Chapter Discussion Shamrock did in one chapter what the fandom accuse Greenbull of doing

#61
It is and that isn't even deniable lmao

The guilt for crimes across all the WG is not equal, it is hierarchical and that the higher up you go, the more culpability for crimes committed goes up. Hence why a CD is more evil than a fodder Marine carrying out the CD's will

Celestial Dragons are higher than Marines including Admirals, so they are more culpable for evils committed
wg being worse doesn't make akainu's actions more understandable
 
#62
wg being worse doesn't make akainu's actions more understandable
Did you read what I wrote? Akainu is a part of the WG

Every faction's crimes are more understandable the lower they are in the chain of command, that is to say, they are less responsible

How can Akainu bear a greater guilt for some evil than the people who ordered him to do it? (keep in mind he's still guilty but the CDs are still more guilty)
Post automatically merged:

This would literally be one the worst aged threads in history if this happened
I don't think so

There's no need for a double standard
 
Last edited:
#63
Did you read what I wrote? Akainu is a part of the WG

Every faction's crimes are more understandable the lower they are in the chain of command, that is to say, they are less responsible

How can Akainu bear a greater guilt for some evil than the people who ordered him to do it? (keep in mind he's still guilty but the CDs are still more guilty)
u are acting like akainu is only evil because he follows CD :seriously:

my guy straight up melted an innocent marine cause of his own marine code but u gonna blame it on the gorosei lmfao

there is nothing " understandable " in this behavior , he is a straight up psychopath .
 
#64
u are acting like akainu is only evil because he follows CD :seriously:

my guy straight up melted an innocent marine cause of his own marine code but u gonna blame it on the gorosei lmfao

there is nothing " understandable " in this behavior , he is a straight up psychopath .
Again, one villain is motivated by an idea, the CD's are motivated by nihilism.
Post automatically merged:

I thought you meant it as "Robin, queen of bullying", remembering her bitchy attitude in Alabasta and her infamous scene with Franky, which made me imagine an EOS giant demon Robin crashing demon-form BB's balls.
We do need Robin to be a bitch again
 
#65
u are acting like akainu is only evil because he follows CD :seriously:

my guy straight up melted an innocent marine cause of his own marine code but u gonna blame it on the gorosei lmfao

there is nothing " understandable " in this behavior , he is a straight up psychopath .
Just wait for the Akainutard squad to excuse this behavior with bUt BuT it'S nOrMaL iN tHe MiLiTArY tO kiLL dEfEcToRs
 
#66
u are acting like akainu is only evil because he follows CD
"Character X is less evil than character Y"
"DURRRRR SO UR SAYING THEY AREN'T EVIL???"

No dumbass I'm saying he's less evil, not not evil. Is your IQ just that low that you're unable to grasp a statement like this


my guy straight up melted an innocent marine cause of his own marine code but u gonna blame it on the gorosei lmfao
He wasn't innocent, he was guilty of desertion during wartime which most countries punish with death

Akainu was wrong at Ohara but this was completely justified. If there is less grave a consequence then Marines will leave the battlefield
 
#67
u are acting like akainu is only evil because he follows CD :seriously:

my guy straight up melted an innocent marine cause of his own marine code but u gonna blame it on the gorosei lmfao

there is nothing " understandable " in this behavior , he is a straight up psychopath .
Execution of deserters used to be pretty common not that long ago, were the military all psychopaths?
Ordering to blow that Ohara ship was much more evil
 
#68
Just wait for the Akainutard squad to excuse this behavior with bUt BuT it'S nOrMaL iN tHe MiLiTArY tO kiLL dEfEcToRs
Desertion during wartime deserves the death penalty if not a life sentence, yes
Post automatically merged:

Akainu uses evil means to achieve a good end

CDs use evil means to achieve an evil end

Both are evil, but at least Akainu is doing it for a good like the end of piracy worldwide
 
#69
What Akainu does is cool and interesting. Simple as honestly. The Celestial dragons stuff was cool in Sabody, and the hunting games is just cringe and was introduced too late, with little plot relevance.
 
