Yea, it doesn't really matter.
I'm not saying the read is perfect, I sort've just picked Michelle at random between her and Luka because I remembered something from Michelle before. I think the mafia jumps on the winning wagon late, usually staying off till the end waiting to see if a better option arises.
Hayumi is my strongest read, but it's a pure read. Mechanically I think Ichigo/Luka/Michelle is good. But like, 1000% the Seatonnes and Cakewalker wagons Day 1 contains at least one wolf, probably 2.
What about Ichigo, I see someone else voting him.