General & Others One piece will never have

[CensoredbyWG]

Jjk will be remembered more than op
When they animate gojo vs sukuna to its over

Shonen jump have been trying to find a rival to OP ever since naruto's end and have failed ever since.

Toriko, nanatsu no taizai, boku no hero and now JJK, OP will NEVER be toppled.

JJK will be remembered for a few nice fights a d thats about it.

The reason for it? LACK OF ORIGINALITY.

 

[Apollo]

That goes for most mangas though, not just One Piece. I dont think any modern shonen had a fight with similar levels of engagement/memes online as Gojo vs Sukuna did. That fight had tension and the back-and-forth between the fighters was great.

On a sidenote, dont expect "great fights" from One Piece. Oda is currently incapable of giving any fight proper time and conclusion due to how late he is on finishing the manga.

 

[Nadel]

JJK I only saw the first episodes and it's garbage...

waiting for spoilers...Zoro I know you humiliated Lucci

 

[OneHater]

Shonen jump have been trying to find a rival to OP ever since naruto's end and have failed ever since.

Toriko, nanatsu no taizai, boku no hero and now JJK, OP will NEVER be toppled.

JJK will be remembered for a few nice fights a d thats about it.

The reason for it? LACK OF ORIGINALITY.

No.

One Piece is popular because of mysteries/lore, sob stories and world-building. One Piece has many faults but people keep coming back because they want to know what the One Piece is or what the void century is. In the meantime, every arc is an new place to explore (world-building) with heart-pulling sob stories and this keeps people engaged. OP shows that the best way to get a "popular" story is to focus on mystery, sob stories and world-building rather than plot twists or battles over anything else.

 

[Steven]

JJK is trash

 

[CensoredbyWG]

No.

One Piece is popular because of mysteries/lore, sob stories and world-building. One Piece has many faults but people keep coming back because they want to know what the One Piece is or what the void century is. In the meantime, every arc is an new place to explore (world-building) with heart-pulling sob stories and this keeps people engaged. OP shows that the best way to get a "popular" story is to focus on mystery, sob stories and world-building rather than plot twists or battles over anything else.

Still, one piece is ORIGINAL, no one even dared to copy OP due to knowing how hard it is.

Jjk is a copycat show who steals whole arcs from naruto, bleach and HxH.

 

[L57]

Still, one piece is ORIGINAL, no one even dared to copy OP due to knowing how hard it is.

Jjk is a copycat show who steals whole arcs from naruto, bleach and HxH.

Luffy is a goku clone

 

[OneHater]

Still, one piece is ORIGINAL, no one even dared to copy OP due to knowing how hard it is.

Jjk is a copycat show who steals whole arcs from naruto, bleach and HxH.

OP isn't original. Oda copied the story structure of Esteban, Child of the Sun.
I agree that JJK is a copycat show and that's why I don't watch it but it's expected that every 5-10 years you'll see a new copycat show that becomes the new big battle shonen because this genre is popular.

 

[Nadel]

No.

One Piece is popular because of mysteries/lore, sob stories and world-building. One Piece has many faults but people keep coming back because they want to know what the One Piece is or what the void century is. In the meantime, every arc is an new place to explore (world-building) with heart-pulling sob stories and this keeps people engaged. OP shows that the best way to get a "popular" story is to focus on mystery, sob stories and world-building rather than plot twists or battles over anything else.

-Nobody cares what One Piece is.

-One Piece is popular because it has many characters and most of them are of the same level.

-What unites me to One Piece is the fight for the title Zoro vs MIhawk

 

[Blahmigooo]

Yes..........Fight oriented manga would usually trumps over one piece when comparing fights.
FULL STOP

But outside of that mid piece trumps over it sadly...........You're underestimating op popularity and it's legacy.
It's too popular that it's stupid, cringey and annoying at the same time. Shit needs to end now before Oda and Shonen Jump official started milking again..........Glad there's some shonen show has made its name from barely 5 years ago and we talking about already surpassing one piece that was 20 yrs older
Let's hope it has rich material and story to tell so it can go on for another 15 years strong.......

 

[CensoredbyWG]

OP isn't original. Oda copied the story structure of Esteban, Child of the Sun.
I agree that JJK is a copycat show and that's why I don't watch it but it's expect that every 5-10 years you'll see a new copycat show that becomes the new big battle shonen because this genre is popular.

True, but other shows do their own thing or at least try too.

Boku no hero and JJK are disgusting due to how unoriginal they are.

Chainsaw man is my favorite from current gen btw.

 

[Juanpiz]

Luffy is a goku clone

Missed the part where rubber boy fell in his childhood on his head which turned him into a nice guy

 

[MonsterKaido]

Iirc G5 was trending very high when it came out.

I think Luffy vs BB or Luffy vs Imu sama has potential for it but who knows.

 

[Rej]

this thread is actually becomming funny

anyway, both JJK and One Piece's era got coffinnailed once Frieren started to air

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Its about the strongest in history vs the strongest in modern era
Fight was build up since ch 1

Oh I thought it's about a suicidal kid who eats dead body parts,my bad

 

[Juanpiz]

Oh I thought it's about a suicidal kid who eats dead body parts,my bad

Finger lickin good

 

[matt245]

If Zoro and Sanji had a 1v1

It would be the best fight
And everyone would talk about it
Give it like 5+ chs

The fight would last half a chapter, then Sanji's flashback would kick in before Zoro get's tired of his bs and one shots his ass

 

[SakazOuki]

Both are trash, but at least with JJK the author tries to give his fans some actual content and detail

 

[OneHater]

True, but other shows do their own thing or at least try too.

Boku no hero and JJK are disgusting due to how unoriginal they are.

Chainsaw man is my favorite from current gen btw.

I like CSM too and I like OPM but they're for an older demographic compared to MHA and JJK. One issue with "shonen" is that this demographic is too broad. CSM is borderline or arguably a seinen while MHA is borderline Kodomomuke and JJK is in between. The innovation in MHA is about what you'd expect from a kids show while JJK is lacking compared to its predecessors (naruto, bleach, saint seiya) but with that said OP was somewhat innovative when it came out but it hasn't been innovative in ~20 years.

Yes..........Fight oriented manga would usually trumps over one piece when comparing fights.
FULL STOP

But outside of that mid piece trumps over it sadly...........You're underestimating op popularity and it's legacy.
It's too popular that it's stupid, cringey and annoying at the same time. Shit needs to end now before Oda and Shonen Jump official started milking again..........Glad there's some shonen show has made its name from barely 5 years ago and we talking about already surpassing one piece that was 20 yrs older
Let's hope it has rich material and story to tell so it can go on for another 15 years strong.......

I don't think OP has a legacy. Lore driven stories like OP tend to fall off a cliff after the author reveals the big mystery.

 

[Bisoromi Bear]

Finger lickin good

I dropped it after 5 chapters