#70
-Attacks a wounded prisoner chained in seastone


-casually talks about taking children hostage to make Elbaf warriors submit


I always said that anti keep projecting the criminal behavior of their favs (like Kekdo of the 100 hostages or Bitchbeard running from a lone old Rayleigh) on admirals, and it seems like I'm once again spot on considering Shanks twin is the new golden boy of this fandom
:BigW:
Why didn’t you post the panel of Shamrock with his hands on his knees shaking that big ol’ thing when that CoC hit him
 
#73
Execution of deserters used to be pretty common not that long ago, were the military all psychopaths?
In certain wars they still do it rn :kayneshrug:
You must consider what kind of story you are reading here. This scene is used to frame Akainu's character in a particular way. In a manga for kids. He is clearly depicted as ruthless a violent, just like when he kills the protagonists older brother in front of his eyes. To say Akainu is written as a heroic character is utter delusion and denial of reality.
 
#74
Because it's completely irrelevant to my point?
Also Greenbull was never on his knees from COC, you're confusing him with Shamrock's superior lmao
I said “with his hands on his knees”. You never see a girl twerk before?:kriwhat:

And the point I was making was that, greenbull is clowned for this:


He can beat all the allegations about hostages and injured opponents all he wants, this is where 99% of his slander comes from lmao ^^
 
#75
were the military all psychopaths?
Sociopaths
Post automatically merged:

I said “with his hands on his knees”. You never see a girl twerk before?:kriwhat:

And the point I was making was that, greenbull is clowned for this:


He can beat all the allegations about hostages and injured opponents all he wants, this is where 99% of his slander comes from lmao ^^
Knee scaling? Really?
 
#76
Just wait for the Akainutard squad to excuse this behavior with bUt BuT it'S nOrMaL iN tHe MiLiTArY tO kiLL dEfEcToRs
It’s funny to me that they are slandering evil characters for being evil while stanning their own evil set of evil characters and trynna justify it .
- bro actually did what u said -
:milaugh:

"Character X is less evil than character Y"
"DURRRRR SO UR SAYING THEY AREN'T EVIL???"

No dumbass I'm saying he's less evil, not not evil. Is your IQ just that low that you're unable to grasp a statement like this
If ur dumbass doesn’t understand then I have alrdy accepted that celestial dragons are worse, I am talking abt justification and u are trynna justify akainu’s action by blaming it on his superiors .
 
#77
He is clearly depicted as ruthless a violent, just like when he kills the protagonists older brother in front of his eyes. To say Akainu is written as a heroic character is utter delusion and denial of reality.
Let me make one thing clear, Akainu isn't a hero and is still evil overall

However he is less evil than the CDs and is portrayed as much

Both Akainu and the CDs are portrayed to us as ruthless and violent, but Akainu is also doing his job, the CDs are not. Clearly he's less culpable here even if he still goes too far
Post automatically merged:

It’s funny to me that they are slandering evil characters for being evil while stanning their own evil set of evil characters and trynna justify it .
- bro actually did what u said -
:milaugh:


If ur dumbass doesn’t understand then I have alrdy accepted that celestial dragons are worse, I am talking abt justification and u are trynna justify akainu’s action by blaming it on his superiors .
Sounds like we agree then, the CDs are worse

I don't know why you're replying to me then because my original comment never justified Akainu, it merely said he is more understandable or justified than the CDs which is just true, objectively

Even if such understanding doesn't justify what he did, which it doesn't.
 
#78
In certain wars they still do it rn :kayneshrug:
You must consider what kind of story you are reading here. This scene is used to frame Akainu's character in a particular way. In a manga for kids. He is clearly depicted as ruthless a violent, just like when he kills the protagonists older brother in front of his eyes. To say Akainu is written as a heroic character is utter delusion and denial of reality.
Yeah this ruthless, but I personally find the order to blow that Ohara ship a must stronger case of Akainu being evil or psychopathic as they were actually innocent and there were kids on it.
And I don't believe Akainu is written as heroic lol, I didn't read the whole chain of replies.
 
Top