Bougya To the "Shanks/Roger sword attacks doesn't cut therefore they are not a swordsmen" troupe

[HerreraIsBack]

Learn how to read the fucking manga

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Big Mom is not a swordsman just like Kaido is not a CLUBman or WB a Spearman, simple as

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Big Mom is not a swordsman just like Kaido is not a CLUBman or WB a Spearman, simple as

Kaido is a clubman. Whitebeard is a spearman.

 

[Blazing Lion]

If you fight using a sword then you are a swordsman.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

If you fight using a sword then you are a swordsman.

Then luffy is a swordsman?
[automerge]1752764088[/automerge]

Kaido is a clubman. Whitebeard is a spearman.

Shame that these things are your headcanon and not written in the manga eh?

 

[HerreraIsBack]

Shame that these things are your headcanon and not written in the manga eh?

So what they are? What Luffy is? What Garp is? The only "class" that exist in One Piece is swordsmen or no class at all.
[automerge]1752765122[/automerge]

Then luffy is a swordsman?

He didn't fight with swords. He used it once against fodders. Not his fighting style.

 

[shastar-sei]

She uses Napoleon as a longsword and has a named technique: Ikoku.

There are also combination techniques that use Napoleon in its bladed form: Happy Mother's Blaze, Mama-Raid, and Maser Saber.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

So what they are? What Luffy is? What Garp is? The only "class" that exist in One Piece is swordsmen or no class at all.
[automerge]1752765122[/automerge]

He didn't fight with swords. He used it once against fodders. Not his fighting style.

He fought with a sword against Oars, my dear.
He appeared with a sword on a volume cover, and wielded a graded sword.
Luffy is a swordsman, for the same reason WB is, as YOU said ,a spearman, who only fought fodder with a spear.

 

[Blazing Lion]

Then luffy is a swordsman?
[automerge]1752764088[/automerge]

Shame that these things are your headcanon and not written in the manga eh?

Yes and Zoro is not a swordsman, he is an MMA fighter.

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Yes and Zoro is not a swordsman, he is an MMA fighter.

Zoro fights with swords, hence a swordsman like Luffy, what do you mean? Why are you upset that Luffy is a swordsman?
[automerge]1752768557[/automerge]

So what they are? What Luffy is? What Garp is? The only "class" that exist in One Piece is swordsmen or no class at all.
[automerge]1752765122[/automerge]

He didn't fight with swords. He used it once against fodders. Not his fighting style.

BTW, Luffy on the ropes used swords against Arlong, clearly a swordsman since in distress he went for swords.

 

[Blazing Lion]

Zoro fights with swords, hence a swordsman like Luffy, what do you mean? Why are you upset that Luffy is a swordsman?
[automerge]1752768557[/automerge]

BTW, Luffy on the ropes used swords against Arlong, clearly a swordsman since in distress he went for swords.

Who said I was upset, I just told you facts, Zoro himself said that he would bite throat to win a fight, he has punched and kicked a lot too as well as grapple so he cannot be qualified as a swordsman anymore.

 

[Rukusho]

A swordsman is someone at their strongest is with a sword, picking up a sword for giggles doesn’t make you a swordsman.

Big Moms strongest technique is with a sword, I dub her a swordsman(women).

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Who said I was upset, I just told you facts, Zoro himself said that he would bite throat to win a fight, he has punched and kicked a lot too as well as grapple so he cannot be qualified as a swordsman anymore.

Why not? according to Pederrera using a sword while fighting is what qualifies a person as a swordsman, Zoro without his magic tools is Franky tier so he is a swordsman 100%.

 

[Blazing Lion]

Why not? according to Pederrera using a sword while fighting is what qualifies a person as a swordsman, Zoro without his magic tools is Franky tier so he is a swordsman 100%.

Why should I accept anyone elses definition of what a swordsman is?

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

Why should I accept anyone elses definition of what a swordsman is?

I answered your message:

If you fight using a sword then you are a swordsman.

Luffy fights Arlong, Oars and on Wano using swords, he is a swordsman.

 

[HerreraIsBack]

He fought with a sword against Oars, my dear.
He appeared with a sword on a volume cover, and wielded a graded sword.
Luffy is a swordsman, for the same reason WB is, as YOU said ,a spearman, who only fought fodder with a spear.

When he had 100 shadows that was explicit showing the techniques of the shadows users....

 

[Salah WG]

Anything you do with a Sword is Swordsmanship.

 

[Blazing Lion]

I answered your message:

Luffy fights Arlong, Oars and on Wano using swords, he is a swordsman.

You referenced I think Herreras definition in the previous message.
Yes when Luffy fights using a sword he is a swordsman. When Zoro fights without a sword Zoro is not a swordsman. How is that difficult to understand?

 

[HerreraIsBack]

BTW, Luffy on the ropes used swords against Arlong, clearly a swordsman since in distress he went for swords.

Cope as you want

A swordsman is someone at their strongest is with a sword, picking up a sword for giggles doesn’t make you a swordsman.

Big Moms strongest technique is with a sword, I dub her a swordsman(women).

How about Aokiji and Kizaru? Aokiji does have an ice saber. Kizaru uses his light sword against Rayleigh.

Anything you do with a Sword is Swordsmanship.

Like pee?

 

[Sword God Ryuma]

Cope as you want
[automerge]1752769632[/automerge]

How about Aokiji and Kizaru? Aokiji does have an ice saber. Kizaru uses his light sword against Rayleigh.
[automerge]1752769657[/automerge]

That makes no sense
[automerge]1752769672[/automerge]

Like pee?

No like swird attack idiot.