Le Fishe Thread Reality check for otakus- successful combat athletes in real life are exactly like Eustass Kid, whereas the losers are like Shanks

yes admirals are villains and yet here you all are pretending that kid is a hero.
Also if you think shanks killing him despite his surrendering which they had done 2 times before and they all chose to ignore it i might add.
Then kidd is even worse than shanks for crucifying people who surrendered.
If you think shanks is bad for what he did then by your own logic kidd is several times worse
What part dont you get that we don’t care how bad the surrendering party we still don’t deem it good to murder them? You think something stops being a war crime because the other person is bad? lmao
Post automatically merged:

It's crocodile tears, though, anyone can tell they clearly didn't mean it
???

i am sorry where in the story can you tell the people who just watched his captain get stomp didn’t mean it :gokulaugh:
 
What part dont you get that we don’t care how bad the surrendering party we still don’t deem it good to murder them? You think something stops being a war crime because the other person is bad? lmao
Post automatically merged:


???

i am sorry where in the story can you tell the people who just watched his captain get stomp didn’t mean it :gokulaugh:
Bro they literally got clapped by Kaido and still came back to not only fight him but Big Mom as well
 

Peroroncino

🅷🅰🅻🅰 🅼🅰🅳🆁🅸🅳
What part dont you get that we don’t care how bad the surrendering party we still don’t deem it good to murder them? You think something stops being a war crime because the other person is bad? lmao
Post automatically merged:


???

i am sorry where in the story can you tell the people who just watched his captain get stomp didn’t mean it :gokulaugh:
oh so you agree that kid is a bigger piece of shit than shanks is then?
 
oh so you agree that kid is a bigger piece of shit than shanks is then?
It’s irrelevant to what happened. But sure, Kid is a piece of shit

I’ll go back to my example. Had the SHs murdered the surrendering beast pirates it would be jarring AF, even if they enslaved and genocided a country for 20 years

If an Admiral had done it would’ve been cool af :kayneshrug:
 
What part dont you get that we don’t care how bad the surrendering party we still don’t deem it good to murder them? You think something stops being a war crime because the other person is bad? lmao
Post automatically merged:


???

i am sorry where in the story can you tell the people who just watched his captain get stomp didn’t mean it :gokulaugh:
Bro you're treating it like its real life shit.

Manga logic works different. If shanks and co didn't do ANYTHING after KOing Kid and killer, and just let them go, who's to say that they won't recuperate and comeback and stir shit up again?

Midd pirates literally were doing that. Benn took Midd's arm off and let him go. Look what they're doing once again?

They're youngsters. shanks literally says so. They're gonna get stronger and stronger. This time, Shanks was there to protect his notoriously weak fleet. But what if he isn't there next time, against a stronger kidd pirates?

It would be because Shanks showed mercy that his allied fleet dies at the hands of Midd.


And since you're equating this shit to irl, take a look.


Look at what the giants are saying. If they point their weapons at them, the giants have the right to self defense. They just invoked that right.
 

Peroroncino

🅷🅰🅻🅰 🅼🅰🅳🆁🅸🅳
Bro you're treating it like its real life shit.

Manga logic works different. If shanks and co didn't do ANYTHING after KOing Kid and killer, and just let them go, who's to say that they won't recuperate and comeback and stir shit up again?

Midd pirates literally were doing that. Benn took Midd's arm off and let him go. Look what they're doing once again?

They're youngsters. shanks literally says so. They're gonna get stronger and stronger. This time, Shanks was there to protect his notoriously weak fleet. But what if he isn't there next time, against a stronger kidd pirates?

It would be because Shanks showed mercy that his allied fleet dies at the hands of Midd.


And since you're equating this shit to irl, take a look.


Look at what the giants are saying. If they point their weapons at them, the giants have the right to self defense. They just invoked that right.
shanks had already given them 2 warnings and they still returned, he knew that even after they surrendered they would just come back again and who know which civilians they'd threaten that time in their hunt for shanks.
 
oda is not an alien and neither am I. I judge shit based of real life shit

If you read a story where rape is allowed, will you be like “well awkshually rape is allowed in this world” or will you be like wtf is this shit :gokulaugh:
Wait. Must characters in a story be the epitome of civilised first world real world morality for it to be good?
 
Being arrogant and being confident are two entire different things. Most fighters are rightfully confident in their skills because of the constant training they do.
Kid has been constantly pushing himself his entire journey, fighting anybody and everybody he has to, whether it be marines, pacifista, going in to a yonko territory to fight a commander, targeting shanks, kaido, whom he lost to and had to endure being tortured in wano, and still bounced back to fight kaido again, and then defeating big mom while his body was held hostage by hawkins....his strength is totally deserved and he every right to be confident after what he achieved. meanwhile shanks has not even fought a yonko in his whole career, shanks is strong for no reason


Shanks wins because he is protecting the people of the island and of his crew.
Kidd loses because he wanted to attack and ravage, to retaliate what happened to him the last time, only for his own individualistic desire of success and vengeance.
imagine spending your whole life suffering through grueling fights and then you have to lose to someone just because they are nicer than you are. Thats just bullcrap, thats not sending any meaningful message
 
He has a realistic personality for a pirate that is trying to conquer and reach the top. If anything, hes actually way less "evil" than the average real life pirate and conqueror. Real life pirates were killing innocents just to take their stuff. Kid will only harm innocents if they have a go at him first. Or he only fight other pirates who have essentially mutually agreed to take part in the same competetion as him. That makes him both respectable but also retains a sense of realism of living the pirate life. Calling Kid a "villain" is just ridiculous. Hes only a villain if you compare him to someone like shanks, who should be part of my hero academia rather than a pirate manga
Nah brah... Real life pirates were pretty boring.... The current somali pirates are pretty dangerous compared to the pirates during golden age as they steal and kill and try to even negotiate while high with govt.
Earlier pirates were more like stealing and making a successful escape.... Many youth used to spend some years as pirate to earn some wealth and then come back to live..... The instances of hardcore violence and action was not really as much... And many used to just bribe and escape or had connections to get themselves out...
 
Top