Theory Gunkos real Identity is… her!?

Pantheos

Heavy Metal
#1
Hey Guys and Girls!

Today i want to unwrap a theory i have for a longer time, Shared it with @Tyki_Mikk often and now i am confident with it, confident enough to share it.

WHO IS GUNKO?


Kid grew up in the south Blue on a separated Island, together with Killer, Victoria and his Crew, just as Friends back then. It wasnt a rich Island as far as we know and was pretty much ruled by scum.
At some day, so the SBS, some „criminal Gang“ came up and killed Victoria, the childhood crush of Kid and Killer.

And at this point, i want to step in. I think this „criminal gang“ was the Holy Knights and the whole thing was the „Native Hunting Competition“, which we know from the Flashback of Kuma and we know from the God Valley Incident. And in my Theory, Shamrock was Part of it. He was the one who took Victoria and „killed her“ and Kid saw it. He saw the man taking and killing Victoria!

Some time after the incident, Kid build his crew and his pirate ship, the Victoria Punk. He swore revenge at the murderer of their Friends, it was his goal to take him down. Entering the sea, he pretty fast learned about higher Pirates and there he saw him in the newspaper, he saw the responsible pirate, he saw Shanks! Not knowing it wasnt shanks back then, but Shamrock. But since nobody knowd about him, he Never had a doubt on Shanks guilt. So The Hunt on Shanks began.

What came next, we all know. Leading to the attack on Elbaf. Here, Kid again attacked shanks and his Crew, fully convinced it was Shanks attacking his Island and killing Victoria. But Kid took the hardest defeat in his carreer. He lost the fight, his Crew and the Victoria Punk.

And now… it’s the time for him to come back.
Pretty similar to Luffys story:
- Luffy losing his brother Sabo / Kid losing Victoria
- Luffy builds his Crew / Kid builds his crew
- Luffy takes his biggest defeat, his Crew is gone, Ace, his other Brother, dies / Kid takes his joggest defeat, his Crew is gone, Victoria Punk, his Memory on Victoria, dies
- Luffy comes back stronger then ever, gets his Crew back together and… meets Sabo! / Kid comes back stronger then ever, gets his Crew back and… meets Victoria!

you are right, what i am saying is:

GUNKO IS VICTORIA!

Shamrock didnt kill Victoria, he took her with him. He made her a holy knight, he brainwashed her, made her forgett, like Sabo forgott his Brothers. But she will remember when she meets Kid and Killer.

Besides the Story which Matches pretty much in my Theory, there are also optical similarities.

Victoria:


Gunko:


Both have pretty short hair, arent overly feminine and seem to have some wild character.
Additionaly, Gunko hides exactly the Parts of her Face which are (in my Theory) covered by freckles, the freckles we know from Victoria. They are hidden behind bandages, which could be also a reference to Killer.


And here comes my final clue:


Gunko has a pretty obvious heterochromia and i think you can also see that in Victorias eyes. Sure, you can argue it’s just sloppy sketching, but i would be also exactly how oda loves to hides hints. I can totaly see the heterochromia in Victorias eyes too!


So, thats it.
Gunko is Victoria, the build up and resemblings are given, now lets see if oda makes it real.

What do you think about this Theory? Does it makes sense for you, or do throw it into two piece? :D

 
#4
Great theory, I could legit see a connection between Kid and Gunko if she is really Victoria.
I overall also think that this defeat was need to give Kid the right view to continue in the future.
I believe that Kid will play a huge role in the final war and also in Elbaf too.

So I can see a way to give Kid a better background build up and improve him in power and character.
 

nik87

Kitetsu Wanker
#8
:quest: Not saying this isnt possible but...
...not sure if you will get what you want from this.
Aka Kidd vs Shamrock.

Reminds me of the story of Doffy and Law...
Ultimately, it wasn't Law himself who beat Doffy.
It's just that this time, instead of Luffy, it could be Zoro.
 

Pantheos

Heavy Metal
#9
:quest: Not saying this isnt possible but...
...not sure if you will get what you want from this.
Aka Kidd vs Shamrock.

