Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Day 2]

My current suspects- York, Fushi, Flower, Butters

The first 3 because they all claimed day one unprovoked which i found unusual, in the games I've played i don't recall ever seeing someone claim day one without being asked or pushed

Butters because she seems to have 5 votes so I'm wondering why more than a hand full of people seen to think she's scum


Everyone else is null for now
This is probably a wolf for fairly self explanitory reasons. To break it down, in nearly every single game Yoho has played on worstgen or one last forum Flower was in. Flower claims every game day one unprovoked regardless of alignment. I do not think that Yoho would suddenly or spontaniously forget that. This seems like a weird conclusion for a weird read.

The read on Sundae being "they're top wagon" doesn't bode very well either
 
I AM NOT SCUM!!! I AM YORHA ALIGNED!!! 🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥
I'm thinking that the Cult Leader can recruit certain Machines with the command "BECOME AS GODS".
Alexis is fundamentally unreadable since he doesn't know how to play mafia, but the latter post is something that the cult leader or anybody culted doesn't make (comes across to much as having TMI) and the former is a fine reaction towards being pushed. Specifically saying one is Yorha aligned despite the majority of claims at this point being Machines, feel as though a scum might be a bit more wary of just being voted out due to ambiguous win conditions.

This isn't the most excellent read out their but it's one I'm making.
 
From what i read about this flavour, if I'm right that is.

Androids are in favour of humans/humanity while Machines were created by Aliens. Aliens and humans are dead but it is believed humans are alive on Moon. Machines vs Androids war is ongoing.
Idk that sounds like a townie role.

Why'd a scum lie about making his role less important by saying the abilities would still pass on?
Vote Ultra with me, he's not dimvit and wouldn't offer to vig me as town. This is not my first inactive game. No attempt at solving my slot either.​
These are Yo Tan Wa's three game related posts, neither of which bode great. The reaction to ultra pushing them was just to blatantly OMGUS them, especially when (with all due respect, it's reasonable to push you if you are not playing the game.) I think that they're unpaired from Ultra but otherwise probably lean wolf.
 
I am aligned with YoRHa(which I am assuming is town?) but I am treated as a Machine Lifeform(which I am assuming is scum) when interacted with

Going to keep my flavor to myself because its fun to make people guess. If someone guesses right I'll say so though
This is probably a town, claimed in a way that I roughly understand and the way they approached the miller claim early game:

Greetings, friends. I hate to start the game with game-talk, as opposed to fluff-talk, but I understand that it is common mafia etiquette that when one is a Miller, they must make it known at the earliest opportunity. Thus, I am making it known


Also yaaaaaaay I got my favorite (unnamed) NPC
Despite being not that true due to what the above post reads feels like they genuinly believe in themselves. Not much reads in the ISO but oh well.
 
It's just speculation as Fuji reminds me more of his Indie self from The Boys game than his Town self.

Also the amount of "lol"s.
Very fair lmfao. The only timfoil I've had on Fuji is that towning Ultra here seems super pre-emptive when I feel like Ultra is playing like a wolf (killed a town D1, admitted to thinking they were town prior, and they're now voting me) with little focus on what I normally see him doing as village (IE: Pressuring slots that actually need the pressure).
 
My brain hurts reading Ultra, Fuji, Flower, Charlie, York, and Kweh...a few decent posts in there though

Someone rolecrushed me for 2 days...when the dribble is past and some people start focusing, hit me up
Making a independent post to comment on this. I'm sure this is outing for Orca as either town or wolf, just need someone with more meta to brush me up on that. I would assume that Orca makes more hastly conclusions like lists and stuff with no progression in those lists as wolf (I'm just taking this from the one game I remember w!Orca in and the one game I remember v!Orca in.)
Suspect:
Alwaysmind
Luka
Pot Goblin
Kweh
Red Night

Gad
Indigo


Suspect adjacent
Polar
Lemon
Random hole
Tpein
Ultra
Having 12 suspects this early into the day seems okay? Like, (gosh I feel like I'm using such flimsly meta here LMFAO) but the game I remember W!Them in they had like, 5 and 2 of them were fellow wolves? I feel like theirs always some wolves in here regardless of anything else.
@The Orca can you explain bolded?

I guess I twon read Orca otherwise. The questions they asked D1 and they way they approached their reads feels to kinda in your facey to be a wolf, when as wolf they tend to from my experience stick low. Not a super strong read, largely because I don't trust in my ability to read Orca on a surface level, but I guess townier than not.
 
Very fair lmfao. The only timfoil I've had on Fuji is that towning Ultra here seems super pre-emptive when I feel like Ultra is playing like a wolf (killed a town D1, admitted to thinking they were town prior, and they're now voting me) with little focus on what I normally see him doing as village (IE: Pressuring slots that actually need the pressure).
I think Ultra is leaning too much into his crack tinfoil to be scum tho. Simply because nobody is buying it anyhow and it's largely ignored lmao.

Also can you claim your ability and flavour please?
 
I think Ultra is leaning too much into his crack tinfoil to be scum tho. Simply because nobody is buying it anyhow and it's largely ignored lmao.

Also can you claim your ability and flavour please?
Devola
Neighbor
Voting Ability
Our Cute lil bus drive ability (I do think that this ability is genuinly really thematically cool)
1x Double Action. Was going to figure out who I use it on after cleaning through ISO's

A fairly weak role, and what I consider to be largely "useless", hence why I was planning to bait the shot.
 
For the Ultra part of that role, I guess I can see a twtbaw angle? For me on a personal level it's almost like I respect him to much to think that this gameplay is coming from v!him (Even if both Him and Ratchet have a tendency to not actually try during worstgen games), but like, neh. Could just be him having fun I suppose

I would still lean scum either way tho. I won't push it if you think that they're town
 
Top