I mean, yes I do think Lodestar is more important than God Valley itself considering it houses the revelation of the RPs and is the physically last island before LT.
You could be right in that there is some signficance between him going to Lodestar 39 years prior and then only a year later, God Valley, but as far as we know, the 4th RP was in FI and now the Burned Man has it.
If the Burned Man is Rocks, I guess I can see the island having some signficance outside of it moving, otherwise, I only see it as a major event between characters.
The issue, again, is design. Oda is showing God Valley, but he isnt showing Elbaf, Lodestar and Laugh Tale. I used to include God Valley here, but then unceremoniously revealed the island fully last chapter in not even a double spread.