Character Discussion If Zoro didn’t exist would Mihawk have any fans?

[Juanpiz]

Okay then get those people and filter out the ones who like Mihawk for his actual character writing and then ask those ones what they think of Cross Guild

Post automatically merged: Nov 4, 2023

@Juanpiz he has no more personality. Now he does whatever the plot wants him to do even when it doesn’t fit his personality

when the marines started hunting him, his personality was that he has been bored and now he is getting excited from being hunted… Then Oda changed his mind decided thatwi actually Mihawk doesn’t want to fight the marines and would just like to join Cross guild

then when he joins cross guild he clearly has no respect for buggy and refuses to do anything buggy says… but the plot wants him to do what buggy says so he simply lets buggy boss him around FOR NO REASON

With personality I mean calm, cultured(wine, castle), nice (Perona
..)

 

[Senfret]

I like Mihawk over Zoro, though I like them both

 

[Midnight Delight]

Would Shanks be popular if he wasn't Luffy's mentor

Would Roger be popular if he isn't Luffy's Benchmark

Dumb question

 

[ImmaIvanoM]

With personality I mean calm, cultured(wine, castle), nice (Perona
..)

With personality I mean character traits that come together to inform the specifics of a characters actions and reactions to things

for example is Mihawk a proud man? He was making fun of Zoro for abandoning his pride by asking for his help to train him. You’d think Mihawk is a proud man from this right? Well how the fuck is him bowing down and following Buggy’s random whims not a complete destruction of his character? Is it not EVEN LESS prideful for him to simply follow buggy because Buggy happened to make a good speech? Is that it? One speech and Mihawk’s pride has been shaken?

I’m getting angry now just remembering this nonsense. This stuff just makes me sad to even think about. I actually once cared about character writing in one piece. That so long ago it hurts

 

[Juanpiz]

With personality I mean character traits that come together to inform the specifics of a characters actions and reactions to things

for example if Mihawk a proud man? He was making fun of Zoro for abandoning his pride by asking for his help to train him. You’d think Mihawk is a proud man from this right? Well how the fuck is him bowing down and listening and following to Buggy’s random whims not a complete destruction of his character? Is it not EVEN LESS prideful for him to simply follow buggy because Buggy happened to make a good speech? Is that it? One speech and Mihawk’s pride has been shaken?

I’m getting angry now just remember this nonsense. This stuff just makes me sad to even think about. I actually once cared about character writing in one piece. That so long ago it hurts

At least he didn't end up as a punching bag like smoker

Maybe he will show himself again in the future

 

[Sigran101]

Yes, but probably less than half of what he has now, and no one would be saying he's strongest in the verse or even stronger than Shanks.

 

[Daves John]

Yes, but probably less than half of what he has now, and no one would be saying he's strongest in the verse or even stronger than Shanks.

People would accept that World's Strongest Swordsman>Yonko swordsman way sooner if he wasn't destined to be surpassed by Luffy's subordinate.

If anything, more people would have him over Shanks

 

[zorovsanji]

Mihawk is the hisoka of op. He just seeks challenges and is a loner. He would still have huge fan base.

 

[Lor D. Coast]

Yes, there would be no bias against him and everyone would be excited to see him.