General & Others Next Straw Hat Crew Members and the Grand Fleet
- Thread starter Uncle Van
- Start date
- Tags #c4ng2g carrot fans are still losers carrot haters are real losers seethe at the rabbit carrot is doing nothing because she doesn't matter carrot will never join the straw hats carrot's story never even began cry about carrot everyone else in the verse neg diffs the bunny imagine thinking stussy won't join its over furry bros keep the bunny on zou nobody else needs her let it go furry bros momo is breeding yamato no character is less relevant than carrot oden larper fans can't read stussy > carrot & yamato stussy supremacy who will be the next nakama of the week? yamato always had a better chance than carrot yamato story is over
@Logiko I am not sure, if I should try to insist on getting an answer from you, but I think I will leave it at that.
Instead, I just want to have a final confirmation from you regarding this part of your theory of your Golden five rules, Number 4A.
In your theory, you said the following regarding the redemption of an antagonist: „The same can not be said for One Piece, where death carries a lot of weight. So murdering psychopath can’t have the same redemption arc. But there is another parameter that can be juxtaposed to death: Suffering. In some cases, suffering can be seen as something even more serious than death. Suffering makes people cry, suffering – in One Piece – can be traumatizing. That is why a character who willingly made a lot of people suffer can’t have a complete redemption arc.”
I just want to know from you, if your rules mean that Lucci is not able to have the slightest chance of becoming a redeemed Strawhat at all, because he made other people suffer and probably has killed a few people during his assassin-career. Do I understand that correctly?
Instead, I just want to have a final confirmation from you regarding this part of your theory of your Golden five rules, Number 4A.
In your theory, you said the following regarding the redemption of an antagonist: „The same can not be said for One Piece, where death carries a lot of weight. So murdering psychopath can’t have the same redemption arc. But there is another parameter that can be juxtaposed to death: Suffering. In some cases, suffering can be seen as something even more serious than death. Suffering makes people cry, suffering – in One Piece – can be traumatizing. That is why a character who willingly made a lot of people suffer can’t have a complete redemption arc.”
I just want to know from you, if your rules mean that Lucci is not able to have the slightest chance of becoming a redeemed Strawhat at all, because he made other people suffer and probably has killed a few people during his assassin-career. Do I understand that correctly?
Post automatically merged:
@Rambles you see this bro 
it’s happening
Finally some realistic Nakama possibilities and not like carrot
it’s happening
Post automatically merged:
Finally some realistic Nakama possibilities and not like carrot
I think I’ve managed to create a system that is better than NoLogikos to determine the next Nakama.
here are the rules
here are the rules
- Be a character in one piece
- Be close enough(distance) to the strawhats so that Luffy can invite you
- Have multiple unique abilities. If one is good more is better
- The save. Luffy needs to save your sorry ass
- Glowing friendship activity
Last edited:
I think I’ve managed to create a system that is better than NoLogikos to determine the next Nakama.
here are the rules
here are the rules
- Be a character in one piece
- Be close enough(distance) to the strawhats so that Luffy can invite you
- Have multiple unique abilities. If one is good more is better
- The save. Luffy needs to save your sorry ass
- Glowing friendship activ
I know. I wonder if @Sigran101 can debunk my system as easily as he did with C4N
I have made my own set of pillars aswell to determine next nakama. 
1. Exists
2. Exists in the One piece manga, other mangas don't count
3. Massive bazoongas (female required)
4. Dreams:
4.a) Post- Wano character: Her parents/people have dreamed about the legends of sun god Goofy epicenter of all, he is the profecy boy who will free/help their people to some new dawn/freedom/dancing/etc
4.b) Pre- Wano character: She wants to meet her pet octopus in the Grand line or something
5. Role, something the Straw hats never needed but suddenly need for one arc but never gets brought up again
6. Sweatdrop power scalings, she must sweat a lot to determine the correct power level
7. Luffy knows of their existence (optional)
I'm still developing more ty for your patience, please don't @ me with your ridicoulus illogical critics.
1. Exists
2. Exists in the One piece manga, other mangas don't count
3. Massive bazoongas (female required)
4. Dreams:
4.a) Post- Wano character: Her parents/people have dreamed about the legends of sun god Goofy epicenter of all, he is the profecy boy who will free/help their people to some new dawn/freedom/dancing/etc
4.b) Pre- Wano character: She wants to meet her pet octopus in the Grand line or something
5. Role, something the Straw hats never needed but suddenly need for one arc but never gets brought up again
6. Sweatdrop power scalings, she must sweat a lot to determine the correct power level
7. Luffy knows of their existence (optional)
I'm still developing more ty for your patience, please don't @ me with your ridicoulus illogical critics.
No he doesn't. He doesn't pass the test of the 5 golden rules. He is not an ally neither a false adversary.
Yes. Lucci made people like Robin suffer, but other people as well, and he is a pathological killer so he doesn't fit this rule.
That's a start lol
lol
Yes. Lucci made people like Robin suffer, but other people as well, and he is a pathological killer so he doesn't fit this rule.
- Be a character in one piece
- Be close enough(distance) to the strawhats so that Luffy can invite you
- Have multiple unique abilities. If one is good more is better
- The save. Luffy needs to save your sorry ass
- Glowing friendship activity
I have made my own set of pillars aswell to determine next nakama.
1. Exists
2. Exists in the One piece manga, other mangas don't count
3. Massive bazoongas (female required)
4. Dreams:
4.a) Post- Wano character: Her parents/people have dreamed about the legends of sun god Goofy epicenter of all, he is the profecy boy who will free/help their people to some new dawn/freedom/dancing/etc
4.b) Pre- Wano character: She wants to meet her pet octopus in the Grand line or something
5. Role, something the Straw hats never needed but suddenly need for one arc but never gets brought up again
6. Sweatdrop power scalings, she must sweat a lot to determine the correct power level
7. Luffy knows of their existence (optional)
I'm still developing more ty for your patience, please don't @ me with your ridicoulus illogical critics.
1. Exists
2. Exists in the One piece manga, other mangas don't count
3. Massive bazoongas (female required)
4. Dreams:
4.a) Post- Wano character: Her parents/people have dreamed about the legends of sun god Goofy epicenter of all, he is the profecy boy who will free/help their people to some new dawn/freedom/dancing/etc
4.b) Pre- Wano character: She wants to meet her pet octopus in the Grand line or something
5. Role, something the Straw hats never needed but suddenly need for one arc but never gets brought up again
6. Sweatdrop power scalings, she must sweat a lot to determine the correct power level
7. Luffy knows of their existence (optional)
I'm still developing more ty for your patience, please don't @ me with your ridicoulus illogical critics.