General & Others Who on the Mt. Rushmore for One Piece (Dead or Alive)?

#21
In regards to what?

Joyboy
Roger
Eos Luffy
Eos BB

The 4 are definitely special.
If you’re adding Joyboy why not IMU?
Post automatically merged:

Eos the top 4 that will standout:
Luffy, Teach, Dragon, Sakazuki

Past era:
Xebec, Whitebeard, Garp, Roger
I did want to put Akainu there but as Fleet Admiral what could he accomplish to put him there? He’d have to end piracy or something or start killing Yonko.
 
#22
If you’re adding Joyboy why not IMU?
Post automatically merged:


I did want to put Akainu there but as Fleet Admiral what could he accomplish to put him there? He’d have to end piracy or something or start killing Yonko.
I was simply ranking pirates in general. If everyone then yeah Imu also.
 
#23
There are a lot of loop holes in that considering that we don’t know what the One Piece is. It could have been something easy to obtain at that time.
It could be, but the fact is that the entire pirate world is fighting for Joyboys legacy. And we still feel joyboys influence as the ancient weapons were supposedly created for him seeing how Vegapunk said that the ancient weapons were created by Joyboys faction and that oden who knew the truth of the world wanted to have pluton ready for Joyboys return

The one piece and the ancient weapons are because of Joyboy. Without him, there would be no pirates.
 
#24
I did want to put Akainu there but as Fleet Admiral what could he accomplish to put him there? He’d have to end piracy or something or start killing Yonko.
Akainu’s accomplishments so far
-First (Admiral) to defeat an Admiral
-Under his leadership the marines are their strongest version ever (after existing for centuries)
I wouldn’t worry about his future achievements he’s one of Oda’s favorites
 
#28
Akainu’s accomplishments so far
-First (Admiral) to defeat an Admiral
-Under his leadership the marines are their strongest version ever (after existing for centuries)
I wouldn’t worry about his future achievements he’s one of Oda’s favorites
He’s one of my favorites, but I don’t think beating an admiral is nearly enough to get you on Mt. Rushmore. You have to do something that changes the world in my opinion.
Post automatically merged:

It could be, but the fact is that the entire pirate world is fighting for Joyboys legacy. And we still feel joyboys influence as the ancient weapons were supposedly created for him seeing how Vegapunk said that the ancient weapons were created by Joyboys faction and that oden who knew the truth of the world wanted to have pluton ready for Joyboys return

The one piece and the ancient weapons are because of Joyboy. Without him, there would be no pirates.
I take your point I’ll add him to my list once we learn more about him, if it’s warranted. The aincent weapons being because of Joyboy doesn’t make since to me. Shirahoshi is a natural phenomenon, what could Joyboy have done to facilitate her existence?
 
#30
What would your list be with everyone?
If we’re talking the entire verse then its gotta be the ones who’ve shaped the world into the state it’s in:
Imu - Created the World Government
Joyboy - Created Piracy
Lili - Separated the poneglyphs throughout the world
Roger - Created the Great Pirate Era

Without any of these four the entire world wouldn’t be anything like it is today. Genuinely I’d argue Roger is the least impactful of the four here.
 
#32
Remove Zoro and Mihawk then lol
I have Mihawk for making a black blade and being the Worlds Greatest Swordsman. I’m fine with either of them being removed for someone that is more deserving.
Post automatically merged:

If we’re talking the entire verse then its gotta be the ones who’ve shaped the world into the state it’s in:
Imu - Created the World Government
Joyboy - Created Piracy
Lili - Separated the poneglyphs throughout the world
Roger - Created the Great Pirate Era

Without any of these four the entire world wouldn’t be anything like it is today. Genuinely I’d argue Roger is the least impactful of the four here.
I don’t disagree with that list actually I just need the context from the void century. I’d still have EOS BB and EOS Luffy on the list over Roger and Lili
 
#37
You could be right about that I’ve never read the Ace novel. Is there somewhere online that I could read it? Also being the first pirate is a good point but I need more because if your the first pirate who are your competitors? I’m not saying he doesn’t belong I just want more information before I add him.
Post automatically merged:


Why Shanks?
I chose the 4 SH owners
 
Top