Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Day 2]

[Ultra]

Don't overcomplicate this shit, we gonna follow the mech. If nobody has anything else to bring to the table we lynch Luka. Then if he's not bad we lynch the host.

 

[Luka]

Like let's take a step back here and assess how this game apparently works - according to Polar's flipped role there is a SINGLE SCUM (or at least it looks that way, maybe it's a split role) to start the game and you can surmise that othee scum are additional conversions by whatever means

So the demand Luka is placing on "bro just solve" is inherently disingenious. He's trying to play the "let's just play normal mafia ignore claims haha"

But this isn't the game we're playing, so it's dicks

Nah, I'm not asking you to ignore claims. Let's not twist my words. I am asking you to play the game though! You have yet to give an accusation on me.

 

[KWEH]

All of you guys are tinfoilers. You're pushing me on what's possible, not probable. I fully admit that I could potentially be wolf here, if I was IC I wouldve just claimed without baiting a NK. But the fact of the matter is that my claim isn't a reason to push me.

You can also look at the Aries game as an example of me just giving up as wolf when the mech is against me. I'm not giving up here since I know I'm not wolf.

I'll dispute that you coming in here and claiming as you did when you did isn't probable in case you're scum. I also dispute that it's not probable you're Eve, given that Adams flip all but confirms that Eve exists in the game.

 

[Luka]

Don't overcomplicate this shit, we gonna follow the mech. If nobody has anything else to bring to the table we lynch Luka. Then if he's not bad we lynch the host.

What mech, you should start answering the questions Ultra! This is two innocent townies you're mischopping in a row!

 

[Random Asshole]

No idea, seems like a pretentious quote by people who wanna tell you that democracy is in danger whenever the guys they don't like win elections

That's American Politics lol

They still make those christ

Yeah I was surprised too

 

[Ultra]

What mech, you should start answering the questions Ultra! This is two innocent townies you're mischopping in a row!

You are eve and you are cooked

 

[Luka]

I'll dispute that you coming in here and claiming as you did when you did isn't probable in case you're scum. I also dispute that it's not probable you're Eve, given that Adams flip all but confirms that Eve exists in the game.

Do you have a wolf case on me yet?

 

[The Orca]

Do you want to discuss your day 1 vote? Because we can.

Let's, break it down

I mean, I directly responded as to why that was my train of thought. So no.

I say you rolecrushed me and jacked my moves and claimed them, it doesn't matter what you respond with if you continue down a terrible assumption by you with bad logic. Get back on track

 

[Luka]

You are eve and you are cooked

All of this yapping and not a single accusation

 

[Luka]

Let's, break it down

I say you rolecrushed me and jacked my moves and claimed them, it doesn't matter what you respond with if you continue down a terrible assumption by you with bad logic. Get back on track

What are you talking about
Genuinly

 

[Ultra]

Nah, I'm not asking you to ignore claims. Let's not twist my words. I am asking you to play the game though! You have yet to give an accusation on me.

Except "playing the game" in this circumstance is playing an Ekko game, and this is basically a concession that you are trying to endorse we all play like it's just your average affair, even when you know that's not a rational proposition. Because it's the best angle you got in your defense.

 

[KWEH]

No since:
1) If you're agreeing with Ultra's push (you are) I was town D1
2) You called the way I went about today towny earlier

Try a little harder.

You being town d1 is Ultras argument and it's not one I agree with. Adams flip clearly states that he'll transform at the end of n2/start of d3 at the latest, so it's likely Polar and you (if we're gonna go with the theory that you're Eve) knew that you were ultimately gonna be scum. If you already know you're gonna turn scum soon, knowing that you're town this very moment isn't something you can fool yourself with, you're gonna play scum from the start.

 

[Ultra]

All of this yapping and not a single accusation

Feeling a little hot under the collar Luka boy? You're seeing so much red you couldn't read that post. You can't fathom that you were caught by no fault of your own and that Ekko would bestow such tragedy upon you.

 

[KWEH]

Like let's take a step back here and assess how this game apparently works - according to Polar's flipped role there is a SINGLE SCUM (or at least it looks that way, maybe it's a split role) to start the game and you can surmise that othee scum are additional conversions by whatever means

So the demand Luka is placing on "bro just solve" is inherently disingenious. He's trying to play the "let's just play normal mafia ignore claims haha"

But this isn't the game we're playing, so it's dicks

At risk of raining on both of our parades, I don't think it's necessarily true that there's only one scum d1. Could be that there's a few from the start and then Adam and Eve get added soon after.

 

[Luka]

Except "playing the game" in this circumstance is playing an Ekko game, and this is basically a concession that you are trying to endorse we all play like it's just your average affair, even when you know that's not a rational proposition. Because it's the best angle you got in your defense.

What
Why am I wolf lol, I've asked this 59 times and you keep dodging the question. Point me towards what makes you wolf

At what point do I hell tunnel you for playing like you want the town to burn

 

[Ultra]

At risk of raining on both of our parades, I don't think it's necessarily true that there's only one scum d1. Could be that there's a few from the start and then Adam and Eve get added soon after.

I'm sorta getting this from the fact that Polar's role states that only the Red Girls know the wincon, which basically implies the Red Girls don't share a chat with any other members besides themself (Can't tell if Red Girls implies a singular role or two seperate ones). But who knows

 

[Ultra]

What
Why am I wolf lol, I've asked this 59 times and you keep dodging the question. Point me towards what makes you wolf

At what point do I hell tunnel you for playing like you want the town to burn

You are Eve and Eve is a wolf. QED.

?

 

[Luka]

You being town d1 is Ultras argument and it's not one I agree with. Adams flip clearly states that he'll transform at the end of n2/start of d3 at the latest, so it's likely Polar and you (if we're gonna go with the theory that you're Eve) knew that you were ultimately gonna be scum. If you already know you're gonna turn scum soon, knowing that you're town this very moment isn't something you can fool yourself with, you're gonna play scum from the start.

Your accusation on me D1 was also bad if it helps! If you scum read me with that last game you got lucky.

 

[KWEH]

Do you have a wolf case on me yet?

Why is it everybody over here insists on cases? I never case people lmao who's got time for that. I caught you d1 last game for fake looking thoughts and I think I noticed the same thing this game as well so I had you as scummy d1. You then disappeared for most of the rest of it so not much change there except other people became more pertinent, but now that you're back front and center and insisting I solve outside of the claim, the above is still something that happened.

 

[Ultra]

I say you rolecrushed me and jacked my moves and claimed them, it doesn't matter what you respond with if you continue down a terrible assumption by you with bad logic. Get back on track

Do you have mech to support this?