Ok. Idk why you keep bringing Yonko up to me when I never mentioned them but my guy is the main character so I don't have to worry while you do, since antagonists lose. If you kept up that's what I said since the start but hey I guess that was too advanced a thought for you.
Gooffy still can lose.
 
I'm gonna make myself a lot of enemies but I think Robert is a bit overrated.
Obviously he's an elite fighter but Rhaegar wasn't all that to begin with so I dont think beating him put Robert on the same tier as Dayne/Selmy/Jaime
Gregor is even bigger and stronger than Robert which are Robert's main strengths.
I think Gregor wins
Top tier of ASOIAF

God tier: Euron Greyjoy
Top tier: Daemon Targaryen, Arthur Dayne, Barristan Selmy, Jaime Lannister, Robert Baratheon
 

Elder Lee Hung

Conqueror of the Stars
Wouldn’t be the first time a Targaryen won a tourney because their opponents were scared to hurt them. lol

He did but only once.
There's quite enough in the books that show he wasnt anywhere near as good as Selmy or Dayne in a fight though
Like what? Iirc all we have from Rhaegar is that he beat Barristan in a joust and lost to Robert
 
Top