I checked soul and your interaction.
Him coming out of his own will to question your pro town claim (which actually turned out to be true) seem genuine.
And, then there is one more thing - I really don't think a scum would get so proactive to lead a wagon against someone on D1 to mislynch in 50 players game.
I am not denying there can't be scum on your wagon but I think they would have casted opportunistic votes and slip in between. That's where I think we should look into