Questions & Mysteries 10 most overrated characters in One Piece history?

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#62
But he didnt say bring me a top tier marine, or he’d have said an admiral or the Fleet Admiral or Garp, he specifically mentioned those two because these two are the only ones Roger respected the strength of.
They have history. It's more personable.
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#64
What history? And again if Roger meant a top tier marine, why not just say bring me an admiral? Why specifically hype up Sengoku.

Sounds like you’re just downplaying him
Yea you're falling for that Oden bs again, characters aren't living breathing powerscalers. They have history, not to mention we don't even know who the other Admirals were by name or even if there were other Admirals at that time. The only one we know was Kong, but he was the Fleet Admiral. He's the one sending the Admirals and Vice Admirals, he's not dispatching himself.

In the same vein, Kaidou putting Oden in his top 5, does not mean Rayleigh, Mihawk etc. are weaker.

Worst case scenario you can say Sengoku was stronger than the marines of his time except for Garp. This says nothing about the mid generation.
 
#65
Just gonna say this, I do not think Oda would give Sengoku a Mythical Zoan as well as CoC just for him to be an average top tier and only equal to the Admirals, when no other Marine sans possibly Garp have those so far. Not to mention he's generally respected by a lot of characters in verse and even Roger hyped him.
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#66
Just gonna say this, I do not think Oda would give Sengoku a Mythical Zoan as well as CoC just for him to be an average top tier and only equal to the Admirals, when no other Marine sans possibly Garp have those so far. Not to mention he's generally respected by a lot of characters in verse and even Roger hyped him.
Sengoku doesn't get to be above Akainu by default, and we know Aokiji could go 10 days extreme diff with him, and Kizaru by way of C3 MF portrayal is the same.

Sengoku's in the same boat. You can def give him the nod over Fuji and Aramaki, but that's all. The others are ~ Akainu.

Lot of casuals put Sengoku over Akainu, and majority of top tiers (Shanks, Mihawk, Dragon, Kaidou etc.) simply old gen wank.
 
#67
Yea it's nothing too crazy. Just Roger saying bring me a top tier Marine, in more personal terms.

When people use that statement along with the fact that Sengoku is part of the old gen, to place him above majority of mid gen top tiers unwarranted. That's where the overrating comes from.
You’re the one downplaying this when there are canonically top tier marines that weren’t Garp and Sengoku. He said Garp and Sengoku cause those are the only two marines who could fight him.

This sounds like you just don’t like that Sengoku > Sakazuki and Kuzan
 
#70
Sengoku doesn't get to be above Akainu by default, and we know Aokiji could go 10 days extreme diff with him, and Kizaru by way of C3 MF portrayal is the same.

Sengoku's in the same boat. You can def give him the nod over Fuji and Aramaki, but that's all. The others are ~ Akainu.

Lot of casuals put Sengoku over Akainu, and majority of top tiers (Shanks, Mihawk, Dragon, Kaidou etc.) simply old gen wank.
I never said Akainu's below Sengoku lol. I just said he's likely above the others.
It'll likely be Akainu >= Sengoku > "normal" Admirals
 

ZenZu

The only one who can beat me is me
#78
WB, Roger, Shiki, Garp, and Sengoku all have better feats and portrayal as the current mid gen was put on the level of the older and weaker versions of these character…
Buddy that's a cool opinion you have, I don't care for it.
 
Top