Role Madness Overlord Mafia Game Thread

Do you wish for Plurality+hammer option if majority of votes are reached?

  • Yes

    Votes: 9 52.9%
  • No

    Votes: 2 11.8%
  • We want to shorten this day phase to 34 hours

    Votes: 6 35.3%

  • Total voters
    17
  • Poll closed .
@Hayumi

I don't actually think this argument holds up, simply because Worst was clearly on his way out at some point, so I don't agree you wouldn't push over Ekko first to try and make that an even exchange.

Pushing over Ekko, if you assumed he's town, results in a clear for Hime who has more opportunity to actually get further in the game
It does hold up because Ekko was also on his way out tho.

If I wanted to look better purely off a flip I should have gunned more for Worst, especially when there were numbers to do so. In your world where I’m scum it’s simply suboptimal for me to want to push out Ekko in that situation if Worst’s lynching is inevitable regardless bc I’d get to look better off yeeting my scum buddy while also soft clearing Hime regardless.

Also in that same world, where scum clearly had info on Ekko via Worst targeting him, it would have been a weird choice to pick him to tie to my teammate there as it was kind of obvious Ekko was likely not flipping town.

Now mafia or indie is a different story obviously.
 
I‘m saying that Stargate was never in the best position. If Hime directs Vigs to Stargate and Stargate doesn’t die/the shots get redirected elsewhere it‘s extra KP for scum or wasted KP if he tanks it and Hime still gets cred.
You only think like this because you're ineffective as scum. That's not good scum play

Hime is clever, she knows she'll get enough mileage out of simply calling him scum, if her intention is to get credit

Specifying them as a vig target is counterproductive even in the best case scenario where you can drive a kill off, because it confirms the person in question as scum.
 
Furthermore she seemed to suspect star early as Day 1 which gives some additional credibility that it wasn't some last minute adjustment

Finally if she has a clear she doesn't need to bus that much period
 
You only think like this because you're ineffective as scum. That's not good scum play

Hime is clever, she knows she'll get enough mileage out of simply calling him scum, if her intention is to get credit

Specifying them as a vig target is counterproductive even in the best case scenario where you can drive a kill off, because it confirms the person in question as scum.
yea she would want credit for lynching /bussing him
Thinking about dofla too now cause he said he thinks stargate is good
didnt give a reason why though.
 
vote lynch Cry

He calls other people out for lacking conviction even tho he also can't stick to one person

He refuses to vote echo at all and he's off an on the vote on Worst

I think both The Worst and Echo camps should just come together and lynch this slot chances are all three are scum together
Ah here was the post

It's awful
 
You only think like this because you're ineffective as scum. That's not good scum play

Hime is clever, she knows she'll get enough mileage out of simply calling him scum, if her intention is to get credit

Specifying them as a vig target is counterproductive even in the best case scenario where you can drive a kill off, because it confirms the person in question as scum.
Let me check her scum games. I don’t really hold her scum play in high regard tbh. Maybe she‘s better as scum than I remember.
 
Let me check her scum games. I don’t really hold her scum play in high regard tbh. Maybe she‘s better as scum than I remember.
She knows enough not to do outright dumb stuff

I'm sure after she got a clear (especially if you assume Hime is town), she's going to use that position effectively. She went after Ratchet the other day when she saw an opportunity, so there's no reason to assume she'd endorse shooting her team mates over toen
 
She knows enough not to do outright dumb stuff

I'm sure after she got a clear (especially if you assume Hime is town), she's going to use that position effectively. She went after Ratchet the other day when she saw an opportunity, so there's no reason to assume she'd endorse shooting her team mates over toen
Meant to say Hayumi here
 
Top