Reminds me of the story of Doffy and Law...
Ultimately, it wasn't Law himself who beat Doffy.
It's just that this time, instead of Luffy, it could be Zoro.
I don’t need Kid vs Shamrock, i need Gunko being Victoria and alive (Sabo Situation) and a monster joining Kids Crew, Loki (Jinbei Situation).
 

RayanOO

Lazy is the way
#10
Hey Guys and Girls!

Today i want to unwrap a theory i have for a longer time, Shared it with @Tyki_Mikk often and now i am confident with it, confident enough to share it.

WHO IS GUNKO?


Kid grew up in the south Blue on a separated Island, together with Killer, Victoria and his Crew, just as Friends back then. It wasnt a rich Island as far as we know and was pretty much ruled by scum.
At some day, so the SBS, some „criminal Gang“ came up and killed Victoria, the childhood crush of Kid and Killer.

And at this point, i want to step in. I think this „criminal gang“ was the Holy Knights and the whole thing was the „Native Hunting Competition“, which we know from the Flashback of Kuma and we know from the God Valley Incident. And in my Theory, Shamrock was Part of it. He was the one who took Victoria and „killed her“ and Kid saw it. He saw the man taking and killing Victoria!

Some time after the incident, Kid build his crew and his pirate ship, the Victoria Punk. He swore revenge at the murderer of their Friends, it was his goal to take him down. Entering the sea, he pretty fast learned about higher Pirates and there he saw him in the newspaper, he saw the responsible pirate, he saw Shanks! Not knowing it wasnt shanks back then, but Shamrock. But since nobody knowd about him, he Never had a doubt on Shanks guilt. So The Hunt on Shanks began.

What came next, we all know. Leading to the attack on Elbaf. Here, Kid again attacked shanks and his Crew, fully convinced it was Shanks attacking his Island and killing Victoria. But Kid took the hardest defeat in his carreer. He lost the fight, his Crew and the Victoria Punk.

And now… it’s the time for him to come back.
Pretty similar to Luffys story:
- Luffy losing his brother Sabo / Kid losing Victoria
- Luffy builds his Crew / Kid builds his crew
- Luffy takes his biggest defeat, his Crew is gone, Ace, his other Brother, dies / Kid takes his joggest defeat, his Crew is gone, Victoria Punk, his Memory on Victoria, dies
- Luffy comes back stronger then ever, gets his Crew back together and… meets Sabo! / Kid comes back stronger then ever, gets his Crew back and… meets Victoria!

you are right, what i am saying is:

GUNKO IS VICTORIA!

Shamrock didnt kill Victoria, he took her with him. He made her a holy knight, he brainwashed her, made her forgett, like Sabo forgott his Brothers. But she will remember when she meets Kid and Killer.

Besides the Story which Matches pretty much in my Theory, there are also optical similarities.

Victoria:


Gunko:


Both have pretty short hair, arent overly feminine and seem to have some wild character.
Additionaly, Gunko hides exactly the Parts of her Face which are (in my Theory) covered by freckles, the freckles we know from Victoria. They are hidden behind bandages, which could be also a reference to Killer.


And here comes my final clue:


Gunko has a pretty obvious heterochromia and i think you can also see that in Victorias eyes. Sure, you can argue it’s just sloppy sketching, but i would be also exactly how oda loves to hides hints. I can totaly see the heterochromia in Victorias eyes too!


So, thats it.
Gunko is Victoria, the build up and resemblings are given, now lets see if oda makes it real.

What do you think about this Theory? Does it makes sense for you, or do throw it into two piece? :D

You had me with the eye color in the child picture

I’m on board with this
 
#14
can’t be

The holy knights aren’t random orphans. That’s what cipher pol is for.

Holy knights are CDs and CD status isn’t just handed out. The two people who’ve been offered it: Loki and York, are highly useful assets to the WG.

No CD would adopt a random kid. CDs see non-CDs as animals. If Victoria was taken by a CD, she’d be a slave. Would tbh make for a nice plot for Kid since his character is basically tortured Luffy.
 
#15
^

This would’ve been possible if Oda didn’t confirm last chapter that Loki is the first person to even receive an invitation to the Holy Knights that doesn’t hail from a CD family

Very low chance Victoria would have a shot

Oda would have quite a bit of explaining to do in order to make this possible
 
Top