I feel like a monarchy would be a good compromise to the situation. Monarchy was how Islam was able to rule over india despite being a minority.

> make judaism the state religion
> have the monarchy marry a jewish israeli to someone from one of the arab royal families of the middle east
> include specific protections in the constitution for Christians, Muslims, and Druze, so everyone has equal rights

basically make Israel like the Mughal empire.

Alternatively they could just have a western democracy, but idk how successful that would be in the region. I feel like israel offers a type of security to the jewish people that they won't just willingly relinquish. Plus I wouldn't be surprised if, were the palestinians to gain power(as they would in a democracy), they might do some pretty awful stuff to the israelis in revenge for the past decades.

Stuff like that did happen in certain african countries. I think in uganda or zimbabwe, there was some sort of expelling of whites and indians once africans took power.
Wtf is this shit? No, a one state solution has to end up having a secular government. Monarchy? who are we the saudis? THese people want rights, you can't take away the possibility of freedom just because you think they'll do something awful.
 
Wtf is this shit? No, a one state solution has to end up having a secular government. Monarchy? who are we the saudis? THese people want rights, you can't take away the possibility of freedom just because you think they'll do something awful.
You Americans are not Saudis,but this is a middle eastern problem and democracies like we have in the west is not something that is standard there.Palestinians becoming Israelis would cause an internal political problem and would eventually become an existential threat to Israel.They need to create a Palestinian state there.
Post automatically merged:

Wtf is this shit? No, a one state solution has to end up having a secular government. Monarchy? who are we the saudis? THese people want rights, you can't take away the possibility of freedom just because you think they'll do something awful.
Also,are you familiar with constitutional monarchies(japan,england and so on...)?
Post automatically merged:



lol at how blatant "israeli lives are worth more than your lives" is to them
Post automatically merged:


israel needs to accept multiculturalism. its 2023. we can't have one race own one country and kill everyone else anymore. isnt that what they say?
Do you really think Israel will make Muslim Palestinians citizens?They know damn well how this will end eventually.It will work for a decade,after that they will probably have a civil war in their hands.
 
Also,are you familiar with constitutional monarchies(japan,england and so on...)?
I hate them, but it's preferable than an actual monarchy.

You Americans are not Saudis,but this is a middle eastern problem and democracies like we have in the west is not something that is standard there.Palestinians becoming Israelis would cause an internal political problem and would eventually become an existential threat to Israel.They need to create a Palestinian state there.
Palestinians on the ground want democracy for themselves. I don't know what the solution is here, I'm not a proponent of neither a one state solution or a two state solution. I know how this is going to end tho.
 
I hate them, but it's preferable than an actual monarchy.



Palestinians on the ground want democracy for themselves. I don't know what the solution is here, I'm not a proponent of neither a one state solution or a two state solution. I know how this is going to end tho.
Only Saudi Arabia is an absolutist Monarchy nowadays.
I hate them, but it's preferable than an actual monarchy.



Palestinians on the ground want democracy for themselves. I don't know what the solution is here, I'm not a proponent of neither a one state solution or a two state solution. I know how this is going to end tho.
I don't see any other solution than the two state solution.The way things are escalating,Zionists will end up just wiping Palestine off the map.All these attacks actually go into Israel's favor since they can justify more occupations and settlements.
Post automatically merged:

I agree on the monarchy, the kingdom of Jerusalem shall be rebuilt
The world needs a new Baldwin IV.
 
Last edited:
Wtf is this shit? No, a one state solution has to end up having a secular government. Monarchy? who are we the saudis? THese people want rights, you can't take away the possibility of freedom just because you think they'll do something awful.
I don't know how stable a democracy would be. I think the two sides just hate each other too much for that to work. I don't think democracy works in every single region in the world.

Some regions just seem to be better governed without democracy. Places like Russia and China have never had democracy. And honestly that's fine.

I think a monarchy or a communist dictatorship would probably serve as a unifying force and create a common national identity.
 
I don't know how stable a democracy would be. I think the two sides just hate each other too much for that to work. I don't think democracy works in every single region in the world.

Some regions just seem to be better governed without democracy. Places like Russia and China have never had democracy. And honestly that's fine.

I think a monarchy or a communist dictatorship would probably serve as a unifying force and create a common national identity.
Israel could do democracy....


Palestine on the other hand, has 0 chance to pull that off...
 
I don't see any other solution than the two state solution.The way things are escalating,Zionists will end up just wiping Palestine off the map.All these attacks actually go into Israel's favor since they can justify more occupations and settlements.
On a tactical sense this is a major Hamas mistake - killing and capturing unrelated civilians from other countries[/QUOTE]
yeah,but they probably couldn't distinguish who is who in the chaos of fighting.

I don't know how stable a democracy would be. I think the two sides just hate each other too much for that to work. I don't think democracy works in every single region in the world.

Some regions just seem to be better governed without democracy. Places like Russia and China have never had democracy. And honestly that's fine.

I think a monarchy or a communist dictatorship would probably serve as a unifying force and create a common national identity.
monarchy?yeah.Communist dictatorship?wtf,bro?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Israel could do democracy....


Palestine on the other hand, has 0 chance to pull that off...
why?
Post automatically merged:

Communism has the ability to unify a diverse group of people under a singular goal.

Look at the USSR
You do realize those countries were subjected to numerous violations of human rights,right?Communism is a vile a regime disguised as an humanitarian Utopia.In the name of equality they create a class of extremely poor citizens and a class of rich and powerful rulers.
 
why?
Post automatically merged:


You do realize those countries were subjected to numerous violations of human rights,right?Communism is a vile a regime disguised as an humanitarian Utopia.In the name of equality they create a class of extremely poor citizens and a class of rich and powerful rulers.
It would be better than the current system in israel
 
To summarise then, fighting back by whatever means, is justified. Wether that's bombing homes, hospitals, schools etc as they're fighting invading terrorists.

By that same logic, there shouldn't be any complaints about how Palestinians choose to fight back against the invading nazi zionist terrorists. They're only defending their lands and people.

If someone had told me this years back, I could've saved myself from a lot of back and forth on this topic
 
To summarise then, fighting back by whatever means, is justified. Wether that's bombing homes, hospitals, schools etc as they're fighting invading terrorists.

By that same logic, there shouldn't be any complaints about how Palestinians choose to fight back against the invading nazi zionist terrorists. They're only defending their lands and people.

If someone had told me this years back, I could've saved myself from a lot of back and forth on this topic
Fighting back is acceptable,but targeting civilians is not.Even back in the middle ages this was seen as a disgusting and cowardly act,despite it being common ofc.Hamas should have focused the ground attack on military targets.Now they gave Israel the excuse they needed to deploy never before seen force on the gaza strip.
 
Top