[FNZ] Role Madness One Piece East Blue Part One - Combined Pirate Crew & Bread Hunter Victory!

[Lord Melkor]

I got one from Reloaded

Do you still have it?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Scum could just shot someone with a vest today?

Unfortunately I am busy today and will not be able to ISO people much.

Did Michelle hint her role pretty early? Was Polar also a rare anima?

 

[Charlie]

I mean, everyone has said something already. If someone with vest lost it, they'd have said something.

Michelle i think hinted something like RB earlier. I mean implied that she blocked Ekko when we thought he was SK and that's why he hasn't killed anyone N1. So i'd guess if scum, she'd be their roleblocker.

 

[Rej]

Votes:
The Orca: T-Pein > Michelle
T-Pein: The Orca
Michelle: The Orca
Seatonnes: The Orca

Votecount:
The Orca: 3
Michelle: 1

Let me know if I missed anything!​

Spoiler: Players

@Lord Melkor
@Red Night
@T-Pein™
@Michelle
@Bepo D. Bear
@The Orca
@HeWhoHasNoEqual
@Seatonnes
@Charlie

 

[Lord Melkor]

I mean, everyone has said something already. If someone with vest lost it, they'd have said something.

Michelle i think hinted something like RB earlier. I mean implied that she blocked Ekko when we thought he was SK and that's why he hasn't killed anyone N1. So i'd guess if scum, she'd be their roleblocker.

Town has vests, doctor, day kill, so I quess scum could have blocker? Would Cake make a rare animal fake for scum?

Also if Orca were scum, would he not say he used his vest to defend himself?

 

[T-Pein™]

I mean, everyone has said something already. If someone with vest lost it, they'd have said something.

Michelle i think hinted something like RB earlier. I mean implied that she blocked Ekko when we thought he was SK and that's why he hasn't killed anyone N1. So i'd guess if scum, she'd be their roleblocker.

if it's some sort of 4d chess move then we just lynch michelle if orca flips town.
No need to overthink this.
not sure why scum would do this rn instead of just killing someone tho.

 

[T-Pein™]

Also if Orca were scum, would he not say he used his vest to defend himself?

cool WIFOM
Orca asked Charlie if he was shot and got his vest broken.
means he knew Charlie was the one shot and that he himself was not the one that got shot.
Otherwise he would not had asked Charlie.
Your scumbudy spilled too much info.

 

[T-Pein™]

He literally faked being a vig.
No townie would do this.
It is anti town.
If he was town he gets counterclaimed and lynched.
Exposes the real vig.
Why did he do it?
He knew there was no vig.
Why?
Because Jesse's role was literally Vig.
idk why we played the whole game thinking we had a vig tho.
Should had been obvious with kekko's flip and Jesse's role that town had no vig.
think.

 

[T-Pein™]

oh and Jesse subbed into a slot that was gonna get lynched anyways.
I was not playing d1 but Isolated Indigo.
The slot was doomed.
also the rep was not that good....
Probably asked to be bussed.

 

[T-Pein™]

I was his m8 on the last game.
He was scum and just coasted.
Didnt even submit role usages

 

[Lord Melkor]

if it's some sort of 4d chess move then we just lynch michelle if orca flips town.
No need to overthink this.
not sure why scum would do this rn instead of just killing someone tho.

If there is more than 1 scum left (i expect 2) are we not getting close to Lylo?

 

[Lord Melkor]

cool WIFOM
Orca asked Charlie if he was shot and got his vest broken.
means he knew Charlie was the one shot and that he himself was not the one that got shot.
Otherwise he would not had asked Charlie.
Your scumbudy spilled too much info.

Why would scum Orca not just say he had the vest and the vest saved him?

 

[Michelle]

Charlie wasn't even voting Jesse, he didn't push him at all. I had to ask him to vote him at the end. Don't think Michelle ever answered why she agreed with the Jesse lynch.. I mean quote stuff out of order and leave stuff out you can frame anything. Clearly you failed here cause I'm town and care

I am sure I posted why, not gonna dig now in my Iso, but i remember Fuji put more than enough hints in showing Indigo is scum and especially after last game I defended Jesse who flipped scum, I knew he can slank as scum.

@Michelle so... You knew Naomi was Gaimon when she was still alive. Why wouldn't you want to visit her?


I will, but i can't rn tbh.

I didn't. The thread was too big to read it all and if I am ISOing I start with lower posters

Scum could just shot someone with a vest today?

Unfortunately I am busy today and will not be able to ISO people much.

Did Michelle hint her role pretty early? Was Polar also a rare anima?

I am talking about my role since long ago, at first I hinted, and after I claimed.

I mean, everyone has said something already. If someone with vest lost it, they'd have said something.

Michelle i think hinted something like RB earlier. I mean implied that she blocked Ekko when we thought he was SK and that's why he hasn't killed anyone N1. So i'd guess if scum, she'd be their roleblocker.

Actually I thought no SK kill N1 was because of my RB :shrug

 

[Lord Melkor]

I am sure I posted why, not gonna dig now in my Iso, but i remember Fuji put more than enough hints in showing Indigo is scum and especially after last game I defended Jesse who flipped scum, I knew he can slank as scum.

I didn't. The thread was too big to read it all and if I am ISOing I start with lower posters

I am talking about my role since long ago, at first I hinted, and after I claimed.

Actually I thought no SK kill N1 was because of my RB :shrug

Assuming you are town what are you reads of other players, especially Orca, Tpein and Seatonnes?

 

[Charlie]

cool WIFOM
Orca asked Charlie if he was shot and got his vest broken.
means he knew Charlie was the one shot and that he himself was not the one that got shot.
Otherwise he would not had asked Charlie.
Your scumbudy spilled too much info.

Orca knew i had vest though. Why would he shot me to begin with?

 

[Michelle]

Town has vests, doctor, day kill, so I quess scum could have blocker? Would Cake make a rare animal fake for scum?

Also if Orca were scum, would he not say he used his vest to defend himself?

There is a lot of KP in the game and the vests could be gifted to mafia. It all depends on reads accuracy, so more RBers makes sense.

Why would scum Orca not just say he had the vest and the vest saved him?

Probably because there can still be a town backup taking Luka's role, or another kind of invest, I know Cake's roles are unpredictible.
A convoluted reason for wifom can be another explanation

 

[Michelle]

Orca knew i had vest though. Why would he shot me to begin with?

To pop the vest

 

[Charlie]

I believe this claim

didn't. The thread was too big to read it all and if I am ISOing I start with lower posters

I mean, this is you saying you believe Polar who's saying he has to reunite with Naomi.

I'd assume it's because you believe you have to reunite with her too.

 

[Michelle]

Assuming you are town what are you reads of other players, especially Orca, Tpein and Seatonnes?

Orca's solve having always a push on me and never reevaluating made me extremely suspicious and that's why I RBed him.
If anyone can explain why else the mafia kill failed I am all ears.
I Seatonnes is town. Everyone was happy to vote him instead the SK.
Pein is just town, and so is Charlie

 

[Lord Melkor]

Orca's solve having always a push on me and never reevaluating made me extremely suspicious and that's why I RBed him.
If anyone can explain why else the mafia kill failed I am all ears.
I Seatonnes is town. Everyone was happy to vote him instead the SK.
Pein is just town, and so is Charlie

So you think there is only one scum left?