General & Others Unpopular Opinions?
- Thread starter Light D Lamperouge
- Start date
- Tags buggy is stronger than we think invincible kata
Carrot is ok and all plus she is super popular based on the last character poll which means Oda definitely did something correct.
However, imho she is not the best. The interaction between Nami and her are not that interesting or memorable to give her that much screentime.
What if you put Tashigi instead of Carrot with Nami in a covert op with the navigator to dig out information. The orange girl would not hesitate to use her charms to get what she wants and Tashigi would be embarrassed and shy when she tries it . When the danger comes, Nami runs away while the captain is courageous inspiring our navigator to stand her ground too. Honestly, that one scene in PH had more memorable character development for Nami than whatever happened with Carrot.
However, imho she is not the best. The interaction between Nami and her are not that interesting or memorable to give her that much screentime.
What if you put Tashigi instead of Carrot with Nami in a covert op with the navigator to dig out information. The orange girl would not hesitate to use her charms to get what she wants and Tashigi would be embarrassed and shy when she tries it . When the danger comes, Nami runs away while the captain is courageous inspiring our navigator to stand her ground too. Honestly, that one scene in PH had more memorable character development for Nami than whatever happened with Carrot.
:zorothink::kizabat:Fishmen Island flashback was worthed the entire arc imo, it was very well built: the duality between Otohime and Fisher Tiger about their point of view of human nature is just too good. The history about Otohime and Miosgard, Jinbe that decides to finally accept brotherhood between human and fishmen species sharing his blood with Luffy (where Fisher Tiger failed)... and so on so forth
Its kinda of the issue... Its the only moment where I empathized with her and that's it.
If you had to pick between Carrot and Robin to go rescue Sanji. Who would you choose ? Who would bring an emotional stake in a Straw hat rescue arc ?
Remember that scene
Imagine WCI but this time its reversed with Robin and Chopper trying to persuade Sanji. The archeologist making reference to W7 but this time around by being the one believing in our cook and trying to rescue him. It would have been a great character development for her and she needs more characterization outside the Poneglyph.
If you had to pick between Carrot and Robin to go rescue Sanji. Who would you choose ? Who would bring an emotional stake in a Straw hat rescue arc ?
Remember that scene
Imagine WCI but this time its reversed with Robin and Chopper trying to persuade Sanji. The archeologist making reference to W7 but this time around by being the one believing in our cook and trying to rescue him. It would have been a great character development for her and she needs more characterization outside the Poneglyph.
Last edited:
