Character Discussion Why aren’t One Piece villains as iconic and memorable as Naruto/DBZ villains?

#45
Lucci, Doflamingo, Crocodile and Katakuri are just as iconic and memorable as any of those characters you listed except maybe the Dragon Ball ones, and that'd be because Dragon Ball all but defined the genre and is infinitely more well known than both One Piece and Naruto combined, though I have no idea why you put Super Buu's irrelevant ass on this list lmao.
 
#48
Because the writer can't write great villains

Even Doffy isn't memorable or iconic

Every other major anime/manga has at least one iconic villain bar One Piece (which tells you how overrated the story is)

I'm commenting since this thread is discussing Naruto and other mangas
Doffy is pretty iconic, I knew about him as a "notable" anime villain before I even read OP.
 

Yoho

✌𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓢𝓲𝓶𝓹𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓲𝓽𝔂 𝓸𝓯 𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮✌
#50
One piece for the most part doesn't have villains at all it's mostly just been antagonist on the opposite side of the law

Really only 4 true villains maybe 5

Doffy
Kaido
Moriah
Arlong
Crocodile


All great villains in their own right
 
#51
Oda downplays his villains all the time, it makes them more believable and honestly better written in many ways, but because of this their reach outside of One Piece becomes limited.

Most iconic villains had this unbeatable aura at some point, no One Piece villain has ever had that and was able to sustain that past an introduction.
Akainu is the only villain that comes to mind but then the anime came and fucked him over
 
#52
Lucci, Doflamingo, Crocodile and Katakuri are just as iconic and memorable as any of those characters you listed except maybe the Dragon Ball ones, and that'd be because Dragon Ball all but defined the genre and is infinitely more well known than both One Piece and Naruto combined, though I have no idea why you put Super Buu's irrelevant ass on this list lmao.
Super Buu was an absolute menace
 
#53
For Dragon Ball villains, they generally have a real level and aura of threat and near-invicibility for a time that One Piece villains lack, and they are allowed to defeat, give brutal beatings and even kill the heroes.

As for Naruto villains I don't know for the others, I had stopped reading after Orochimaru, but Orochimaru was in a whole entire league of threat and fear compared to OP antagonists, I had nightmares after watching him for the first time, and he was as much as a physical threat as a psychological terror as seen with how he was able of terrorizing Sasuke and leaving deep trauma in him and other characters.

Also I don't think that Dragon Ball and Naruto downplay their antagonists like One Piece does.
Post automatically merged:

Also most OP antagonists don't have much of a dynamic and real and interesting relation with Luffy and the Straw Hats, save for Arlong with Nami.
 
#55
Because One Piece villians can't get a W if their lives depended on it (and a few cases it actually does), and most anime iconic villians actually have character connections with the protagonists one way or another. Meanwhile in One Piece most villian encounters are usually just the Straw hats pulling up on the villians' turf. It also doesn't help that whereas the villians in other mangas are direct and constant threats to the protagonists or their close ones, the ones in One Piece are usually in the background until the Straw Hats come to them.

Basically, the antagonists/villians in other mangas are usually active and serve as direct opposition to the main characters/heroes while the ones in One Piece are pretty much doing things that really don't affect the lives of the MCs, or aren't really even doing anything at all.
 
Last edited:
#56
Probably because almost 100% of the story revolves around those villains sort of.

In OP they feel like steps in the way, we always knew about 7 shichibukai and 4 yonko + admirals and so on.
 
#60
How do they know Frieza? LMAO, them knowing Blackbeard makes more sense as its based on real Edward Teach.

You are a clown who is being butthurt due to Teach scarring Shanks lmao.



Don't compare stoic shallow and weakass NT villains to the Goat.
One Piece hasn't ended yet, Teach is yet to have his own arc, he's already my fave manga villain ever, but I know when he finally makes his endgame moves he's gonna get elevated to GOAT villain status.
 
Top