[FNZ] Role Madness Overlord Mafia Game Thread

[hime]

What's interesting about it?

felt jaguark and stargate were scummier off the bat

 

[hime]

More of a hunch, but this just seems like something she couldn't let go if she was scum. Would need to comment like this to at a minimum make an appearance of brushing it off while secretly screaming for being caught by something dumb

"hImE iS cAuGhT sCuM bC sHe StArTeD pOsTiNg At An UnKnOwN tImE tHaT sHe AsKeD fOr AnD bC sHe Is A gIrL"

 

[hime]

got any names that you think are opportunistic on his wagon?

no, not currently

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

"hImE iS cAuGhT sCuM bC sHe StArTeD pOsTiNg At An UnKnOwN tImE tHaT sHe AsKeD fOr AnD bC sHe Is A gIrL"

welp that's a pretty solid argument so i cant argue with the facts

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

can u go over why for mango and alexis?

Mango has good energy and clear intent to solve.

Alexis is more gutty than anything, I was just scummates with him he'd just ghost the thread and not do much of anything there. Not really the impression I get this game.

 

[hime]

@hime if you had any other reads aside ali
that would be appreciated

from what i read, stargate pinged me too
they seem far more interested in mechanics than thread solving
believe they were talking abt how feasible it was to kill a certain role which is pretty weird

jaguark pinged me too but on a lesser note
felt as tho that one interaction between him and flower where he was asking for a read on him was pretty awkward too

 

[hime]

not sure if you're asking for my thoughts on hime or if you're asking people what they think about both of us

in any case, i have some reservations on hime from this:


hime made this post toward ali but didn't vote him herself. it's not outright scummy by her but it gives me the vibe that hime didn't really believe she caught scum here. it rings a bit hollow. there is no spirit behind it. if im being too charitable i can consider it as hime reaction testing ali, but nothing else


fast forward after 4 players displayed agreement with her post (ratchet, flower, hayumi, lanji), hime finally votes ali. i don't like the colored parts because hime's initial post on ali didn't seem like a scum read on him, more so hime throwing a jab at him to see how he reacts - because saying "town role" isn't a strong reason to scum read someone on it's own.

in the orange colored paragraph ^, hime is acting as if her initial post on ali was a properly thought out scum read when it wasn't. hime never tried to convince anyone that ali is scummy to begin with, nor gave me the impression that she believed he was actually scum.

The red colored paragraph is a false dichotomy.

i think hes scummy for it but i dont think he is 100% caught scum
ppl agreed with my thoughts and i was fine putting pressure on him

i dont need to convince ppl that he is scummy, not sure where that is coming from
its not like i can case a player off of one word

 

[hime]

i also don't like this much. asking a question then admitting that there wasn't much reason behind it is essentially admitting to performing the hallmarks of busywork.

yes, and?

 

[hime]

vote lynch hime

going to eat, will be bk later

so whyd it take u so long to vote me from ur initial sus?

 

[Yoho]

Whats the current vote count?

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

so whyd it take u so long to vote me from ur initial sus?

was waiting for your re-entrance

pretty happy with this direction now

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

yes, and?

pretty much admitting to being scum. town doesn't willingly indulge in busywork

 

[Stargate18]

i think hes scummy for it but i dont think he is 100% caught scum
ppl agreed with my thoughts and i was fine putting pressure on him

i dont need to convince ppl that he is scummy, not sure where that is coming from
its not like i can case a player off of one word

Not got time to backread, had another busier than expected day.

I mostly made the comment because it made Mango's flavour claim seem more legitimate to me, and would explain why they weren't worried about being targeted as (presumably) a powerful town role.

(Feel free to vote me if town would prefer, though. My role is shit lol.)

 

[SoulKiller]

well i was gonna say first but i guess crying beat me to it so now i gotta ultra kill him

Vote Lynch: Hime


I am sorry that you rando'ed scum this game hime. I guess I have to put you down, and it pains me to do so. But sometimes, you have to sniff out the darkness of this world.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

i think hes scummy for it but i dont think he is 100% caught scum
ppl agreed with my thoughts and i was fine putting pressure on him

i dont need to convince ppl that he is scummy, not sure where that is coming from
its not like i can case a player off of one word

my issue with it is your initial post to ali felt like a whatever jab at him for saying the word "town role". it felt more of a reaction test than a read. you don't need to convince people or anything when making a reaction test. you didn't have a read. that's my point basically

but when 4 other players agreed with you, suddenly now you're acting as though you had an actual scum read on ali all along and are acting as though you've been trying to convince people and are surprised that people followed you very easily for what can only be a jab/reaction test

you wouldn't be surprised that the others followed you if you really think you were actually cooking. you knew you got nothing that incriminating on ali hence why it was surprising to see the others follow it.

 

[hime]

was waiting for your re-entrance

pretty happy with this direction now

fake reason
theres no reason to wait for my re-entrance to vote
u can wait for my reaction, sure, but me just getting back doesnt have any effect on whether u vote me or not

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

fake reason
theres no reason to wait for my re-entrance to vote
u can wait for my reaction, sure, but me just getting back doesnt have any effect on whether u vote me or not

mostly i wasn't that confident you're scum so didn't want to vote you prematurely and tip you off causing you to enter the thread more carefully

doesn't matter to me when i vote, but i find it more likely you'll enter while letting your guard down when im not voting you than otherwise which is exactly what you did, you addressed the most boring stuff in your re-entrance.

 

[hime]

pretty much admitting to being scum. town doesn't willingly indulge in busywork

do u think im an idiot? genuine question
feels like ur acting like this is something i wouldnt know as scum and using it as a "gotcha!"

 

[hime]

Not got time to backread, had another busier than expected day.

I mostly made the comment because it made Mango's flavour claim seem more legitimate to me, and would explain why they weren't worried about being targeted as (presumably) a powerful town role.

(Feel free to vote me if town would prefer, though. My role is shit lol.)

i still fail to see y thats of such importance to u tho

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

do u think im an idiot? genuine question
feels like ur acting like this is something i wouldnt know as scum and using it as a "gotcha!"

no i don't think you're an idiot, i think you are caught and are damage controlling.

i didn't set you up for any gotcha here, you walked into outing yourself willingly. if admitting to busy work and saying "yes, and" was sarcasm i'd say it didn't land well. i think you just don't know what to say and think that this'll make you appear brave or whatever