained, Itachi wanted Sasuke to gain MS and in order to do that you have to kill someone close to you. Duh Itachi is a murderer Einstein, he killed his entire clan. Itachi cared more about Sasuke than anything else.

 

[NAMELESS]

You obviously were speed reading Naruto. It was already explained, Itachi wanted Sasuke to gain MS and in order to do that you have to kill someone close to you. Duh Itachi is a murderer Einstein, he killed his entire clan. Itachi cared more about Sasuke than anything else.

yeah,but wouldn't that make Sasuke a rouge ninja too?

 

[Enma]

Tbh he didn't tell him to kill his best friend, he said that killing your best friend is a way to obtain MS. And Itachi was never said to be a good guy, he is a good soldier first and foremost that put loyalty to his country above loyalty to his family.

 

[lee33]

yeah,but wouldn't that make Sasuke a rouge ninja too?

Yep, Sasuke was a rouge ninja.

 

[NAMELESS]

Sasuke was a rouge ninja.

Well,he said that shit before Sasuke became one.Itachi planned for Sasuke to become a hero for Konoha.

 

[soheilhazrat]

why would a good guy tell his baby brother to be a murderer

cuz he wanted sasuke to become strong enough to defeat him and after he is dead sasuke to be strong enough to not need itachi's protection from the shadows anymore?
Did u even read the series? U are trying so hard to find a plot hole but u just keep failing

 

[lee33]

Well,he said that shit before Sasuke became one.Itachi planned for Sasuke to become a hero for Konoha.

He planned for Sasuke to be the hero who killed the person who was responsible of murdering an entire clan.

 

[NAMELESS]

He planned for Sasuke to be the hero who killed the person who was responsible of murdering an entire clan.

yep,a hero doesnt go around killing his friends btw

 

[soheilhazrat]

yep,a hero doesnt go around killing his friends btw

Kakashi is laughing at your face
[automerge]1693347075[/automerge]
Kakashi killed his friend and they gave him the nickname hero of the sharingan lmao

killing a friend isnt as big thing as u make it to be. Specially a nobody genin that itachi thought sasuke would he friends with

 

[lee33]

yep,a hero doesnt go around killing his friends btw

Danzo and Itachi before he murdered his clan, killed leaf ninjas and were still considered heros of the leaf. You can't put real life morals and place into a fictional story. Also, from what I recall, Sasuke becoming a hero of the leaf, was in the words of Tobi, not Itachi.

 

[NAMELESS]

Kakashi is laughing at your face

Itachi was wrong.He was no hero.He didnt save anyone.He killed his clan and became a spy and killer for hire.Itachi is the incarnation of "good intentions pave the road to hell".
[automerge]1693347110[/automerge]

Kakashi is laughing at your face
[automerge]1693347075[/automerge]
Kakashi killed his friend and they gave him the nickname hero of the sharingan lmao

killing a friend isnt as big thing as u make it to be. Specially a nobody genin that itachi thought sasuke would he friends with

i read that as Itachi.Kakashi's case was exceptional.

 

[soheilhazrat]

Itachi was wrong.He was no hero.He didnt save anyone.He killed his clan and became a spy and killer for hire.Itachi is the incarnation of "good intentions pave the road to hell".
[automerge]1693347110[/automerge]

i read that as Itachi.Kakashi's case was exceptional.

That why itachi is such great and complex character there is no good in what he did but what else could he done? No body can say he is wrong nor right.

 

[NAMELESS]

That why itachi is such great and complex character there is no good in what he did but what else could he done? No body can say he is wrong nor right.

I agree,he is an anti-hero of sorts.

 

[Tai long]

You obviously were speed reading Naruto. It was already explained, Itachi wanted Sasuke to gain MS and in order to do that you have to kill someone close to you. Duh Itachi is a murderer Einstein, he killed his entire clan. Itachi cared more about Sasuke than anything else.

Won’t that make sasuke a bad guy and if he makes his brother a bad guy won’t that make him a bad guy
[automerge]1693347594[/automerge]

That why itachi is such great and complex character there is no good in what he did but what else could he done? No body can say he is wrong nor right.

He is wrong he killed innocent uchiha there is no two sides to it. He is a murderer, he killed innocent people

 

[soheilhazrat]

Won’t that make sasuke a bad guy and if he makes his brother a bad guy won’t that make him a bad guy
[automerge]1693347594[/automerge]

He is wrong he killed innocent uchiha there is no two sides to it. He is a murderer, he killed innocent people

Life isnt as black and white as u think it is