Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Night 6]

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Exactly

So after 3 people claimed Yorha u still thought you were a LW and 3 of your partners just outted?

 

[Flower]

In any case we are looking for scum who were already in the scum chat.

Since both Gad and Lemon who are OG scums have Machine fakes do we think they had YoRHa fakes as well to let them know the YoRHa alignment exists?

 

[Yoho]

So after 3 people claimed Yorha u still thought you were a LW and 3 of your partners just outted?

After the 3rd claim and fushi saying red doesn't necessarily mean scum, I figured it was safe to reveal myself

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Bro...he was literally protected from a lynch by scum...how is that a lucky shot, it's a no brainer duel target.

Yeah I predicted a Gad lynch N2 bc of how obvious this was. I don’t think it was sheer luck

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

After the 3rd claim and fushi saying red doesn't necessarily mean scum, I figured it was safe to reveal myself

You were still claiming machine D1 and voting York. This was after Fuji, BS, and York had all claimed Yorha I think

 

[Yoho]

You were still claiming machine D1 and voting York. This was after Fuji, BS, and York had all claimed Yorha I think

I was claiming machim up until Day 2 or 3 I had no real reason to say i was Yorha just yet

 

[KWEH]

@KWEH boo hoo can u help me understand what's going on here? im so confused boo hoo
first u complained about not wanting to claim bc u didn't do enough derusting and that u should've used it more
and u also claimed not targeting anyone besides charlie
which is fine until you say
"I only had one derust shot left".
If you only had 2 derust shots this whole time and you used 1 on n2 then why are u upset about not using your derust when you've used half your shots?
Also wasn't N3 the night of the triple NK?
Also are we supposed to believe you're actually a 2-shot deruster and 2+ shot commuter?

Myeah in hindsight that was an overstatement on my part, I felt like I messed up because it became apparent that just about every machine had already been damaged by rust and me waiting to use the second shot was a mistake

 

[KWEH]

Crying rereading d1 is just town again btw

Think I'm still happy with my solve from earlier

Vote lynch Orca

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

I was claiming machim up until Day 2 or 3 I had no real reason to say i was Yorha just yet

So wait you were either too scared to claim and thought 3 partners outted themselves until D3

OR

You got comfortable enough to claim once 3 Yorha outted and Fuji said Yorha could be town.

You can’t be both. Why? All the events in the second case happened D1 so you should be feeling that comfort starting D1 not D3. BS Fuji and York all claimed Yorha super early AND Fuji was considering 2 towns super early on I think. Unless it was Flower who said that.

Like I was also scared the machine lifeforms were mafia but once a ton of ppl claimed D1 I felt good enough to claim. I think a lot of Yorha claimed D1 too

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Crying rereading d1 is just town again btw

Think I'm still happy with my solve from earlier

Vote lynch Orca

Why is it Orca?

 

[The Orca]

Crying rereading d1 is just town again btw

Think I'm still happy with my solve from earlier

Vote lynch Orca

Explain your reads in detail please

 

[Flower]

I wished I knew Crying's MU name.

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

I wished I knew Crying's MU name.

 

[The Orca]

I wished I knew Crying's MU name.

@Crying bc no Cryo can I tell her?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

@Crying bc no Cryo can I tell her?

Fine sure go meta read me boo hoo

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Myeah in hindsight that was an overstatement on my part, I felt like I messed up because it became apparent that just about every machine had already been damaged by rust and me waiting to use the second shot was a mistake

So u regret using it N4 instead of N3 essentially or u regret commuting N1?

 

[The Orca]

@Flower it should be Pqwerty

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Dang so day really ends in 40 mins huh

 

[KWEH]

It's never Flower imo, dueling out her own teammate isn't her kinda thing I don't think. If you ask her she considers herself 5 times cleared or whatever the fuck. The only point I could somewhat give you here is the fact she's still alive seems kinda weird.

Crying I found reasons to read town along the way which I forgot by now. Him going back to reread d1 doesn't seem fake though and his constant questioning of me today also doesn't seem malicious or in search of a gotcha so happy to just say town here.

Flower made a point yesterday that Himes frustration at the modlynch seemed genuine. By now I say that something like that is easy to fake imo and compared to Crying, her questioning of me seemed more gotcha-y and less driven by logic. It's like she has all these points why I'm not scum right in front of her and she just chooses to brush em all aside and believe in fringe scenarios where I'm scum anyway instead. Then when those points whiff she goes with ahaaaa but you might be indy or ahaaa three protective roles make no sense, ignoring the fact that this is role madness and those preconceptions don't apply. Kinda don't know what to think of all this, it's annoying at best and scummy at worst.

Yoho is still a wet lettuce but I can buy the utility of his role as towny tbh.

York I frankly have no idea. Can anyone explain to me why everybody just silently agrees it's not them?

Orca I have no reason to read either way as well tbh. Can't remember a single thing he's done this game.

In summary my POE is

Hime = Orca > York > Yoho > Crying > Flower

 

[KWEH]

So u regret using it N4 instead of N3 essentially or u regret commuting N1?

I regret not using it n3 and saving the shot for a good occasion